Why Not an Immigrant President?

Why Not an Immigrant President?

I was born in Peru but have lived in New York City since I was 6. It has become my home. Even though I don’t plan to run for president, it would be nice to have that option. But the Constitution states that only native-born citizens of the U.S. are eligible to be president.
Nation of Immigrants
Now Senator Orrin G. Hatch, a Republican from Utah, wants to change that. He has proposed a constitutional amendment in which immigrants who have been citizens of the U.S. for at least 20 years and residents for at least 14 years would be permitted to run for president. In the House of Representatives’ version of the amendment, immigrants would have to be naturalized citizens for 35 years instead of Hatch’s 20 years.
“Ours is a nation of immigrants,” Hatch declared to the Senate upon presenting his amendment. He is a friend of Arnold Schwarzenegger, who came here 35 years ago from Austria.
Not surprisingly, the actor-turned-governor-of-California supports the amendment. He told The San Francisco Chronicle that “times have changedâthere are so many people here in this country now from overseas who are immigrants who are doing a terrific job.”
Immigrants hold high positions in government. For example, Jennifer Granholm, a native of Canada, is the governor of Michigan; the U.S. Secretary of Labor, Elaine Chao, is from Taiwan; and Representative Tom Lantos (D-California) was born in Hungary. Immigrants have also served in the armed forces; Congress has awarded 700 Medals of Honor to foreign-born soldiers.
Second-Class Citizens
Immigrants who want to become naturalized citizens must endure a slow and difficult process. My mother is in the middle of applying for citizenship. She has long and tedious forms to fill out, endless fees to pay and an exam on the history of the nation to pass.
With such clear evidence of immigrants’ loyalty and love for America, why should we continue to be excluded from the presidency of this country? Noah Feldman, an assistant professor of law at NYU, told The New York Times that keeping immigrants out of the White House is “creating, in a way, a kind of second-class citizenship.”
When one becomes a citizen, that’s it-you’re a citizen. There shouldn’t be a difference between the treatment of natural-born and naturalized citizens.
But the Constitution can’t be changed without a great deal of public support. In order for a constitutional amendment to be passed, two-thirds of both the House of Representatives and the Senate must vote in favor of it. Then the amendment has to be approved by three-quarters of the nation’s 50 state legislatures.
History of Distrust
Experts agree that the immigrants-for-president amendment will be especially challenging because the U.S. has a tradition of distrusting immigrants’ political loyalties. After all, the framers of the Constitution included the “natural born” clause because they were afraid that an immigrant president would be more loyal to his home country than to the U.S.
During World War II, the government made Japanese residents of the U.S. leave their homes and live in internment camps. More recently, in the wake of September 11th, the Justice Department has held some immigrants for months without charging them with a crime.
I hope that the public (and more politicians than Hatch) will overcome this kind of suspicion of immigrants. Someone who has gone through the rigors of becoming a citizen and has lived here for 20 (or 35) years, as the proposed amendment requires, deserves a chance to run for president.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.