Names have been changed.
During my first chemistry test at my new school, Stuyvesant HS, I was surprised to find the guy sitting next to me glancing over at my paper. It took me a moment to realize what he was doing.
“No, he’s not cheating,” I thought. “He’s so smart.”
But on the second test there was no denying it. He was clearly looking at my paper.
He wasn’t the only cheater. After the first test, a girl in my class discussed it with me in the gym locker room.
“Did you hear papers rustling during the test?” Anne asked me.
“No.”
“Oh, thank goodness! I had my notebook open under my desk and I was so nervous when the teacher was walking around the room,” she said.
Typical Teenage Activity
Naively, I asked why she did it. Anne looked at me curiously and wrinkled her brow as she just shrugged it off. Cheating-a typical activity that teen-agers engage in. No need to dwell on it.
I, on the other hand, was shocked and appalled. I couldn’t believe that a person would cheat on one of the first tests of the year. Talk about starting off on the wrong foot. What offended me most, though, was Anne’s indifference to cheating.
But I soon learned that Anne’s view on cheating was not unique. The student union vice president at my school was forced to resign last fall after she was caught cheating on a chemistry test.
‘Everyone Cheats’
For many students, what was controversial was that she had to resign, not that she cheated. While riding the school’s escalator, I overheard a student saying he thought the decision was unjust. “I bet that if you ask anyone in this school, they’ll tell you that they’ve cheated before,” he said.
His thinking seems to be that if the majority does something, no matter how dishonest it is, it should be accepted.
And it’s not only at Stuyvesant. After talking to students from several New York City high schools, I discovered that cheating is an accepted part of our academic life.
One South Shore HS senior said, “Cheating is bad, but when it comes down to either cheating or going to summer school, I’d rather cheat.”
All the students I talked to felt like the guy on the escalator: that cheating’s acceptable because almost everybody does it.
“Everyone cheats every now and then,” said one John Dewey HS sophomore.
“It’s not something to be proud of, but like everyone cheats,” said a sophomore at Brooklyn Tech HS.
Too Much Pressure
Why do so many teenagers cheat? For starters, we’re under a lot of pressure to perform. From the time we’re young, many of us are bombarded with the idea that doing well in school is the surest way to guarantee a successful future.
According to a sophomore at Abraham Lincoln HS, many students fear that “their parents, friends, or teachers will be disappointed” if their grades don’t measure up. Many also worry about the effect their grades will have on their college acceptance or ability to get scholarships.
Others are simply worried about passing the class and graduating on time. As a friend from Stuy put it, “Almost all the people I know and have known through school didn’t care about ‘remaining on top.’ They just wanted to pass and get out of school.”
An Image to Keep Up
And others feel pressure to cheat because to them, grades are indicators of success, accomplishment and character. They think that by getting high grades, students show the world they can measure up to an ideal.
The Brooklyn Tech sophomore said he sometimes cheats because he doesn’t want “to be looked upon as a below-average or unintelligent individual” by doing poorly on a test.
Competition is another reason why some students cheat. For overachievers, every digit and grade counts.
In schools like the one I go to, where grades in the 90s are common, many may feel the need to cheat to keep themselves one step ahead. As the guy who cheated in chemistry explained, “In a competitive academic environment, one needs to take every advantage they can get.”
When I transferred to Stuyvesant from LaGuardia HS, I’d expected competitiveness, but I was caught off guard by the attitude toward grades. Earlier this year when transcripts were handed out, I saw my peers scramble to find out each other’s averages, down to the decimals.
People I barely knew casually asked me what my transcript average was, oblivious to a little something called manners. The obsession over grades even made people resentful towards the highest scorer on a test. But it was the amount of cheating that bothered me the most.
I thought it was strange that cheating seemed even more rampant at Stuyvesant than at my old school, LaGuardia, a school where admission doesn’t involve sitting through a two-and-a-half-hour written test. I assumed that since Stuyvesant’s population was filled with skilled test-takers, they would have less of a need to cheat.
1980 Regents Scandal
But after hearing stories from other schools, I’ve come to believe that cheating goes on everywhere. It probably just seems worse at Stuy, because everyone is so grade-obsessed, they talk about it all the time.
Cheating at Stuyvesant, as at schools across the city, is nothing new. In his book ‘Tis, former Stuyvesant teacher Frank McCourt, who started teaching at the school in 1972, writes about his attempts to discourage his students from cheating.
And in June 1980, Regents exam answers were available around the city before the exams were given. Stuyvesant’s former underground newspaper, Voice, ran a story about the Regents cheating scandal. The students’ reasons for cheating then sounded just like those of today’s students.
My friend Sarah, a good student with a strong work ethic, is not someone I would have expected to cheat. But one day, joining me at the usual table during lunch period, she announced: “I just had a quiz in Spanish.”
Then she added, with a laugh, “I cheated through that whole thing.”
Her carefree attitude irked me, so I asked her why she did it.
“It’s Spanish,” was her explanation.
Hold on there. What makes it more acceptable to cheat on a Spanish test than, let’s say, a math test? Sarah explained that sometimes people don’t prioritize studying for something like a small Spanish quiz when there are more important things, “such as family issues or a larger term paper or exam.”
Many students who don’t cheat all the time feel that it is “OK” to cheat in certain situations, although how they determine that is complex.
Fear of Getting Caught
Some people believe that when a test really counts, students won’t cheat because the consequences of getting caught are too high. One friend from Brooklyn Tech doesn’t cheat on major exams like the SAT or major subject tests” because of this.
Students might also cheat in a class that isn’t being taught well, out of spite, or in a class that they view as too easy, uninteresting or unimportant to bother studying for. Others cheat on the subject that is hardest for them.
The ‘Tests Are Unfair’ Excuse
With so much emphasis on tests and grades, it’s no surprise that many students don’t see learning as the priority. Tests require students to know many specific details that don’t reflect our deeper understanding, and many of the details won’t stay with us.
This justifies cheating for many, like one Stuy sophomore who said that it’s all right to cheat when “you just can’t seem to remember a specific name or date.”
Even though I still think cheating is wrong, I too am starting to feel the pressure to take the cheater’s way out. The demands of high school and being a teenager are so overwhelming at times that I don’t get to study for a science or history quiz. Cheating becomes the more appealing option when the other choice is to fail.
Are Stricter Rules the Answer?
What can be changed so that cheating is not the more appealing option? When I started writing this article, I believed that less emphasis should be placed on tests. Students I talked to agreed that lessening the pressure is the way to go, but schools take the route of stricter rules and harsher punishments.
At Stuyvesant, the administration is working on a committee to “promote academic honesty” by establishing guidelines for academic integrity-and by enforcing the penalties for breaking the rules.
That may discourage cheating, but I’ve realized that I’d still be unsatisfied because it’s not so much the cheating that bothers me but the disregard for integrity. That happens in other ways, too, like when we “kiss up” to teachers.
I don’t see how that can change. Even if academic cheating is decreased, people will still continue to cheat themselves by faking their way towards their goals. They may achieve their aims, but they won’t have deserved them.
SIDEBAR
Cheating Made Me Feel Guilty
Since I think cheating’s wrong, I never thought I’d do it. But I did. One day, my teacher sprang a pop quiz on us for a chapter I hadn’t read. Since my teacher told us it didn’t really “count” (I suppose it was just to make sure we read it), I didn’t worry too much. Also, it seemed logical to me that if I hadn’t read the chapter, then I shouldn’t do well on the test. Simple as that. But then something happened. I realized that I could easily do well on the quiz without doing the obvious look-at-the-person’s-paper-next-to-you form of cheating. My teacher read the questions and choices out loud, so all I had to do was watch the students who had read the chapter and when they put their heads down to write the answer after the correct choice was read aloud, I’d do the same.
Impulsive Decision
My decision was impulsive. At the moment, it seemed stupid not to take the opportunity to do well when it was so easy. It also didn’t help that other kids in my class weren’t taking the quiz seriously. Towards the end of the quiz, however, I was hit with a pang of guilt. My teacher noticed someone and said, “No, don’t cheat! [Sigh.] Well, I won’t say who it was, but it certainly changes the way I see that person.” Guilt Tore at Me I don’t think it was me he was talking about, but the prospect of having someone I respected think less of me was devastating. After the quiz, I scolded myself for cheating. I felt like I’d violated the moral standards I’d set for myself. I was also in the middle of writing the cheating story, so I felt like a hypocrite. The guilt tore at me. I thought, “Oh, no. I’ve become one of them: those out-of-touch Stuy kids who’d do just about anything for a grade.” But was it really the unbearable possibility of failing a test that made me cheat? Thinking about it now, I don’t think that was it for me. It was just how easy it would be to get the right answers without much risk of repercussion. The chances of getting caught and being penalized for it seemed slim. Now I know better, though. There are repercussions-just not those that I had been worried about. Doing well on a quiz is not worth the anxiety and guilt I felt. If I had the opportunity to do that again, I wouldn’t, not even if I was unprepared. I’d rather have a clean conscience than a perfect test record.
A Nation of Cheaters
Teens all over the U.S. cheat. In a 1998 nationwide survey of high school students by the Josephson Institute of Ethics, 70% said they’d cheated on an exam within the past year. That didn’t even count cheating on things like homework and reports. And 45.2% agreed that “a person has to lie or cheat sometimes in order to succeed.” Despite that, 97% of the students surveyed thought that it’s important to “be a person with a good character” and 91% were “satisfied with [their] own ethics and character.” Go figure.
