During the Republican National Convention, and the weekend before it, hundreds of thousands of protesters took to the streets of Manhattan. Nearly half a million people marched on Sunday, August 29, to protest the war in Iraq, and many smaller groups gathered that week to voice their anger at President Bush’s policies and to voice their support for such issues as legal abortion, gay marriage, immigrant rights, jobs and civil liberties.
On Wednesday, September 1, a group of Stuyvesant HS students organized a demonstration to protest what they saw as Republicans using the events of 9/11, which many New Yorkers feel is a personal trauma, to promote their political party and to justify the war in Iraq. Stuyvesant HS is a few blocks from where the twin towers used to be. I talked to some of the students at the demonstration.
Hannah Barber, 15
What motivated you to come here?
“I just think it’s not really cool that the Republicans keep on coming back on 9/11, using it for their advantage.”
What are you trying to accomplish? Do you think protesting can make a difference?
“I’m trying to send a message to all the people who can hear us out there. I think protesting can make a difference to those people standing here. If politicians could see this and understand it, it would be amazing.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“The war used to bother me most. Now it’s the small things, like blatantly being against gay rights.”
How do you feel about participating in this event?
“I think it’s really cool that we can all come together for the same cause. I wasn’t actually at Stuyvesant at the time, but I still feel it affected me.”
Have you protested before?
“I’ve been to a bunch of protests. The best was the Sunday one simply because there was so much representation and you knew you were making a difference.”
Jess Pinkham,18
What motivated you to come here?
“I’m mainly pissed off at [former mayor Rudolph] Giuliani. I think he’s coyly using 9/11 to run for president in 2008.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“I’m concerned with the way money’s being spent. Social services are being cut for this big partisan party.”
How do you feel participating in this event?
“I’m proud of the students who started it. It was good seeing someone take the initiative. It’s good to be back in the spotlight for something we want to get attention for.”
Have you protested before?
“I’ve been doing stuff every day. I’ve done the March for Women’s Lives [across the Brooklyn Bridge on Saturday], United for Peace and Justice [the big Sunday march], Economic Human Rights Campaign [on Monday]. Yesterday [Tuesday] I checked out the day of direct action.”
Sam Shapiro, 17
What motivated you to come here?
“Since 9/11 I feel scared for my own personal safety. I feel the attack on 9/11 was not intended for me but for the crazy government.”
Do you think protesting can make a difference?
“I don’t think protesting can make a difference. It’s never really accomplished anything, because no one wants to listen until the situation is way too far gone. But I think protesting serves as a warning.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“The bills being passed in Congress since 9/11. I’m so pissed off by the suppression of peace done by the FCC [the Federal Communications Commission, which regulates radio and broadcast TV programming]. I hate the Patriot Act [see explanation on previous page]. It’s a blatant violation of the Constitution. In Abu Ghraib, it was all mercenaries, something paid for with all our money. I also hate the lying, the constant lying. I feel like if nothing else, Kerry would be honest. He would just say,’I’m going to bomb Iraq.’ “
How do you feel about participating in this event? “It feels good that I’m not the only one shouting.”
Have you protested before? “I did a couple of walk-out protests before the war started, like the one that got broken up in Washington Square Park.”
Zoe Thomas, 15
What motivated you to come here?
“I feel that Bush is exploiting what happened on 9/11 for his own gain.”
What are you trying to accomplish? Do you think protesting can make a difference?
“I think we’re just trying to send the message out that the students aren’t going to stand for this. I think protesting can make a big difference.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“Mostly, the war. I think a lot of our finances and taxes are going to the war. Frankly, I’m a little afraid of the Republicans. I’m afraid of what they’re doing to the country. I’m more scared of them than of the terrorists.”
How do you feel participating in this event?
“It’s a good feeling that we’re all here for the same cause. There are no conflicting views. Each time you do a protest you get more passionate for its cause.”
Have you protested before?
“I did one yesterday (Tuesday, August 31). I did protests before the war. The biggest one was in Washington, D.C., to prevent the war from happening.”
Kathy Szymkoqiak, 17
What motivated you to come here?
“I don’t agree with 9/11 being exploited and us students being used as a political platform.”
What are you trying to accomplish? Do you think protesting can make a difference?
“We want to make the people aware that we don’t agree with what they’re saying about 9/11. I think protesting can make a difference. Not everyone supports Bush and there’s always two sides to a story.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“The exploitation of 9/11. It bothers me that they don’t care about the people, but about money and taking over the world.”
How do you feel about participating in this event?
“These are all my classmates, and so it feels good that we can all come together.”
Have you protested before?
“I’ve been to other protests, against the war in Iraq.”
Kate Garaufis, 19
What motivated you to come here?
“I feel that it’s wrong that Bush is coming here to have a party to benefit New York City, but the convention’s actually making it the same lock-down city it was right after 9/11.”
What are you trying to accomplish? Do you think protesting can make a difference?
“I think some people here aren’t from New York City. Maybe them seeing us young students will make them think twice about what’s being said about Bush. If we make one person think twice, it can make a difference.”
What issue concerns you the most?
“Bush’s lack of concern involving minorities, like gay rights and women’s rights.”
How do you feel about participating in this event?
“I’m glad that we could come together and show some people how we feel.”
Have you protested before?
“I did Critical Mass on Friday [Critical Mass is a monthly group bike ride to celebrate bicycling as environmentally friendly and to urge safer streets for bikes-that day’s ride added protests against the Republicans], the big march on Sunday. I was vaguely involved with direct action [on Tuesday].”
Why Are You Protesting?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.