Why Are the Regents Failing Us?

Even though a lot of people hate math, it’s one of my favorite subjects and I’m good at it. Last year, my sophomore year at Harry S. Truman HS, I was in class every day on time, did all my homework, and passed every test with a 95 or above.
I never had a problem with math till I took the Math A Regents in June. I got a 55.
Most students in New York State must now pass the Math A Regents to graduate from high school. That’s why many people in my math class last year were seniors, even though it was a sophomore class. Some of them had failed the math Regents once or even twice.
Seeing people repeat the grade over-and listening to people who’d already taken the Regents talk about how hard it is-made me panic. Still, I felt more prepared for the Math A Regents than for the other Regents I had to take. I even had extra help from my math teachers every day after school.
But while I passed my other Regents, I still failed Math A.
Other Test-Takers Walked Out
I thought the multiple-choice part of the test was kind of easy. But then I got to the short answer part. Most of those questions were hard; they hadn’t ever been taught in my class.
One of the questions asked us to use a compass. In my school, students aren’t allowed to bring a compass because it’s metal and has a sharp point. I remember my elementary school teacher using a compass to draw circles, but I’d never used a compass for any kind of work in class.
Some people gave up, leaving the room almost as soon as they got the test. I myself couldn’t believe I’d find a math test so hard. At first I thought it was my teacher’s fault, which made me mad.
But afterward as I went through the textbook we used in class, I didn’t see any lessons related to several questions that were on the test. Then I didn’t know whose fault it was.
Only 25% Passed
It turns out that the June test was one of the hardest math Regents ever, and I wasn’t alone in failing it. Of the 38,329 kids in New York City public high schools who took the test, only 25% passed. Statewide, 37% passed, compared with 61% last year.
The June physics Regents was hard, too. Statewide, 33% of students failed the exam-three times more students than failed the year before.
Students weren’t the only ones complaining about this year’s Regents. Teachers, parents, principals and superintendents spoke out, too. Some teachers and school administrators on Long Island said that, unless changes are made, they’d boycott the physics Regents next year and refuse to give it to their students.
It’s Official: Too Hard
The New York State Council of School Superintendents published a report online explaining why they thought the June 2003 Math A Regents was unfair.
They wrote that the test included math that students hadn’t been taught and that some questions, especially the word problems, were confusing.
Other questions, the report said, were at the pre-calculus level and “certainly beyond the scope of the Math A curriculum.” (The Math A test is usually given at the end of 10th grade.)
The superintendents’ council recommended that the test not be included in students’ course grades. The council also recommended that the test shouldn’t keep seniors who failed it from graduating.
A week after the exam, New York State’s education commissioner, Richard P. Mills, announced that the test results wouldn’t count.
Eleventh and 12th graders who failed the Math A Regents in June 2003 would be allowed to graduate without having to retake it, but freshmen and sophomores who failed, like me, would have to take the Math A Regents over.
New Grades-I Passed!
Then, at the end of August, the State Education Department recalculated the test scores. They adjusted our 2003 scores to look more like the results of the June 2002 Math A exam, so many students who originally failed the June 2003 Regents now passed it.
My 55 is now a 69, so I passed. Now I won’t have to retake the exam.
Unlike Math A, the scores of the June physics Regents weren’t canceled or changed. Students don’t have to take the physics Regents to graduate, though they do have to take one science Regents-and the Math A.
I’m glad the Department of Education realized the problems with the math test and changed the scores. But the fact that they gave us that test at all shows how our high schools and the people making the Regents exams are out of touch with each other.
Tests Should Reflect What We Learn
I still think it’s OK that we have to take the Regents. The Department of Education needs to know if we’re learning enough.
Besides, students in 19 other states have to take standardized tests to graduate from high school. Just because the tests have different names doesn’t mean other students don’t have to take them.
But if we’re going to be expected to pass a standardized test, then that test should reflect the things we learned in class. I don’t know how we’re supposed to pass the Regents when the textbooks we use don’t have problems like those that are on the exam.
My School Does Math Differently
In my high school, teachers use a creative math curriculum, IMP (Interactive Mathematics Program), that’s supposed to help us understand how math is useful in real life. For example, in my freshman year IMP1 class, we spent nearly half a semester on “The Overland Trail,” which was about families going on a journey and the number of items they could bring along with them.
I learned interesting things about math in that class, and I had great teachers. They made sure we understood every topic they taught, and they even stayed after school to give extra help.
The problem is that the “real life” math we learned my freshman year didn’t look much like the problems on the real life math Regents.
Most of what they taught in my second year math class (IMP2), like the Pythagorean theorem, did show up on the Math A Regents. IMP3 has even more material that’s on the Math A test.
It would make sense if we took the math Regents at the end of year three. Maybe by then we would’ve learned more of what the state expects us to know, even if we learned it in a different order.
Something’s Got To Change
But whether it’s the Regents exams or the classes, something’s got to change.
Many of us students are trying hard to learn what we need to know, spending lots of time on homework and studying. The Department of Education should try harder to find out what we’re being taught and make fair exams based on that. Or, if they’re not going to change the tests, the schools should change what they teach us.
Schools should also make things fairer by separating the Regents exam from the class grade. Student grades should reflect how we did in class-test scores, attendance, class participation and homework-not on an outside test. If students pass the class and fail the Regents, we should still get the credit.
However they do it, the Regents need to be made fair by testing students on what we’ve learned and not what we haven’t.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.