What’s the Real Graduation Rate?

I went to a panel discussion recently about New York City’s high school dropout problem at the New School for Management and Urban Policy. I was surprised to learn how low the graduation rate is-just over half of New York City high school students graduated on time (within four years) in 2004, according to the New York City Department of Education (DOE).
But I was even more surprised to learn that this number included students who didn’t actually graduate.
When the DOE calculates the graduation rate, they include not only students who actually graduate, but also those who left school and got their GED. Out of the 36,339 students who graduated on time in 2004, 1,812 of them, (5%), got their GED instead of finishing high school.
Should GEDs Count?
I was confused to learn that the DOE counts GED recipients as graduates, because the federal government doesn’t. Under the federal No Child Left Behind Act, getting a GED isn’t the same as graduating.
Lawyer Daniel Losen, a panel member from the Civil Rights Project at Harvard University, said it was wrong of the DOE to count GED recipients among the graduates, because it makes the graduation rate look higher than it actually is.
Need to Know the Numbers
There’s controversy about the high school dropout rate, too. The dropout rate for the class of 2004 was 16.3%, or 10,922 students, according to the DOE. But the DOE defines a dropout as a student who has been in high school for at least two years before they stop going.
That means that a teen who drops out anytime between the first week of 9th grade and the last week of 10th grade doesn’t count as an official dropout.
Losen pointed out that the DOE is about to change this so that you only have to be in school for five months before leaving to be counted as a dropout.
But it made me wonder, how many students from the class of 2004 dropped out in 9th or 10th grade? I wondered if the actual number of dropouts might be much higher than 10,922 students.
One thing is clear. No matter how you measure it, everyone agrees that too many teens don’t graduate on time and some are struggling even in their first year of high school.
To help them, we need an accurate count of how many kids graduate, how many get their GED and how many drop out.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.