What’s the Point of Gym?

An Interview with Lori Benson, Head of Phys Ed for NYC Schools

To find out the real purpose of gym-and why we have to wear that horrible uniform-I decided to go to the top. I spoke to Lori Benson, the Citywide Director of Fitness and Physical Development for the New York City Department of Education.
-Danielle Morganstern
NYC: What’s the point of gym?
Lori Benson: The point of physical education (PE), you mean. “Gym” is just the name of the room. The point is for students to become more physically active and, hopefully, embrace activities they’ll want to continue through their lives.
Quality PE experiences can only have a positive influence on students. A physically active person can reap the benefits in the mental and social world as well. It’s important to find an activity that makes you feel good about yourself. I’m not even talking about for health reasons, but for personal enjoyment.
NYC: How did you feel about PE as a teenager?
Benson: I’m really glad you asked that, because I wasn’t the most athletic person and I didn’t like team sports much. I wasn’t that good at them. I was a good dancer, I liked to play tennis-I liked the individual type activities.
Also, I was pretty overweight as a kid. So I did feel the pressure of being socially ostracized. I didn’t want to change in front of friends because I was heavier than most of them. But it was part of what you had to do.
Dancing and being involved in movement always made me feel good about myself, though. Really, I had to find the activities that made me feel good.
I remember in high school I was so excited to get into the weight room. Since I was on the swimming team I was allowed to take weight training. I’d never tried it before and that just made me feel so proud of my accomplishments. I think that really started my whole career in the fitness industry.
But I have some not so great memories too. I think it’s important that we try to create more wonderful memories for students when it comes to PE.
NYC: Do many kids fail PE in New York City?
Benson: It varies from school to school. And, just so you know, PE is a graduation requirement only at the high school level, not necessarily in elementary and middle school. From what I understand, the main reason students fail PE is, frankly, because they don’t get dressed.
NYC: Many students don’t like to change. Why do we have to do it?
Benson: I can understand. It’s difficult changing in a locker room in front of your peers. And I think a lot of that stems from the fact that many students don’t have the opportunity to do that in elementary and middle school. So now all of a sudden the child is a young adult and being asked to change in front of his or her peers. It can be an uncomfortable, semi-threatening atmosphere.
But to be able to really participate in activities, to be able to move well and safely, kids need to wear sneakers and appropriate clothing. There isn’t a formal uniform policy, but students have to be prepared to participate in a safe, orderly environment.
NYC: Your job is new. Why was this position created?
Benson: For many years, the city’s Department of Education didn’t have a central office to support PE. In 2003, the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene did a study looking at the height and weight of more than 3,000 elementary school students. They found that 43% of our elementary school students are either overweight or obese.
So now we have this tremendous issue of childhood obesity, and one of the things the Department of Education can do to combat it is provide better quality physical education. I think that helped create my position in August 2003.
NYC: What other steps has the Department of Education taken to improve PE in New York City?
Benson: In addition to my position, there’s now a regional director of fitness and physical development in 10 regions of the city with 100-150 schools each. So there are 10 of these wonderful, dynamic people thinking about PE 100% of the time.
NYC: What kinds of changes are these regional directors working on now?
Benson: One big thing is dedicated professional development. Non-PE teachers have 200 minutes of this each month, during which they’re trained in other areas of their curriculum.
But for years PE teachers didn’t have professional development. Other teachers got together to do literacy and math, but no one was conducting workshops for PE teachers on things like the latest stretching techniques or ways to assess students’ fitness levels.
That’s changed. As of this September, the regional directors host regular trainings for teachers and assistant principals. So they can share their issues and say, “Listen, we have an issue with changing at my school. What do you do in your school? What are some of your strategies to get students motivated?” It really builds a community, and is rebuilding the culture of PE.
NYC: Is there a formal PE curriculum?
Benson: In the past, it was up to each school to decide what they do. But now we do have a curriculum, called “Physical Best.” It focuses on the health-related aspects of PE.
We’ve also selected a tool to assess students’ fitness levels, called the “Fitness Ramp.” It assesses their aerobic fitness, muscular strength, flexibility, and body composition. It actually develops a computer report that goes to students, and we’re working on a report that goes to parents.
Also, when students get to high school they’vebeen doing the same old thing in PE for 10 years already. We need to think about the element of choice for high school students. They may be interested in aerobic dance or volleyball. They should have the opportunity to explore those skills further.
Not everyone’s going to be a basketball player. Not everyone’s going to play soccer. But some people might find their niche through another activity, and it’s our responsibility to provide those other activities.
NYC: Are there any plans to improve PE equipment in schools?
Benson: Right now, we’re trying to find out what schools have and what they don’t. Some schools have a few gyms, a weight room or a dance studio. But some schools don’t have any huge area like that.
we’re also looking to develop partnerships with organizations in the community, like the YMCA and Bally’s, so that if a school doesn’t have facilities, there can be a relationship with a place nearby that does.
For example, Bally’s just adopted Theodore Roosevelt HS. Instructors from Bally’s are going to come and support the PE program at Theodore Roosevelt. All the students are also going to have the opportunity to go to that Bally’s down the street and work out there for free.
NYC: Could this be a solution to the overcrowding problem many schools face?
Benson: Empowering students to do independent studies with gyms and other organizations in the neighborhood is an interesting strategy. It’s definitely something we’re going to pursue. Not just with one school, but with many schools. If PE isn’t going to happen within the building, we have to figure out a way for it to work outside the building.
NYC: Do kids have any say in the changes you’ve been talking about?
Benson: I think it’s important for kids to have a voice. I’d urge students to become more active on their student council and student government. They should bring their issues to the school administration and say, “Hey, we love yoga. we’re all about lifetime fitness. But I’m done with basketball and soccer. I really want to study yoga, but there’s only one class available and it doesn’t fit into my schedule. Can we have more selections available?” Students have a very powerful voice, and I urge them to send their message to the school administration.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.