Would you make a deal with a company that offered you $100,000 for simply signing a piece of paper? Maybe you’d guess that there must be a catch. But I bet you wouldn’t expect to end up with tap water so toxic that it catches on fire.
” Gasland ” is a documentary that reminds us not every deal is as good as it sounds. The film is about people across the country who say they’veexperienced the negative side of hydraulic fracturing. Hydraulic fracturing, or hydrofracking-or often just “fracking”-is a process of removing natural gas or oil from underground rock by drilling into the earth. The process injects water, along with chemicals and sand, into the earth at pressures high enough to fracture the rock.
Whether oil and gas companies should be allowed to “frack” is controversial. On one hand, there is evidence that it can harm the environment and people’s health. On the other side of the debate are those who say that fracking is attractive because it harvests natural gas, a fuel that creates less pollution than oil or gasoline. They also say fracking will reduce the price of gasoline and America’s dependence on oil from foreign countries.
One of the largest potential sources of natural gas in the United States is the Marcellus Shale, which stretches from New York to Pennsylvania, and south and west into West Virginia and Ohio. “Gasland” came about after Josh Fox, a filmmaker, received an offer of $100,000 to lease his family’s land, which was on top of the Marcellus Shale in Pennsylvania, for fracking.
The property was a place of great natural beauty-acres of grass, trees, and wildlife, alongside a log cabin where Fox spent most of his childhood. Fox uses footage of the place he calls home to show his audience the beauty of unaltered nature. He didn’t take the $100,000, but he did begin researching what fracking really is and investigating its dangers on camera.
Hairless Cats and Flaming Water
Fox began by trying to telephone officials from the large oil companies involved in fracking in Pennsylvania-such as Haliburton and Chesapeake-for comment. Getting no results, he took his camera and headed to Dimock, Pennsylvania to talk to people who live with hydrofracking on or near their land.
He found that these people had a lot of complaints about fracking, including medical complaints. One significant concern regards the chemicals being injected into the ground to break up the shale. Companies don’t have to disclose what these chemicals are, but scientists have determined that they number in the hundreds, and some of them are known to be toxic. This raises concerns that the chemicals may leak into underground sources of drinking water. There are also fears that radioactive substances underground, and the extracted gas itself, are leaking into water supplies.
One resident’s tap water turned brown and had a metallic taste, while the cats and horses she owned began losing their hair. She said that a representative from Cabot Oil and Gas, the Houston-based company fracking near her home, suggested that telephone poles in her area caused the animals’ hair loss, though her cat was an indoor cat. Another complaint came from a man who demonstrated for Fox’s camera how he could light his tap water on fire. He had his water tested and found that it was contaminated with natural gas.
Acting on Fracking
Fox then traveled to Colorado, Wyoming, and beyond to talk to affected families, government officials, and environmental experts about the dangers of fracking. It’s not just drinking water that’s jeopardized, he discovered. Collection tanks at fracking stations release toxic vapor into the air, while people nearby suffer from headaches, dizziness, and a loss of smell and taste. This process also leads to acid rain, which can kill plants and wildlife. Some meat farmers living near the tanks suggest that the pollution will contaminate their beef.
The film concludes with footage from a meeting at which oil company executives and members of the United States Congress in Washington, D.C. debated the safety of hydraulic fracturing. This hearing came after three members of Congress introduced the Fracking Responsibility and Awareness of Chemicals (FRAC) Act in 2009. The FRAC Act would require oil companies to publicly reveal the chemicals they use for fracking.
During the meeting, company representatives insisted that the chemicals used for drilling are perfectly safe. If that’s the case, countered Congresswoman Diana DeGette, a Democrat from Colorado, then why don’t you want to tell the public what they are?
It was good to see congressional representatives standing up to the executives on behalf of people who might be endangered by fracking. Yet though this hearing exposed how secretive oil and gas companies are, the FRAC Act has yet to be passed.
New York Weighs the Risks
It’s difficult to estimate the dangers of fracking as long as companies don’t have to tell what chemicals they’re using. Industry representatives say that there is little evidence directly linking fracking to water contamination.
However, in its interviews with knowledgeable experts and real people telling their stories, “Gasland” presents a convincing argument that fracking is harmful. And the New York Times recently reported on the case of a well contaminated by fracking chemicals that was documented by the Environmental Protection Agency. (Apparently, in many other suspected cases of contamination, landowners sued oil and gas companies and the legal settlements prevented researchers from getting access to information that might have proved contamination happened.)
Right now, our New York City drinking water is some of the cleanest water in the country-but maybe not for long. The city’s water supply comes from a watershed upstate, which provides 15.6 million people with its well-known drinkable water. It’s the largest unfiltered water supply in the world. Since 2008, fracking has not been allowed in the state, but officials are reviewing this policy and may change it soon.
That’s because state lawmakers face political pressure over fracking. Despite environmental risks, the gas trapped in rocks under our feet holds the potential to boost business and lower the price of gas, a major consideration in this recession.
Governor Andrew Cuomo wants to lift the ban, and this summer the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation, which is controlled by the governor’s office, released a report recommending that fracking be allowed with certain restrictions. (For example, it would not be allowed within 2,000 feet of a reservoir or within 500 feet of a private well until more studies are done on the potential dangers.) The report will undergo a period of public comment and debate that’s sure to be heated.
A Warning Voice
Even if certain restrictions help to protect New York state water supplies, “Gasland” shows how the health of those who live near fracking sites is sacrificed for the sake of getting access to oil and gas. We should also remember that if it ruins large tracts of land and contributes to widespread air pollution, wildlife devastation, and other environmental hazards, fracking is ultimately a threat to humans everywhere.
In my opinion, Fox gave a voice to the voiceless about this topic. The film uses personal stories to promote a clear message: Say “no” to fracking! Fox encourages viewers to use his website ( gaslandthemovie.com/take-action/ ) to find anti-fracking organizations, get contact details for elected officials, and band together against fracking.
The $100,000 he was offered to allow fracking on his family’s land might sound like a lot of money, but I don’t think the trouble fracking can cause is worth any amount of cash. Taking the audience on a cross-country road trip from Pennsylvania to the center of Texas, Fox revealed the dangers that we may face if hydraulic fracturing comes to a town near us.
What the Frack?!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.