Just a few weeks ago, a woman from Tampax came to my 11th grade science class to hold a question and answer session about sex, sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and sexuality. She was in her thirties, with blond hair and glasses, and spoke in a serious tone.
Anyone who had questions for her was free to write them on a piece of paper, crumple it up, and put it in the glass jar at the front. She spent the period pulling questions out of the jar and answering them.
Some of us had serious questions, like “How is HIV transmitted?” But sometimes what she said just made the class burst out laughing. In the middle of a discussion about hygiene, for instance, she said out of nowhere, “If I have one piece of advice for you girls, it’s this: don’t douche.” The class cracked up.
It was clear that not everyone took the lesson seriously. One piece of paper that she dug up asked the question, “How do you like it?”
“I’m not answering this,” she said.
Despite all the kidding around, though, I’m sure everybody learned something. For example, I was surprised to learn that most college students who were tested for STIs had some form of genital warts.
But overall, the class felt awkward. At the end of the period, one kid jokingly yelled, “I douche my ass!” before scattering with the rest of the crowd.
A Serious Policy Debate
I’m sure that this kind of silliness is fairly common in sex education classes around the country. Looking back on my earlier sex ed experiences, all I can remember is a classroom full of laughing boys watching cheaply produced instructional videos about puberty and self-esteem, featuring skits about kids trying to hide their sheets from their parents after having a wet dream.
I didn’t think that I learned much of anything. For people who have had similar experiences with sex ed, it can be hard to imagine why anyone takes this stuff seriously.
But even though we may laugh about-or at-sex education, there’s a serious battle going on in capitol buildings, principals’ offices and PTA meetings over what kids should learn in school about sex: Should schools prepare us for being sexually active, or should they teach us only “just say no” to sex?
Learn About Contraceptives or Not?
“Just say no” education programs teach that abstinence is the only surefire way to avoid contracting an STI or getting pregnant. These programs don’t explain anything about contraceptives or birth control (except their failure rates), or about using condoms to prevent spreading STIs. Often, supporters of abstinence-only programs have religious reasons for believing that teens shouldn’t have sex before marriage.
Comprehensive sex education covers both abstinence and contraception (birth control methods). The basic idea of comprehensive sex ed is: “Young people should wait to have sex, but if they don’t, they should use birth control and practice safer sex.”
Bush Pushes Abstinence-Only
The battle between the two approaches is being fought at every policy level, from individual schools up to the federal government. President George W. Bush has made it clear which side he’s on.
Since Bush became president three years ago, the federal government has significantly increased the amount of funding for abstinence-only education, while programs that distribute money for comprehensive sex ed programs aren’t getting enough funds.
“When our children face a choice between self-restraint and self-destruction, government should not be neutral,” Bush told a church audience in February 2003. “We must promote the good choices.”
But not everyone in the federal government thinks that abstinence-only is the “good choice.” Congressman Henry Waxman, a Democrat from California, says that President Bush is ignoring public health by pushing abstinence-only education. Waxman believes that it’s better to teach teens how to protect themselves from disease if they choose to have sex.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is the federal department that gives out money for abstinence-only programs, but the people who work there don’t necessarily support the president’s position, either. “We don’t have a choice,” Kevin Ropp, press officer of HHS, told NYC. “We do what the president and Congress tell us to do.”
A Matter of Values
Supporters of abstinence-only education claim that telling kids how to practice safe sex encourages sexual activity. They say that teaching us how to use contraceptives shows us that it’s OK to have sex outside of marriage, which they say encourages the wrong values.
They also argue that no sex is safe sex. “Eight thousand young people a day are contracting [STIs] because they listened to the safe sex lie,” said Leslie Unruh, president of the Abstinence Clearinghouse. Abstinence-only programs like hers stress the failure rates of contraceptives.
It is true that the STI statistics for teens are grim. Out of the more than 15 million people who catch sexually transmitted infections each year in the U.S., about 4 million are teenagers (roughly 25%). But most people get these infections because they don’t use condoms when they have sex.
Science on Their Side
Supporters of comprehensive sex education argue that science is on their side; there is no evidence that teaching kids about birth control makes us more likely to have sex. Instead, they argue, when teens have accurate and balanced information about STDs, pregnancy and contraceptives, we can make wise decisions and protect ourselves.
In the United Kingdom and Canada, where sex ed is comprehensive, teen birth and abortion rates are about half as high as in the U.S.
“Considerable scientific evidence shows that programs that include information about both abstinence and contraception help teenagers delay the onset of sexual activity,” said Rebecca Wind, a spokesperson for the Alan Guttmacher Institute, an organization that focuses on sexual and reproductive health research.
‘Smut Degrades the Mind’
But science aside, the battle over what to teach in sex education has a lot to do with the messages adults think teens are getting about sex from the world around them-and the messages they think teens should get.
With so much emphasis on sex and sexiness in popular culture, “Millions of young people are desensitized to nudity and illicit sexual behavior,” Unruh told NYC. “Thoughts are the seeds of action. Government studies have proven that smut and illicit sex degrade the human mind.”
She and other abstinence-only supporters say that their programs give kids the self-esteem they need to say no to sex. Meanwhile, they argue, comprehensive sex education is a bad influence on children who need to gain control of their sex lives, because the lessons are based on the idea that teens have sex.
Better to Give Teens Information
Supporters of comprehensive sex education believe that it’s better to give young people the information they need than to try to hide that information. As for self-esteem, they argue that’s more likely to come from feeling more comfortable with your body and knowledgeable about your choices.
Guidelines for the abstinence-only sex education programs that get federal money say that these programs are supposed to teach that “sexual activity outside of marriage is likely to have harmful psychological and physical effects.”
But opponents of abstinence-only education argue that even if this message frightens teens into practicing abstinence, it’s also more likely to make them ashamed to plan for sex-which many end up having even if they have conflicting feelings about it.
“Teaching teens that abstinence until marriage is the only way to protect themselvesâfails to provide them with the information they need to act responsibly and protect themselves when they do become sexually active,” Wind told NYC.
In a recent university study of teenagers who formally pledged to abstain from sex, teens who took the pledge and then broke it were significantly less likely to use contraceptives than teens who hadn’t taken the pledge in the first place.
Same Goal: Fewer Pregnancies and STI Cases
If there is one thing that both supporters of abstinence-only and comprehensive sex education agree on, it’s the goal of lowering the rate of teen pregnancy and slowing the spread of STIs among young people, especially HIV/AIDS.
According to the Alan Guttmacher Institute, not only do 4 million U.S. teens get an STI every year, but nearly 900,000 teenage women accidentally become pregnant. In addition, on average, two people in the U.S. under age 25 contract HIV every hour.
Will abstinence-only education lower rates of sexual activity among teens, or just leave us ill-prepared to practice safe sex? Was the woman who visited my science class doing us a service or was she putting us in danger?
As far as I could tell, nobody left the class any hornier than when he or she came in. Many of the people in the room are already sexually active anyway, so trying to shelter them couldn’t do much good.
Teens can only act responsibly when we’re informed. It is important that we receive a balanced and accurate sexual education.
What Should Teens Be Taught About Sex?
Just say no' or'be prepared'?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.