“It’s usually a humiliating experience… She’s, like, on a different dimension-she doesn’t understand how we can’t understand what to her seems so simple.”
-Mary, 15 (not her real name).
“In math, it’s really just drill work and if you don’t get it, then you just don’t, and there’s no way to make it fun. At least, it was never made fun for me.”
-Jessie, 17.
“In this society, a lack of success in math is alright, it’s acceptable! The U.S. is very young and it has a `frontier’ mentality… American heroes are men of `action,’ not men of thought. So, it’s not looked down upon that you’re not a thinker-in fact the opposite is the truth! I’ve seen some African-Americans [to whom] learning is a `white’ thing… that’s a bad attitude. To say that learning is `square’ is a recipe for disaster.”
-Henry Jackson, math teacher, Brooklyn Technical HS.
Why is it that students in the United States rank far below students from other countries in knowledge of math and science?
Why is it that 48% of 11th graders in one of the greatest countries in the world can’t even complete a basic algebra problem?
The situation at the present time is becoming increasingly desperate, and it may become even worse-by the year 2000, nearly everybody will need some basic math and science skills to enter the work force.
If you don’t have those skills, then you’re probably headed for the unemployment line or a low paying job.
And without an adequate education in math and science, who will be the doctors, engineers, and researchers of the future?
What’s going on? Why are our futures being placed in such jeopardy? And who, or what, is responsible?
Told They can’t Learn
No one is saying that math or science is easy. It took me a year and a half before I could finally finish and pass algebra. Many students are in the same situation.
Many kids are frightened of math and science-and feel that they can’t do well in them because they are either “stupid” or, in the case of many “minority” students, because they are Black or Hispanic.
But, according to George Leonard, an 8-year veteran of the science teaching staff at Boys & Girls HS in Brooklyn, the real reason “a lot of minority students feel they can’t learn is because, a lot of the time, teachers give them the impression that they can’t learn.”
Let’s think about that for a second. It doesn’t just apply to minority students in the so-called “Inner city” either! There are many different ways in which a student can be lost forever…
Peter, a 17-year-old from Brooklyn, said: “I had one math teacher who was actually a Spanish teacher. My chemistry teacher was a retired police officer-it was his first year off the force. Another one of my math teachers was a basketball coach. I don’t think any of them understood really what they were doing.
“And, in most cases,” he continued, “they would just say’I really don’t have to be teaching this, so if you don’t want to learn it, then I just won’t bother.’ The idea was that they weren’t going to go out of their way to force anything on you, so if you weren’t willing to pick it up the first time around, then you just didn’t get it.”
Mary (not her real name), a 15-year-old girl in a Manhattan high school, had this to add: “In the 7th, 8th, 9th grade… I don’t think that they [basic math/science concepts] were adequately covered. I think that if you don’t have the basics, you can’t really expand on anything.”
Teaching Only Part of the Class
Michael Johnson, executive director of the Science Skills Center in Brooklyn, observed that among some teachers there is a “sifting” attitude, rather than an “opening” attitude-in other words, the teacher teaches only those students in the class who already have a basic knowledge of the subject and ignore the rest, instead of teaching so that everybody will learn.
According to Michael Johnson: “They want to teach to the’converted.’ “
Jessie, 17, confirmed this: “I’ve had some teachers that are very good at what they do, who know what they are talking about, and are very good with kids who catch on quickly-but, they don’t seem to have very much time or patience for kids who need to back up or do slower work.”
Peter continued: “They were like, `This way is the only way in my class-there are other ways, but I don’t want them done here,’ which doesn’t prepare you for what’s going to happen later on-but it makes them happy. Usually, what they want is the easiest possible method to grade. The one that they don’t have to put any work into grading.”
When describing a former math teacher, Anthony, a 17-year-old from a Brooklyn school, said that, “He wasn’t above belittling a student, or being insulting.”
George Leonard went on: “They’ll teach at a rate where the students can’t keep up, and then when the students don’t do well and their grades are low, the teacher reprimands them in a way where it makes them feel like it’s their fault. And then the student believes, `Well, maybe I can never get this…'”
Henry Jackson, a math teacher for 19 years who currently teaches at Brooklyn Technical HS, had this to say: “Making the class interesting, that always helps. I remember my teachers that were boring-and I don’t remember a thing I learned. I just remember that they were boring.”
Can It Be Different?
In the school system, there are many teachers like the ones that have been described above-impatient, incompetent, spiteful, unqualified, perhaps prejudiced, and definitely boring-who are in the system year after year and who have destroyed the minds of countless students.
The reasons why these people are bad teachers are, perhaps, unimportant-maybe they were once good teachers who have “burned out,” maybe they were that way to begin with… it doesn’t matter.
Something that does matter is that there are a fair amount of good, dedicated, qualified and caring teachers-teachers like George Leonard and Henry Jackson.
Neither one set out to be a teacher-Jackson majored in economics in college, Leonard wanted to become a doctor-but they both found that teaching was something that they enjoyed.
Both are involved at the Science Skills Center in Brooklyn, an after-school program which teaches students the finer points of science and mathematics. And both have a great deal of concern and love for their students.
“Part of being a good teacher,” said Jackson, “Is simply respecting your students as people, respecting their abilities… That’s what I enjoy, the idea of bringing light to someone else-setting up a situation where they can discover further insight for themselves. Rather than telling them, you want them to discover… It’s better than just writing down a list of rules and formulas for students to copy and memorize.”
George Leonard recalled that, “When I was in school in Harlem, education was really poor there. It didn’t prepare me for college… for high school! I struggled as a student -I noticed that I missed certain things from my teachers. So, becoming a teacher has allowed me to give back a little bit that I lost as a student.”
Relate It to Their Lives
Jackson continued: “The hardest thing about teaching math is getting students to see that it’s not some gift that you are born with. It’s an acquired skill-it’s really an art. And art can be mastered.”
When I asked Mr. Jackson what his approach to teaching was, he said, “The thing is to relate math to their everyday lives,’cause they think that math is just something that you do in school and that you don’t need it on the outside-it’s just an abstract exercise… Show them the new concepts, but also show them why they need the new concepts, and that tends to help them retain things better.”
George Leonard added: “My approach is against the norm-I don’t follow the calendar that my supervisor gives me… you can’t teach a class based on a timetable-because then you’re rushed!’If the students understand, if they don’t, it doesn’t matter, you just go on’-I don’t believe in that… I believe that’s hurting the overall goal. I don’t move on’till every student understands, and I mean every student.
‘Crazy Into Biology’
“Teachers should demand that students learn, demand that students do homework, demand that students understand-be more dramatic!” Leonard continued. “Pound on a table… wake ’em up! Be all into the lesson… so they realize,’God, he’s into it! This person is crazy! Crazy into biology!’ And then maybe they’ll be crazy too… Instead of using the same approach in teaching that brings about failing grades, obviously you have to change your approach!”
“When you have high expectations for the students, you’re going to work a lot harder, and the students respond to it,” said Jackson.
We need more teachers like Jackson, Leonard, and Johnson to inspire young people to inquire, seek answers, and learn science and math-but the sad truth is that, at the present time, such teachers appear to be at an all-time low.
And if this is the case, more and more students are being condemned to a tragic fate-a fear and hatred of math and science. Unless steps are taken soon to put the situation right, we as a nation will soon reap the awful consequences.
“Teachers are so quick to say, `Those students can never learn! There’s no way they can learn, so I just teach them the basics!’ ” said Leonard. “When you have fixed in your mind that a student is not going to do well… then you’ve already lost. Get out of teaching!”
Next month: New approaches to teaching math.
What Did You Learn in Math and Science Class Today?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.