(Some names have been changed.)
Last July, The New York Times reported a recruitment slump for the armed forces in recent years due to higher-paying civilian jobs and a higher college attendance rate. According to government officials, fewer young people were viewing the military as a career.
Nonetheless, I still know people who are signing up to join. I even found myself deliberating over whether I should join the military after high school. I wondered what prompted other teens to join.
Derrick, a 17 year-old Latino, recently joined the Marines after receiving his high school diploma. He’s now taking part-time college courses at home through the military’s program.
Derrick didn’t like regular classroom environments, which is partly why he decided to become a Marine. “Ever since I was little, sitting in classrooms has made me restless. I simply don’t think that the classroom is for me, and I got my C-average to prove it,” he said. “If I weren’t in the Marines, I’d probably be working some half-ass minimum wage job.”
College Plans Thwarted
Eddie, an 18-year-old originally from Trinidad, had hoped for a traditional college education, but now plans to join the Marines after he graduates high school.
“I don’t even really want to join the Marines,” he said. “I just want some money to help my family, and a good-paying job for the future.”
Eddie started thinking about joining the Marines a couple years ago when his family began having financial trouble.
Eddie had plans to go to college, but they were thwarted by his family’s financial woes. He found himself even more discouraged when he was rejected by his top two college choices and accepted to two other schools that offered him chump change for financial aid.
Unhappy About Marines
After talking to a friend who recently joined the Marines, Eddie saw the military as the most promising solution for a successful future. The Marines guaranteed his friend a $13,000 salary per year for the minimum four-year enlistment along with food and housing. And he’ll get $50,000 for tuition.
Despite the benefits, Eddie isn’t happy about joining the Marines, but feels like he has no other choice. “I don’t think that being in the military will be such a great experience. I hear that a lot of physical and mental abuse goes on there,” he said.
“I remember seeing one particular news story on television where newcomers to the Marines had to have pins ground into their chests for initiation.”
So is the military the only option for teens who feel like they can’t or don’t want to go to college right away? According to Mary McNiff, a career counselor at Erasmus Hall HS, the military isn’t necessarily the first choice for students who fall off or choose to leave the academic track.
“Students, who for whatever reason, don’t think that they will succeed in college almost always seek full-time work instead of joining the military,” she said. “But the ones I know who do join always join for financial reasons. Most of them want to go to college but they don’t have the money, and want to use the military in order to continue their education.”
McNiff said this is where many students have the biggest misconception about the military. They think that the military is recruiting them just to send them through college, and underestimate how much time they’ll spend providing their services to the military.
Can’t Leave Until Contract’s Up
According to some military personnel, being in the armed forces makes finding time for school difficult.
Gary, a 28-year-old African-American who was enlisted full-time in the Army for four years, joined the Army to use it as a vehicle to college. But “after about a year of being in the service, I wanted to leave, because I wasn’t able to spend enough time on my education, and it felt like I was forced to stand still when I was supposed to be moving,” he said.
“The problem was that I couldn’t leave because I had signed a contract agreeing to serve for four years.” To leave the army without finishing your contract is known as a dishonorable discharge, and you can end up in jail.
Serious Commitment
According to Gary, “When you get a dishonorable discharge, many employers will frown upon it, so, in other words, you’ll be blacklisted, and it will be very difficult to find a jobâ regardless of your reason for leaving.”
Hearing Gary’s experiences made me realize how serious a commitment the military is. “People who try to escape doing well in school by dropping themselves in the Army will most likely not be successful,” said 26-year-old Army reservist Felicia.
She joined the military two years ago in order to develop her nursing skills after earning a Bachelor’s degree. “The Army is not a place for joking around and it’s not a shortcut either,” she said.
For instance, in order to make it as a licensed practical nurse in the Army, you have to pass both written and practical exams as well as a grueling physical training test. She knows of recruits who’ve had to repeat the program or were told to find an alternative track, such as being a cook, because they failed exams.
Recruiter Talked Benefits
Information like this was glossed over when I visited my local Army recruiting office to learn more about what potential full-time recruits should expect. The recruiter told me that the Army has 240 jobs to select from and guarantees $50,000 for college or $65,000 to pay back existing college loans for a four-year enlistment, in addition to a minimum salary of about $13,000 per year.
In addition, you can get life and house insurance, and health care benefits for you and your dependents while you’re active.
But I kept in mind that recruiters’ jobs are to sign up as many people as they can, so it’s only logical for them to tell you the military’s benefits rather than include its drawbacks.
Recruits Detailed Drawbacks
For instance, Gary pointed out that recruits with some college background usually get better positions than those who join straight out of high school.
Gary also said he had a hard time making ends meet with his pay of $14,000 a year. “It may sound like a big deal to a teenager, but a $14,000 per-year salary, even with all the benefits, isn’t really that much,” he said. “I had to send money home [to Brooklyn every month] to support my son, which included food, clothes, and baby-sitting fees, and money to help pay for where my girlfriend and him were living.”
And there’s always the possibility of ending up in a combat situation for those who become soldiers.
Gary spoke of troops in the Gulf War who now suffer from Gulf War Syndrome, with symptoms such as tiredness, convulsions, breathing problems, pain, numbness and psychological dysfunction.
The causes of the mysterious illness are not clear but may be linked to the medical shots the troops received, smoke from oil-burning fires, stress or chemicals that affect the nervous system, like pesticides.
And, of course, in any combat situation, there’s the risk of death.
If you don’t want to join the military but like the idea of training or service, McNiff said you might want to consider volunteer and internship programs.
Counselor Recommends AmeriCorps
She recommended AmeriCorps, a national volunteer program that allows people to earn money for education in exchange for one year of service. AmeriCorps members choose among projects like teaching children to read, building affordable homes and responding to natural disasters.
AmeriCorps members get a modest living allowance, health insurance, student loan deferment, and training. After serving their year, they get a $4,725 education award to help pay for college.
After finding out more about the options I have besides the armed forces, I decided not to take the military route to get my education because I don’t think I’d be content. (See my sidebar.)
Others who have chosen the military are happy with their decisions. Felicia is proud of her choice because she feels the Army has allowed her to develop professionally and personally. Derrick feels similarly about the Marines.
“I don’t think that being a Marine is so bad except for when the sergeants yell in my face or force me to do tedious tasks,” he said. “But other than that, I think that it will earn me respect from everyone.”
Weighing the Military Option
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.