Earlier this month, President Obama met with lawmakers who have been working to change U.S. immigration rules. Obama is pushing for a bill that includes a way for the nearly 11 million people living in the country illegally to become U.S. citizens.
It’s a controversial issue. Some people are against all immigration, and I wonder if they realize these immigrants are their fellow human beings. The millions of undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. all have a story and a reason for being here. Recently, I saw a documentary called La Americana, in which one young filmmaker, Nicholas Bruckman, tells the big story of why people immigrate through the experiences of one woman who came to the U.S. illegally.
Financial Necessity
In 2000, Maria del Carmen Rojas’s entire life is flipped upside down when her 9-year-old daughter Carla becomes paralyzed from the waist down after being hit by a bus. Carmen is a struggling single mom in Bolivia, the poorest country in South America. There is no way that she can earn enough money to pay for the kind of care her daughter needs.
Carmen applies for a visa to work in the United States, where she could earn much more than she could in Bolivia. But it doesn’t work out (it’s very hard to get a U.S. work visa). So Carmen decides to travel illegally to the U.S., where she’ll be able to make more money to provide for Carla’s ongoing medical care and education. The documentary follows Carmen’s long, difficult journey from Bolivia to New York as she searches desperately for a way to support her daughter.
The film makes a powerful statement about American attitudes toward illegal immigration and the hardships that cause people like Carmen to sacrifice the things most precious to them in order to support their families back home.
Carmen leaves Carla in the care of her own mother, a sad parting Carmen describes to the camera. Then she explains in great detail how she crossed the border. It is a very dangerous and expensive journey, where one is always prone to being caught by U.S. border guards. Carmen first goes to Tijuana, Mexico, to arrange the trip. From there, she’s smuggled behind the back seat of a woman’s car. She says that she nearly suffocated, staying in such a tight, enclosed space for hours. But she makes it across the border undetected.
From there, Carmen goes to New York City to become a cleaning lady in designer retail stores and wealthy homes. This allows her to make a steady income that supports Carla back home-many times what she’d be able to earn in Bolivia.
Guilt and Sadness
Carmen is overcome with guilt about being absent from her daughter’s life. But if she did go back to Bolivia to visit, she wouldn’t be able to return to the U.S. unless she were smuggled back in again through Mexico. So Carmen only gets to talk to her daughter by telephone. It was painful to watch Carmen break down in tears when she talks about how much she misses Carla and the rest of her family.
When the film begins, six years have passed since Carmen arrived in New York. The U.S. Congress is considering an amnesty bill that would give long-time undocumented immigrants the chance to stay in the U.S. legally. This gives Carmen a temporary hope of being able to return home to visit Carla. However, the bill is not passed, and Carmen’s sadness and disappointment grow.
As Carla’s 15th birthday approaches, Carmen is overwhelmed by the choice between staying in New York or returning to Bolivia to be with her daughter. Finally Carmen decides that even though she hasn’t saved up as much money as she’d hoped to, the time has come for her to reunite with her daughter.
Before leaving New York, Carmen visits the Statue of Liberty, a place she’s always wanted to see. But her attitude about what the statue represents has become more cynical. She calls “The American Dream” an illusion and questions why long-time immigrants can’t be granted amnesty. If America is where people come to make their dreams come true, why does the U.S. government make it so hard? As I watched her speak, I couldn’t help but agree with her.
Carmen and Carla have an emotional reunion back in Bolivia. As Carmen approaches her daughter’s wheelchair, Carla latches onto her mother and holds her tight, wailing non-stop at the top of her lungs for several minutes in the middle of the airport. Carmen consoles her daughter, not the other way around. This was my favorite part of the entire movie.
The rest of the film shows Carmen living in Bolivia and getting adjusted to her life back with Carla. Mother and daughter, despite their long separation, share an immediate bond. Carmen, like she promised, is able to pay for Carla’s modest quinceaÅera, an important coming-of-age ceremony on a girl’s 15th birthday that marks her transition to becoming a young woman.
Being present for these special moments in her daughter’s life is obviously important to Carmen, but in day-to-day life, things don’t run so smoothly. There is no fairytale ending. Carla will need medical care for her entire life, and Carmen soon realizes it is going to be very hard to provide for her daughter.
Because of her paralysis, Carla has to wear diapers and she gets painful bedsores. Not long after she returns home, Carmen learns from the doctor that there’s no hope of Carla ever walking again. Just to keep Carla’s condition from getting even worse will require an operation that they can’t afford, and physical therapy five times a week at a cost of $5 per session. There’s no way Carmen can afford this.
Seven months after Carmen’s return, her savings runs out. The film ends with Carmen still in Bolivia, left with her struggle to support Carla. She questions whether she should go back to New York, even though she’s promised Carla that she won’t leave her again. For the moment, she’s doing the best she can with what she has in Bolivia.
But as a disabled person in need of constant care, Carla’s future looks uncertain. In one heart-wrenching scene, Carla lies on her bed doing math homework as the movie Beauty and the Beast plays on her tiny television. Her attention keeps shifting to the TV, where she watches longingly as Belle dances across the screen in the arms of her love. You can’t help but wonder what Carla’s own future holds, and you understand why Carmen is willing to break her daughter’s heart again by returning to the U.S. in order to give her the best possible chance.
We Are All Immigrants
People often say that immigrants are taking the jobs of U.S. citizens, and that they add to the crime rate in the country. But the majority of people who come here are people like Carmen, trying to find a better life for themselves and their families. Most Americans can’t begin to imagine the hardships that millions of immigrants like Carmen face back home.
Let’s face it: with the exception of Native Americans, we are all here because the older generations of our families immigrated here. European settlers colonized (stole) the land of millions of Native Americans-including, probably, Carmen’s ancestors -who were already occupying the Americas. How can the act of crossing a border in order to support your family compare to that kind of crime? Who is the real American?
If politicians are so concerned with family values, why don’t they recognize the strong family values that people like Carmen are demonstrating, sacrificing everything for their loved ones? If they were in her situation, would they do anything different?
We Are All Americans
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.