U. of Owe

Shop around to get a deal on college

I had just started receiving college acceptance letters when I saw a New York Times article about how a college degree can’t get you a job these days. “Just under 20% of graduating seniors looking for a job were lucky enough to land one,” the story said. Great. So is college even worth it if I have to borrow tens of thousands in student loans?
Yes, says Phillip James, co-founder of College Assistance Plus-as long as I look for ways to save on tuition so I’ll be under less of a financial burden later. For a fee, his company helps students and parents through the financial aid process. “We got into this business because students were walking out of college with an incredible amount of debt that really cripples them for the rest of their lives,” he said. In fact, the average student loan debt for New York college grads was almost $26,000 in 2008, according to the Project on Student Debt.
Student loans are necessary for most of us, and you have to remember that a college degree will help you earn more money in your career. But to make sure you don’t end up borrowing more than what’s manageable, you must weigh your choices carefully at several critical points along the way.
1. Choosing schools to apply to
I’m one of those name brand junkies; whenever I have an event to attend, I rush online to see what’s new at Burberry, Ralph Lauren, and Marc Jacobs. My love for high-end designer clothing has little to do with price tags; I think the clothes are better quality and I like that air of self-confidence I get from wearing something few other people have.
When I first started thinking about which colleges I wanted to apply to, I took this same view. If it didn’t come with a label of prestige, I wasn’t interested. But then I saw the price tag of some of those fancy schools-tuition was more than $30,000 per year-and I snapped back to reality.
Actually, James believes a degree from a “brand name” or Ivy League school isn’t worth all that money. “After you graduate and get your first job, people don’t care where you went to college,” he said. “In the real world, it’s usually about how good a communicator you are, how you get along with people, and how well you know your job.” His advice for students who are doing well in high school: “They should definitely look at a moderately selective school. If they go to a moderately selective school, rather than a highly selective school, they’re likely to get more scholarships, grants, and free money.”
But I wasn’t sold. I think it’s worth applying to a highly selective school to see if you get in and to find out what kind of financial aid package you can get, even if you ultimately decide it’s too expensive. Plus, it has always been my understanding that exclusive schools had exclusive alumni, and that, at least in some fields, those connections really do matter.
Of course, choosing schools to apply to was about a lot more than the school’s reputation: I wanted a school that had both of the majors I was considering, was close to home, had a small average class size, and offered on-campus housing. I applied to four SUNY colleges and two expensive private schools that I knew would challenge me academically-and financially.
2. Applying for and negotiating financial aid
Part of the reason I wasn’t too worried about paying for college was because I knew that I’d be eligible for a lot of financial aid. The Free Application for Federal Student Aid, known as the FAFSA, was one of the most important documents I had to fill out; it was right up there with the actual college application itself. The form is used to determine how much financial assistance you can get in the form of grants (free money) and student loans (which you have to pay back, with interest, after you leave college).
James said, “We find that 60-70% of people make mistakes on the FAFSA, which could cost them thousands of dollars.” don’t make assumptions about anything on your FASFA form; if you don’t understand what’s being asked, call the FAFSA helpline or ask your guidance counselor where you can get free financial aid help.
After you send in your FAFSA, you will begin receiving financial aid offers from each college that has accepted you. If you’re unhappy with the financial aid package a school is offering, you can actually call the college’s financial aid office and ask if they’ll give you more money. Although it sounds like a bold thing to do, negotiating with a college will never result in them taking away the money they’vealready offered, James reassured me. He said there are many circumstances that might not be reflected on your financial aid forms-a parent who just lost a job, for instance-and colleges understand that.
3. Choosing a college
I know college is going to be expensive, regardless of which one I choose. When I mentioned that I was trying to decide between a private school and a state school, James said that state or city colleges are initially cheaper, but they’re also less likely to negotiate costs with you simply because they have less money.
So far, I’ve heard back from five colleges. I’m not sure which I’ll choose, but my goal is to borrow no more than $2,000 each semester if I can help it. I have somewhat changed my mind about wanting only a “brand name” college. As sometimes happens with clothes, I might end up buying from the sales rack.
Other Cost-Cutting Ideas
College Assistance Plus charges $1,895 to provide consultation services throughout your college career, but co-founder Philip James offered this free advice to NYC readers:
¥ Rack up college credit while you’re still in high school. Some colleges may give you credit for high school AP classes, which means you could complete college in three and a half years. But this also means you miss out on one semester of college fun.
¥ Try, try again. If you don’t score well on your SAT or ACT the first time, try again. Even though it might mean more weekend study sessions now, a higher score on the second try may help you get a better financial aid package.
¥ Look for colleges outside your comfort zone. Universities that are far from home might welcome a city kid like you, and offer you a better financial aid package than you expect. “Colleges really like diversity, and diversity is not only the color of your skin or ethnicity; it’s also being from another region or state,” James said. Just ask yourself before applying: Do I really want to live in Wyoming?
¥ Save money while you figure things out. If you’re not sure what you want to major in or don’t feel ready for a four-year college, consider spending two years in a low-cost community college and then transferring to a four-year school. Just make sure to keep your eye on the prize-a college diploma-or you might get stuck and wind up like that old guy on the TV show Community.
For information on tuition and average student loan debt by school, go to: projectonstudentdebt.org.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.