Part of No Child Left Behind is meant to give students in bad schools a way out: They can transfer to a different school, or possibly get money for tutoring.
About 40% of New York City’s public schools are failing (compared to about 25% of all the nation’s public schools). If the more than 200,000 kids in New York City who are eligible to transfer out of their schools did so, we’d have an enormous problem trying to find places for all of them.
can’t Transfer to Richer District
Already, even though fewer than 6,000 kids transferred this year, many transferred into schools that were already full without them. The law does not name overcrowding as a legitimate reason to turn away transfers, so even the most packed schools are supposed to accept NCLB transfers.
At PS 19 in the Bronx, a school with 450 students but built to accommodate only 325, 30 new students were transferred in because of NCLB, creating the worst overcrowding the school has ever seen.
And which students can transfer, and where they can transfer to, is complicated. For instance, Humanities Prep is a failing school. However, 10 kids still transferred in anyway.
The law works like this: Kids in failing Title I schools (Title I schools are schools that get money from the federal government because a lot of their students are poor) can transfer out. They can’t be put in another failing Title I school, but they can be put in a failing school that is not Title I. So, kids who transfer out of one failing school might be put into another school that’s failing according to NCLB, which doesn’t seem to make much sense.
And while these students must be allowed to transfer to another school in their district, there is no way of forcing schools from other districts to accept these students. In other words, if there is a struggling school district that borders a richer district, the schools from the rich district don’t have to accept transfers from the poorer district, even if they live just over the border.
If NCLB works the way its supporters claim it will, then everyone in America will have access to a high-quality public education. If it works the way its critics say it will, then it will only create large problems for public schools, possibly a crisis.
Transferring Out of Failing Schools
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.