Trade Schools Can Rip You Off If You Aren’t Very Careful

Here’s your ticket to a brighter tomorrow!”
Does this slogan sound familiar? You see it on the buses, trains, and subways all the time-trade schools offering you all the benefits of a college education, with courses that last three to eight weeks instead of four years. They promise you financial aid and job placement after you’ve graduated.
Picking a trade school can be exciting, but it’s also a tricky step to take.
Beware: many of these schools are in business to make money, not to educate you. There are trade schools out there that can and will rip you off.
Betsy Imholz, an attorney at Brooklyn Legal Services, says that many students don’t discover how hollow the promises are until after taking out a loan to attend.
$13,000 FOR 15 MONTHS
“One of the business schools in Brooklyn costs over $13,000 for a 15-month secretarial course,” says Imholz. “That’s a higher tuition than many Ivy League colleges.
“Students have teachers that don’t show up for class. There are typing classes where the machines are broken, and [the machines the students are trained on] are not used in the job market,” she adds.
Students must carefully read the “fine print” before enrolling, says Martha Bright, community relations specialist at the CUNY Center for Law and Social Justice.
If not, they could end up signing promissory notes for loans, putting them in debt for thousands of dollars.
Even if the student drops out of school, “The loan-plus interest-must be paid back,” says Bright.
Why do many students drop out of trade schools?
Overcrowded, Underequipped
According to Christopher Atwell, a reporter for The City Sun who has written several articles about trade schools, “The biggest complaint is [that] these schools are completely overcrowded and underequipped. There are beauty schools where there aren’t enough rollers to go around.”
Dawn J., a 17-year-old at Evander Childs HS, says, “When I went to Barbizon, I was 14. I went to sessions every Saturday for a year and a half. I was paying over $1,000, and they didn’t even show me the things that I was supposed to know.”
Bright says a high absentee rate among the teachers is another reason why students leave. Also, many of the teachers don’t really know their subjects. She adds that the equipment students are supposed to learn on is often outdated or missing altogether.
One trade school hires teens to recruit for them in the high schools. The recruiters get money for it, but the students being recruited are not aware of the games that many trade schools play.
According to the new state laws for licensing private trade and business schools, all school recruiters (on and off school premises) must be certified by the New York State Education Department.
“They [unlicensed recruiters] have no business recruiting students who are still in high school. If students are older [than 14], they are tempted to drop out to go to these trade schools,” says Bright.
Recruiting High School Students
Deborah Brown, a 17-year-old at Paul Robeson HS, was hired to recruit for the American Business Institute (ABI) and Wilfred Academy of Beauty.
“What attracted me was getting a commission,” she says. “It was great.”
Deborah was told to give out surveys in her school, and to ask the students if they’d like to go on a tour of either Wilfred or ABI.
What happened?
“People that came in the office were too young . . . about 14 years old, they were still in high school. But they [the trade school representatives] told them to come back after they graduate,” says Deborah.
“Because students are looking for shortcuts, they don’t want to go through high school, or get to college. [But] they come out [of the trade schools] with less skills than they had before, [and] they are paying bills,” says attorney LeRoi Gill.
Gill also says that some trade schools get laws favorable to them passed by the federal and state governments by contributing to politicians’ election campaigns.
“You could be failing, but they’d still have you on the books. They make money off you,” says Atwell.
What do students have to say? Do they know that many trade schools are ripoffs?
Tray M., 18, who attended SCS Business Institute, says that even the computers used for daily attendance can’t be trusted, because “you get marked 30 days absent if you are absent for one day.” This is a big ripoff, because students who are absent must pay an additional fee.
Courses Are Shallow
Even comments from students who liked their trade schools reveal how little these schools actually helped them.
Nicole Bowman, 21, said she was glad she attended the Wilfred Beauty Academy.
“I love doing hair,” she said. “You have to love it to do it . . . not just to make a quick buck.”
But Nicole also said Wilfred’s courses were shallow. “Wilfred teaches the basics,” she said.
“If someone wants to be a serious hairdresser, [their education] shouldn’t end at Wilfred. They [the representatives] offer you what is not the real world, but the teachers let you know what’s out there-they are more realistic,” Nicole added.
Would Nicole consider the beauty business as a career? “Career? Forget it! I’m interested in money . . . Too many people are doing hair. That means the wages are going to be lower.”
Not every trade school is in the business of ripping off students. There are many that give you your money’s worth. But it is important for you to be aware of those trade schools that are ripping off teens.
To know what you’re getting into, you must ask the schools about their dropout rates and student-teacher ratios. Also, ask if you can sit in on classes to see what they’re like.
You can call the New York State Education Department, 212-488-3252, to find out whether a trade school is licensed or not.
You can also call the New York State Department of Consumer Affairs, at 212577-0111, to get the booklet “When Choosing a Trade School,” which can tell you what to look for and how to protect yourself.
Consumer Affairs also offers a taped phone message with information about vocational schools. Call 212-732-8400 and ask for tape #504.
Many Good Alternatives
There are good trade schools which have courses that you can take for free. There are also alternative programs that offer broader training and education.
“There are hundreds of alternatives in the community-Jobs for Youth, Mid-Manhattan Adult Training, City Volunteer Corps, Private Industry Council, High School Auxiliary, and the Boy Scouts,” says Bright.
John M., 22, left the Taylor Business Institute, but is still paying for it. He had a better experience with the City Volunteer Corps, and adds that taking time to study the trade schools is better than “rushing to get to the future.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.