Imagine you’re 18 years old. You’ve just graduated from high school and you’re already qualified for your dream job. It’s what you’ve wanted to do since you were a little kid. You’ve dreamed about it every day and worked hard to achieve it. And here’s the best part: The minimum salary is almost $400,000 per year.
Unfortunately, you’re denied the job, not because of your qualifications but because of your age. The company has a minimum age requirement of 19. They expect you to take an extra year of training in college, training you don’t necessarily need.
Talented high school basketball players no longer need to imagine that.
Since 1971, the National Basketball Association (NBA) has been allowed to draft players right after they graduate high school, when most of them are 17 or 18. Before 1971, players had to be at least four years out of high school to be eligible to enter the league. Then the U.S. Supreme Court case Haywood v. NBA opened up the game for high school stars. Still, only a few players entered the league straight from high school in the 1970s and ’80s.
18-Year-Old Superstars
That trend changed dramatically starting in 1995, when Kevin Garnett was drafted from Farragut Academy HS in Illinois. Since then, 38 other players have been drafted straight from high school, including superstars like Kobe Bryant, Tracy McGrady, and Jermaine O’Neal. In the 2004 NBA draft (an annual event where teams select new players), eight of the first 19 picks were high school players.
While some players like O’Neal (drafted in 1996) and McGrady (drafted in 1997) needed a lot of time to develop into superstars, some of the more recent prom-to-pros players like LeBron James, now 20, have met instant success.
James has become the poster boy for successful players who skipped college. Drafted two years ago from a small Catholic high school in Akron, Ohio, James started gaining national attention his sophomore year. By his senior year, he was playing games on national TV in a sold-out college arena (his high school gym was too small to fit the fans and camera crews) and being declared the next Michael Jordan.
In his two-year NBA career with Cleveland, James has already been discussed as a Most Valuable Player (MVP) candidate and one of the top players in the league.
18-Year-Old Bench Warmers
But while several players have successfully jumped from high school to the NBA, just as many, if not more, turned out to be disappointments. Kwame Brown, the first player chosen in the 2001 NBA draft, hasn’t lived up to expectations despite getting plenty of opportunities to play.
Some players just don’t have enough skill to compete at the NBA level when they graduate high school. Because they can’t make immediate contributions to their team, they end up spending most of their time on the bench.
That’s one reason why the NBA raised its age minimum to 19. NBA Commissioner David Stern originally wanted the minimum age to be 20, but the union that represents the NBA players strongly opposed it. Both sides compromised on the age of 19 during labor negotiations in June.
Nothing to Fall Back On?
I talked to basketball fans and amateur players about their views on the age minimum for NBA players. Some agreed with the NBA’s decision to raise the draft age.
“I’m tired of all the high school players declaring for the draft and coming to the NBA when they’re not ready,” said Narin Soodtunyaratana, a 17-year-old freshman at Baruch College. “LeBron James is an exception.”
Keith Dsouza, 30, who was playing a pickup basketball game near LaGuardia Airport, where he works as a security attendant, said that going to college before joining the NBA would be better for these players in the long run. Dsouza, who’d injured his knee during the game, told me that if straight-from-high-school players got a serious injury in one of their games, they wouldn’t have anything to fall back on for a career.
Playing in college also gives them the chance to build their bodies, face better competition (compared to high school), refine their skills and become better players. Waiting a year gives them the opportunity to mature under the guidance of college coaches, which would help them adjust to the unique NBA lifestyle: sudden wealth, fame and endless traveling.
College vs. Cash
College basketball also benefits from the higher age minimum. In recent years, with many talented high school seniors and underclassmen immediately turning pro, colleges have had trouble recruiting the most talented players and maintaining strong enough basketball programs to compete for a national championship.
But opponents of a higher age minimum argue that if an 18-year-old is ranked as a top draft pick, why should he have to go to college and risk injury, and lose out on making loads of money?
“Most players grew up in poor communities, like Ben Gordon in Mount Vernon,” said Badinn Chobhaphand, an 18-year-old student at the State University of New York at Stony Brook. For players in this situation, it may be in their best interest to quickly make the most money they can to support their families.
Chobhaphand, sporting a black LeBron James band on his right wrist, also disagreed that college would help players in ways other than basketball. “Most players don’t think about academics,” Chobhaphand said. Star athletes don’t focus on school because they don’t need it once they turn pro.
Unfair Perhaps, but Legal
Andre Yoffa, 20, playing at the pickup game near LaGuardia Airport, called raising the age limit “an indirect form of racism” because it would affect primarily one racial group. Yoffa, a student at New York University, even wrote a seven-page paper on the issue. Of the 36 American high school players who participated in the draft between 1995 and 2004, all but one were African American.
Though it seems almost undemocratic to deny someone a job for any reason other than his qualifications, it is not illegal. Plus, age restrictions exist in the regular job market. For example, you have to be 21 to join the NYPD.
In sports, there is no uniform minimum age. The National Football League (NFL) requires players to be three years removed from graduating high school before being eligible for the draft. Major League Baseball (MLB) allows teams to draft high school graduates. Major League Soccer (MLS) teams can sign players much younger. Two years ago, D.C. United signed 14-year-old Freddie Adu.
Will a Year Make a Difference?
Though an age minimum of 19 isn’t the highest or lowest in sports, it might be the most controversial because of the proven success of some pros who skipped college. Plus, it’s unclear whether raising the age minimum by just one year will make much of a difference.
Putting young stars through only one or two years of college means that the effect it will have on them academically and athletically may be minimal. But at least the colleges get to borrow the services of future NBA talent for a couple of basketball seasons.
Too Young to Play
Is the NBA's New Age Minimum Fair?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.