There’s More Than One Way to Teach and Learn Math

Recognize these statements?
“The damn class is BORING”
“The subject seems so cold and lifeless-almost inhumanâ”
“What does learning this sh-t have to do with the real world? With my life?”
“I just don’t understand. It seems so hopeless sometimes, ’cause I just don’t get itâ”
If you are a student who has trouble with math, then these complaints are very familiar. Many students feel alienated, disgusted, or just don’t give a damn when it comes to mathematics nowadays, and it shows.
Enter a math class in many New York City high schools and you’ll see student s sleeping, reading, doodling, talking to classmates-anything but learning.
There is a general feeling among many students that math is a subject that is “closed” to them. The perception is that teachers just don’t care, are unqualified, or just can’t seem to relate to the students.
Another view is that the present teaching methods used in the public schools are perhaps to blame for the rising tide of student mediocrity in math and science.
Some common complaints about the present methods used in teaching math are: that it stresses rote memorization, rather than understanding; that students are rushed-forced to try to grasp difficult mathematical concepts in a limited amount of time; that it’s boring and unimaginative.
Humanizing Math
Arthur Powell, 35, is an associate professor of Mathematics at Rutgers University in Newark, N.J., and is in charge of their Developmental Mathematics program.
He works with students who are having trouble with mathematics, and in doing so he feels that he has come across a method to “humanize” the study of mathematics-a way to help students relate to mathematical concepts more clearly and to retain their knowledge for a longer period of time.
According to Powell, “What I dislike is the curriculum… that says that within the span of 14 weeks, you must learn this amount of material. People have different rates of learning…
“Most of education, but particularly in mathematics, is taught in the following way: the teacher walks into the classroom, states what is going to be taught that day, presents a definition and an example of that definition, and then shows the students how to solve a problem of that certain type,” Powell continued. “Then students are given problems of that type to solve…the problem I have with that is, when you present a definition, nobody except the instructor knows why the definition is used…”
Victims of the System
When talking about the students he teaches, who have been “taught” in the traditional manner, he says that he “feel[s] a sense of solidarity with them, in that these students are victims of the educational system. they’vebeen convinced that they can’t do mathematics. And as far as I’m concerned, that makes them the victim.
“The students I meet,” Powell continued, “when they come to college, they have gone through 12 years of this victimization-many of them tend to be minority students, Black and Latino, and they then are students who have experienced racism, whose hope for an economic future is sometimes low. So their sense of motivation, their sense that they’re coming to college for four years of difficult work [that will] pay off in the end-they don’t always have that…”
Powell went on to say: “Mathematics should be taught first from situations and in the sense of a problem-solving approach. And then, in the process of examining the situation, or in trying to solve the problem, then you develop the definition and the techniques. So then one sees why it’s necessary to do [what they are doing in the problem].”
Developing a System
When he began teaching in 1981, Powell felt that many students who were being taught math in the traditional way weren’t being provided with a proper understanding of the subject.
“So,” Powell said, “one of the things that I knew when I started teaching in `81, is that, whatever I did, I shouldn’t do that. So, the question is, `What is it that I do?’ One of the things that I realized at first is that I don’t memorize things-[I] develop a feel, a sense for what’s required…”
From that, he slowly developed a system where the students are exposed to a general mathematical principle, are given a problem that relates to that principle to solve, and then, students try to solve the problem by experimenting with various techniques-including journals in which they make daily entries.
Jose Lopez, a student who was taught by Powell, said, “Throughout the semester I kept a journal detailing my observations of the class, course, and my learning of mathematics. I found many instances where certain ideas or concepts became clearer to me as a result of my writing about them…”
Writing About Math
According to Powell, the writing of journals is “a mechanism to get students to think about, to reflect on what they are doing. By having students write, it provides them with an opportunity to look ever more deeply into themselves with respect to what they understand.”
The journals are collected at the end of the week, commented on by Powell, and redistributed to the students, who break up into smaller, co-operative groups where they discuss the work they’vedone and the methods they used to solve the problem.
“By having students work in small groups together,” said Powell, “It gives them the opportunity to talk mathematics, which they don’t do normally… you put them in a situation where they are talking the mathematics, and so they’re helping each other learn.
“When one learns through this alternative approach,” he continued, “one retains their knowledge of mathematics much longer because what stays with them is their understanding, as opposed to having memorized the rules… You can forget those.”
The question that remains is whether or not these methods can be applied in the public schools. After all, wouldn’t this type of learning be more useful if applied at an earlier time-at the elementary, junior high school, or high school level?
Can the Old Ways Change?
Unfortunately, according to Powell, “the public schools are extremely conservative. The willingness of the system to change is very low. In that case, it’s a political battle.”
And, even if the schools should agree to change their approach to math teaching, he added, “…In order for teachers to teach in these new ways, they have to experience being taught in these new ways-teachers [would] need to be retrained.”
So, in the end, all that can be said is that you shouldn’t hold your breath waiting for this ‘cutting-edge’ approach to math teaching to hit your school any time soon. But this method may be used with future generations of students who are having trouble with mathematics.
Or, if there is enough political pressure from student groups, parent organizations, interested politicians and the like, it may be widely used much sooner than you think. Time can only tell-and the clock keeps ticking…

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.