From my point of view, ambition can be good or bad. It really depends on what you want to accomplish and how you decide to get there.
A teen girl’s ambition to start her own community-based organization and help others might motivate her to do her best in school, work hard, and save her money. That’s a good pathway that will lead her to good things, like the ability to help poor kids around her neighborhood. On the other hand, a hustler’s ambition to make money no matter what will lead him down a bad path and likely cause him to hurt others.
My own ambition is to open a hair salon. “If you want to make your dream come true, you’ve got to work hard and take the right path,” my mom tells me. And she’s right. Ambition needs to be accompanied by a plan, so I’ve figured out what I need to do: First I have to get my GED, and then find a cosmetology school. I need to talk with someone who has experience and go see different salons to get ideas and learn what kinds of tools they use. I’ll save my money and, eventually, buy my own boutique.
Everyone has different dreams, and sometimes I wonder what being ambitious means to other people. Is it about being famous? And does ambition come from growing up thinking you can be whatever you want to be? My fellow YCteen writers had a roundtable discussion to examine questions like these. Here are some of the answers they came up with.
-Cristhians Gonzalez
With Sherilyn Blake, Evin Cruz, Rosie Scolaro, Jhanae Shine, and Renea Williams
How would you define ambition? Do you see it as generally a good or bad thing?
Jhanae: Ambition is the desire to achieve or obtain something, and generally I think it’s a good thing. Not necessarily because it shows a desire, but because it’s taking action for the things that you want.
Evin: I just want to say something to make everyone think a little more: Does anyone think Hitler was ambitious?
Sherilyn: Yes, for the wrong reasons. I think ambition is the drive to do something that you think is right. To someone else it might not be the most logical thing to do, but to you it’s the right thing to do. Ambition is defined by people differently.
Jhanae: I agree that Hitler was ambitious. You can take bad actions in going for something, but ambition is just that sense that you are going toward something. Like if you’re cheating on a test, you’re ambitious: You’re striving to pass a test. But the actions you took for that ambition were wrong.
Why are some people ambitious while others aren’t? Do a person’s culture, gender, social class, wealth, or personal struggles have anything to do with it?
Jhanae: Not to go into a history lesson, but there have been plenty of times when a gender or a cultural group has been oppressed. Ambition is about going for your goals, and maybe in a lot of those cases the goal is to overcome oppression.
Evin: I think wealth helps. Even if my grades were awesome, I wouldn’t be able to afford Harvard. If you can’t afford it, then you think, “I can’t go there, why should I even try?”
Renea: I say culture. For example, in India, you have the caste system. If you are untouchable, you can’t go above being an untouchable. You have to just stay there.
Rosie: I have a friend whose parents are both from Yemen. She went on a shopping spree and bought herself 20 pairs of Uggs. I was like, “How can you afford this?” She said, “Well, my dad spoils me.” She said that when he was growing up in Yemen he didn’t have money, and when he came to this country he wanted to achieve and be able to provide things for his children. He had the motivation to get the money. He’s a hard worker because of what he didn’t have.
Sherilyn: I think gender has a big effect. I know a lot of people feel that the workforce is male-dominated, but women try to compete with men so they can be recognized and show that they’re equal to men.
Do others agree? Who thinks girls are more ambitious than boys, or vice versa?
Renea: Girls must be more ambitious, because boys don’t do their work. Girls get higher grades than boys and get accepted to better colleges.
Jhanae: Since I went to an all-girls school for a big part of my life, I can say that girls are highly competitive, but boys are about doing what it takes to get what they want and where they want to be. Despite the fact that they fool around sometimes, boys care a lot.
Rosie: I agree. I don’t know if it’s ambition so much as that they feel they need to prove something. I know many guys who need to prove something.
How much of our ambition is based on our desire to prove something to others?
All: A lot.
Evin: I have ADD (Attention Defecit Disorder), and when I was diagnosed, I had this sudden urge, “I want to prove to everyone that even though I have this, I can do anything!”
Sherilyn: I think it goes back to the gender and social class thing. Some people feel they should achieve more because of who they are and where they’vebeen. They’re like, “Just because I was poor doesn’t mean I can’t be rich one day,” or, “Just because I’m female doesn’t mean I can’t be president.” They try to do something that they know society won’t expect.
Can being overly ambitious be bad for you?
Evin: I definitely believe that. If you put too much focus on one thing, like your work, other areas of your life will suffer. Your friendships; your relationships; if you’re married, your husband or wife. A “workaholic” I think is the term.
Rosie: It comes down to being able to balance your ambition with other things you need. In my internship seminar, we’re looking at this question, “Do you find wealth in the search for meaning, or meaning in the search for wealth?” And I think that ties back to the idea of ambition and what you’re looking for.
If someone gets good grades in school but lacks direction in life, would you call that person ambitious?
Evin: I know someone like that. This guy was smart, top of our class in high school, but he didn’t go to college afterwards. He’s working in a restaurant now. This kid was a genius but he just didn’t care.
Jhanae: I don’t think it makes them any less ambitious. They proved they were capable of doing something-getting good grades-that is an achievement in itself.
Sherilyn: This kind of sounds like me. I’m in the top half of my class and work really hard at school, but I don’t have a concrete goal of what I want to be. I’m applying to college right now and I don’t even know what college I want to go to, or what I want to do when I get there. Every day I change my mind. It doesn’t mean that I’m not ambitious, it’s just so overwhelming and confusing to decide what you’re going to do for the rest of your life. It has to be something that you’re willing to wake up to every single morning.
At what point does ambition cross over into greed?
Jhanae: If you’re willing to sacrifice anything and everything to get what you want.
Evin: If everything else starts to lose focus, and you can only focus on this one thing, which is the power.
Sherilyn: I was reading an article about this man who lives in a fancy house. He has a gardener and all this other stuff, but he’s saying that he struggles to get by. His gardener was a luxury that turned into a necessity for him. He’s delusional, because he has a lot of money and doesn’t realize that the things that are a luxury for someone else feel obligatory for him.
Can you imagine losing perspective like that? To bring it down to a more realistic level, has anyone ever had a part-time job where suddenly you got used to having spending money, and your expectations changed?
Jhanae: When I was 15, my dad got me a summer job, and before that I thought that work was a thing for grown-ups. I never wanted to do it. He said, “You’re going to get paid,” and I said, “I don’t care; that doesn’t matter.”
I spent the summer working, and I got a little bit of cash and spent it all on the stupidest stuff. When school started again, I was like, “I can’t wait to grow up! I want to have a job!” I can see how that feeling could make your standards change a little bit.
Is there something desirable about being known in itself, or is it only desirable to be known for something you’ve accomplished?
Sherilyn: I guess today fame is like a lottery ticket: If you have a winning number, that’s all you need. Look at the Kardashians-all they do is drive around in a car and spend money. They’re not actually known for achieving anything.
Would you be interested in being in a reality show?
Evin: Absolutely not.
Sherilyn: I’d like to be famous for accomplishing something that would help solve world problems, like global warming, or poverty, or animal abuse.
Renea: You’re saying you want to be famous for a good cause, but those people are not even that famous. People will say, “Oh yeah, she did something good.” But the next week they’ll say, “Who’s that?”
Rosie: I think it would be cool to have a reality show, even though it would get annoying. I’m a very lazy person, so the idea of being rich and famous for no reason at all is very appealing.
Jhanae: The thing about being famous is that I’d feel I had meaning or a purpose; it would be a reminder of my own existence. If people know you, you have-I don’t want to say self-worth, butâ¦
Sherilyn: If you’re famous, you have a voice. People will listen to someone who’s out there in public more than just some guy in a cornerâ¦But no matter what kind of fame you have, our society is all about the bad. People only care about the bad things you do. They’ll use one bad thing to label you for the rest of your life.
Are your ambitions for yourself the same as your parents’ ambitions for you?
Jhanae: My parents try not to make their ambitions for me too specific, which I think is good. But they have some things set in stone, like they want me to pursue my education and have a career that I am proud of.
My friend, her parents are both well-known dentists and they have their own private dentist’s office. Since 7th grade she’s said she wanted to be a dentist. She’s in her junior year now, and she’s like, “I don’t want to become a dentist.” But the family is already planning to leave their business to her, and she feels overwhelmed by the idea that she has to become a dentist. I don’t know if they’veever directly said, “I want you to become a dentist,” but that’s the idea. It’s a lot of pressure. And also, that’s a way that she can afford to live the life of luxury that her parents have.
Were you told growing up that you could be whatever you wanted to be? Do you think that’s true?
Jhanae: I don’t think you can be whatever you want to be. I used to believe that, and I was told that when I was younger, but I definitely don’t think it’s true. There are rags to riches stories, but they are the exception. I don’t think it’s fair to tell a kid, “You can be whatever you want to be.”
Rosie: It’s like lying to your kids.
Evin: I know I could never be a CEO. Why? Because I don’t like math. So I know I can’t do that.
Jhanae: At a certain age, your parents should stop telling you, “You can be whatever you want to be.” It’s only when you’re, like, 4, and nothing’s happened to you, that you can be whatever you want. But by the time you enter junior high school, there needs to be a little asterisk.
Renea: When I was little, I wanted to be a pediatrician. But when I got to high school science classes, I decided, chemistry? No. Physics? No. I like English, so now I’m focused on becoming a teacher. Leave being a pediatrician to someone who can handle it.
The Two Sides of Ambition
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.