Imagine if high schools in the city were going to be closed down, and you had to travel to school all the way in Westchester County. It might sound bad because it’s so far away, but guess what? It wouldn’t be that bad.
For a writing assignment, I had to go to Hastings-on-Hudson, which is located in Westchester. I interviewed some of the students at Hastings HS and it was nice.
Trust me, if you had to go to Hastings HS, I’m telling you, you would love it.
When I went to Hastings I was looking forward to meeting the people and seeing what life is like in the suburbs.
A Town Like You’d See On TV
When I hit the town shopping center, it looked like one of those towns you see on TV, like on “Dawson’s Creek”, or in the movie “Stand By Me”. It was a peaceful sight and a nice view all around.
The grass was nicely trimmed and a pale color green, and there were a lot of hills to walk up. When the cars were riding down the hill, it looked like they were sliding down.
Now when I got to the school, it looked old and fancy. The classrooms in the school were clean and quiet and decorated with posters on the wall.
All the classes I went to were small, about 15 or 20 students. The thing that surprised me most was how neat the classrooms were. Because in my school the classrooms are filthy.
Not At All Like My School
This school even had a student lounge with couches. And about half of the school was carpeted. Their school was small and nicely decorated. That was very different from my school, which is big and which has a lot of vandalism.
I go to high school in Manhattan now, but for the first two years of high school I went to school in Brooklyn, and it was the pits.
I thought the teachers were crappy, because they didn’t seem to teach you much and they would still fail you if you didn’t do well in the class.
The teachers also acted as if they were afraid of the students. The kids would curse the teachers out and they wouldn’t say anything back to them, they’d just sit there and let the kids disrespect them. They’d allow it to go on every day until they finally kicked them out of class.
Kids who didn’t belong there would walk into the class if they felt like it, and if the teacher asked them to please leave, they would say, “I’m not leaving,” and they wouldn’t.
Gangs and Fights Outside
My new school is better. Some of the teachers care and they go out of their way for the students.
My counselor was a good history teacher, and he put time aside to explain what we didn’t understand. He also took time out to talk to students if they had problems.
But my school doesn’t feel safe like Hastings. There’s a lot of drugs there on the low, and students carry weapons and smoke in the bathroom.
And outside the school there are gangs, drugs and kids smoking. The gangs look for fights and wait for certain people to come out who they want to fight.
Some kids don’t pay it no mind, but some kids are nervous, because they’re the ones who’ve got the beef with the gang.
No Beef In Hastings
And inside or near the school there’s probably a fight once a week. That’s very different from Hastings, where they said fights are rare. Hastings HS doesn’t even have security guards!
“I don’t have to look behind my back,” said Meg McElroy, a senior. “We only have fights a few times a year, if there’s beef.”
“There’s no beef in Hastings. We just have bullsh-t,” said Tyler Morris, also a senior.
Now, some schools in the city are probably a lot nicer than mine (friends of mine go to schools that sound cleaner and safer), and I’m sure that some suburban schools are not as fancy as Hastings. But it still shocked me to realize that a high school could be so different from mine.
Small Classes, Good Teachers
Hastings was also different because most of the kids I met there had really good grades. It surprised me a little, because a lot of city kids are failing badly or dropping out.
I think the kids I met were doing so well because the students and teachers work together. The students cooperate with the teachers during class, and the teachers see that the students are willing to learn, so the teachers show the students they care. In my school, the students are not as respectful.
One teacher who I really liked was Ms. Laura Rice, an English teacher. She was really friendly and had a kind heart.
I’m not sure what it was that she was teaching the class, because I was too busy looking around the room. But the way she was teaching the class was nice.
If she asked them a question, the kids would raise their hands and wait to be called on. They had a lot of respect for her explaining detail after detail.
Suburbs: Not Diverse Enough
I felt like a student in Hastings myself when I was sitting in the classes, because I was paying attention to the teachers, and they were teaching pretty well.
They seemed so close to their students, and they took time out to show them something they didn’t understand.
I think school would have been different for me if I had lived in a nice suburb like Hastings because I would probably have learned a whole lot more.
It’s not that I didn’t learn much in my school, it’s just that when I had trouble, the teachers didn’t help me as much as they could have. That was a problem for me and most of the students in my school.
Still, Hastings isn’t perfect either. Most students said they’re happy with Hastings HS because they’re learning a lot there. But many also said that the school is too small, and that it’s not diverse enough.
The school has only 300 kids, and when I was there, I saw only five Black kids and one Hispanic kid.
Black in a White School
I thought the Black kids might feel a little uncomfortable because most of the school is White.
I would feel uncomfortable there myself, because I’m not used to being around a lot of White people. There are no White people in my neighborhood, and I only knew one White guy in my school.
But Michael, one of the few Black kids I met, said he doesn’t really feel like his race stands out.
“I might have felt weird if I just moved here in 10th grade, but it doesn’t bother me, because I grew up with a lot of the kids in this school,” he said. “You just grow up and get used to it.”
I was pretty impressed with Michael. He has a 90 average and he is taking honors and AP classes, and he plays on three sports teams during the year.
Michael plans to go away to college next year. I think that’s good, because it’s important for him to show that Black kids can do that, too.
I think part of the reason Michael does so well in school is because there are no distractions. His neighborhood is quiet and his school is quiet. Michael just goes to football or basketball practice, and then he goes home and studies.
“My street is quiet,” Michael said. “A lot of people who live there go to school, but after school, no one’s around.”
My neighborhood is not peaceful like Michael’s. I live in the projects, and they are not a nice place to grow up.
I think living in a house like Michael’s would be different even in small ways, like you could leave your belongings outside your own house and not have to worry about anyone stealing them.
In the projects, you can’t even leave a child outside alone with all the stuff that goes on in that environment.
Poor Kids Need Better Schools
Now, not everybody wants to live in the suburbs or can afford to live there, but we should have schools that are as good as Hastings HS here in the city.
We should complain to the governor or the mayor, and protest against the Board of Education because of the way they’re neglecting the schools in the poor communities, which need help the most.
Poor kids need better schools than wealthy kids, because they need an education. Without an education, what have they got? Nothing. And if they’ve got nothing, then how will they survive?
I’m sure the majority of the people in the suburbs would agree with me.
The Board of Ed. should clean up our schools and the government should stop being so cheap. If I had everybody’s open ears, I would tell them to think of others besides themselves for once.
Besides, if city students don’t get a good education, it’s only going to cause problems for everyone in the long run.
So think of the youth and their future. Save them, don’t destroy them. Help them, don’t neglect them.
The Suburbs: A Different World
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.