The Mysteries of Faith

It's a miracle I escaped my abusive Christian foster home

Some people think that the shortage of foster and adoptive parents for older children can be solved by inviting churchgoers to take us into their homes. After my experience in a strict religious home, though, I know that going to church doesn’t guarantee that a person will practice what they preach.
I grew up knowing I was Catholic, even though my family never took me to church. My relatives always had crucifixes and pictures of Jesus and saints all over the house. My aunts told me that when I was being baptized as a baby I ranted like crazy, screaming at the top of my lungs.
Ever since, I’ve been trying to work out my beliefs about religion. I’ve also tried to figure out what to think about people who claim to be Christians.
A Major Decision
I don’t know why I was taken from my Aunt Sandra and Uncle Willie when I was 6 years old. I just remember a social worker at my agency saying, “We got this nice family for you. They have a girl there in the house with them, and her name is Jonelle. Mingo and Milagros are good people. I’m sure you will love them.”
I was all happy and jumpy about staying over with these new adults. If I liked them, my social worker added, their house would be my new home.
Their house was much nicer than my Uncle Willie’s. It had mirrors and a beautiful table and all the furniture was nicely sealed with plastic. A 5-year-old girl who turned out to be Jonelle was in the dining room watching cartoons. “That is so cool! You guys have a nicer TV than in my aunt’s house,” I said.
My new foster father Mingo came home later that evening and said “hi.” The house was nice and calm with no drama. I was in heaven! I called my aunt later in the evening and I told her how nice it was and how everyone was treating me well. My aunt didn’t approve of me staying with Milagros and Mingo, but I shook it off. I liked my new lovely home.
Boy, Was I na•ve
The first Sunday I was there, Milagros and Mingo took me to their Mormon church, The Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter-Day Saints. It was boring, but I liked the air conditioning. Also, I felt assured that Milagros and Mingo would be really good parents because they believed in God.
Boy, was I na•ve.
A few months later, I was in Milagros’s bedroom playing with Matchbox cars. Without any notice at all, she started whipping me with a belt and yelling. I couldn’t understand what she said. When she got excited she spoke in really fast Spanish and my Spanish is limited to just a few words. She beat me and beat me, then left me on the carpet and shut the door. I was confused and scared. “What the hell?! She just whipped me for no reason,” I thought.
I figured this had to be a one-time thing. So I just let it slide. After all, Mingo had been nice to me. He blew air on my chest to make a fart noise, like a dad having a fun time with his son.
The Fairy Tale Is a Nightmare
But a few days later, I was messing around with a tube of Milagros’s perfume and spilled it. Jonelle looked at me and said “Ooooh! You are going to get in trouble, I’m going to tell Mingo.” I ran downstairs but Mingo ran after me, and he had his belt in his hand. He hopped over the sofa and whipped me over and over again. I had lash marks on my back.
While I cried, Jonelle just looked at me, smiling. A half hour later, Milagros came and smacked me in the face. That night I feel like I was Hansel, in the house with an ugly witch ready to throw me in the oven.
Every Sunday, I had to get up at 7 a.m., eat nasty oatmeal that made me gag, and be dragged to church for six hours. The preachers were boring, but Milagros seemed happier in church, when there were other people around, so I felt a little safer then. I couldn’t believe Milagros would sit there wearing an angelic smile, singing hymns and praising God like a good churchgoer after all she had done to me.
After church Milagros was the wrath of Satan. “666” should have been carved on her chest. There was not one week I wasn’t beaten, not one month I was not forced into a dark, scary closet. She would slam the door and yell at me that I should eat the roaches I found there.
Any mistake-forgetting to clean, not eating their pink mashed potatoes, dropping a picture-resulted in a beating. I was so terrified all the time, I wet the “bed” (a mattress on the floor next to Milagros’s bed). Of course, I got beaten for that, too.
I felt cornered everywhere I went in the house. Mingo and Milagros were always threatening me: “If you make one stupid mistake, God is going to put you in hell with Satan!” I begged God to make them stop, but they kept right on with their beatings and threats. If there was a God, He had failed me. Why would He have put me in this house with these messed-up people? What had I done to deserve this?
When I was 9 years old, Milagros and Mingo had me baptized as a Mormon, even though I had already been baptized Catholic. They were already talking about me becoming an elder in their church.
A False Confession
Milagros and Mingo took me to Puerto Rico, where my real family came from. It looked beautiful, but looks can be deceiving.
One day Milagros hollered, “Dominick, ven aqui!” I was scared right away and my hand trembled. Milagros ordered me to stand in a line with Jonelle and this other girl named Amy. “Who stole $40? Grandpa had $40 in his bedroom and now he doesn’t have it!” Milagros yelled. We all stood quiet.
I knew that Amy and Jonelle had had a lot of money a few days earlier and that they’d bought chocolate ices with it. But I wasn’t sure if it was the stolen money.
“If you don’t come up with it right now, you all will get beaten!” Milagros screamed.
I didn’t take the money, but suddenly, my mind seemed to think it would be a good idea to say that I did. Maybe I didn’t want to see all three of us get the belt, or I had been brainwashed into believing I was a sinner. All I know is I felt the urge to confess to something I didn’t even do. “I took the $40, Milagros,” I said.
She gave me this nasty look and said, “Dominick, go to the bathroom right now!”
Milagros’s mother, Ramos, ordered me to take off all my clothes and made me get into the bathtub, naked, and stay there for three hours. Mosquitos bit me and the two girls laughed and laughed. This, to me, was worse than being hit.
Milagros and Mingo took me to church in Puerto Rico, too. All the time, Milagros would order me to get on my knees and “pray about all of the things you have done wrong right now!”
“Godâis good. Jesus, I have been a bad personâ. I have done wrong to the familyâ. Please help meâ. Amen,” I would pray. I didn’t know what I did wrong. I just knew I was bad. But on some level, I think I knew that I wasn’t.
A Kindly Aunt
Not long after I was baptized, Milagros and Mingo took Jonelle and me to Clovis, California, a few miles away from Fresno. We were supposedly there to visit Milagros’s family, but I think my foster parents wanted to go there because it was about 110 degrees. Demons feel most comfortable in the temperature of hell.
Milagros’s family, though, was really nice, especially her sister Millie, who wasn’t as religious as Milagros. Millie taught me how to do box stitches with a lanyard, and was always kind. A few weeks after we got there, Millie walked in while Milagros was yelling at me. She asked, “Dominick-has Milagros ever treated you nice?”
I was scared, but stood up and said “Noâ”
“That’s a lie!” Milagros interrupted. “We give you food! Mingo makes waffles for you! We treat you with respect!”
“No you haven’t,” I said.
Milagros smacked me in the face.
I cried and walked out, but I heard Millie yelling at Milagros for half an hour. The tension between them must have been bad, because we left that night.
An Unexpected Rescue
My foster parents made me sit on the floor of the car. Every time I said anything, someone smacked me in the head for opening my mouth. “You will get the worst beating of your life when we get back to New York,” Milagros told me.
My hair stood up like Alfalfa on The Little Rascals. On the plane back home, I sat with Milagros and could tell she wanted to kill me. When the plane got to JFK Airport, policemen came on and walked toward us.
“We need you to get up,” the policeman said to Milagros. That’s when it hit me: The policemen were taking me away from her!
Here was the chance I wanted-to be free from them. But now that I had the chance, I was afraid: I didn’t know if new foster parents would be even worse. I started crying. I was glad I didn’t have to get beaten by those bastards ever again, but I was also just so tired and confused.
The cops took me to a nearby police station where they gave me food and a blanket and had me talk about what happened. Later that night I was taken to a foster home in Co-op City in the Bronx. That family took care of me and gave me a nice bedroom to sleep in. They were Baptists, but only expected me to go to church every couple weeks. By this time, I was sick of both religion and God.
My Faith Is Restored
I got interested in the occult and Satanism because I wanted to rebel against everything Milagros and Mingo said. But Satanism didn’t really make sense to me, either. I started to wonder if I could just pick and choose the best things from different beliefs. Eventually I decided I was an atheist-someone who doesn’t believe in God.
At age 16, a great thing happened to me that made me think the world might be a safe place. I got adopted by a really nice man who is agnostic (that means he doesn’t believe in organized religion). He’s also gay, which many religious people think is a sin. In fact, some have even gone so far as to try to prevent gay parents from fostering or adopting kids because they think gay people set a bad example. But I noticed that my dad’s partner, Devon, prayed every night before we had dinner.
“Do you go to church?” I asked Devon. He said he didn’t, so I asked him how he could pray without going to church. He explained that God is not the property of any one organized religion and that his relationship with God was personal. Devon really got me thinking that I could have a relationship with God on my own terms. So now I believe in God and pray to Him when I need to. Like Devon, I see God not as a punishing God, but as a loving God.
My Saviors
For many years, I’ve wondered how Milagros could claim to be such a devoted Christian, go to church, pray and sing hymns, while beating me the other six days of the week. How could she be so hypocritical?
Thinking back, I am also fairly certain that Millie was the person who called the police on her own sister. I wish there was a way I could see her and thank her, because I consider her an angel who saved my life. Millie wasn’t as religious as Milagros, but she did the right thing when self-proclaimed Christians didn’t.
A lot of religious people do a good job as foster parents, but being religious doesn’t mean you’ll automatically be a good foster parent. I also think it’s wrong for foster parents to force religion on children and fill them with fear.
I pray now that God will forgive all the people who hurt me and abused me, including Mingo and Milagros. Forgiving and letting go has freed me from the prison of my past. Milagros and Mingo took away my faith, but people like Millie, Devon, and my dad restored it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.