Last March 29, two NYC reporters, Tanya Wade and Clare Comardo, visited Fishkill prison in Beacon, New York. The visit was made possible by a juvenile justice worker who visits the prison regularly.
The van picked up Tanya and Clare at 8:30 a.m. During the ride, each of them silently wondered what the prison would be like. Tanya was thinking of a massive prison riot; Clare was off in her own little world, humming one of the latest rock tunes.
All too soon the van came to a halt. Clare and Tanya looked out the window in amazement. The prison area was beautiful. The grass was green, the sun was bright, and the prison itself looked like a mansion. If you took away the barbed wire and fences, one might mistake Fishkill for a resort area.
Clean Socks
They stepped out of the van and were led by a guard to the prison’s scanning area. The scanning area had a metal detector and two tables that were a few feet from each other. The guard told them to remove their jackets and shoes. “I hope my socks are clean,” thought Clare as she drew closer to the guard.
All of a sudden they heard:
“Shouldn’t be no talking!”
“No talking?! What happens if I talk?” Clare thought, but she kept her mouth shut.
“Keep that aisle clear, get off the wall and move it over!”
Tanya and Clare were ready to turn around and get the hell out of Fishkill. However, their legs, which were frozen, had other ideas.
“I have to go to the bathroom,” they both thought simultaneously.
Suddenly, they were out in the hall that led to the visiting rooms. The hallway was murky.
Even the pictures that covered the walls didn’t do much for the dull and dismal surroundings.
Tanya and Clare were led to a visiting room by another guard. While Tanya’s eyes remained at her feet, Clare looked straight ahead into thin air. Both girls felt a nervous twinge in their stomachs.
On their way to the basement, they were met by 81A4-788, a middle-aged prisoner, who pulled them aside into a room that lawyers use to confer with their clients. He was in charge of the Youth Assistance Program (Y.A.P.).
The program is run by a group of convicts who try to show youngsters how to avoid prison while yelling and screaming obscenities. He told them the rules: “When I ask you to stand up and face the wall, do it, OK?”
‘This One Looks Scared’
Clare had no idea what the man was talking about, but fear told her to nod. Tanya nodded her head weakly. She tried to look cool, but it didn’t work.
“This one over here looks scared,” 81A4788 said with a grin. Tanya could only grin back and gulp. “Thank God he didn’t notice how nervous I am,” thought Clare, as he led them down to the basement.
As they walked, the walls changed from a dull, drab beige to a dull, drab green which matched what the prisoners were wearing.
There were chairs arranged in a circle for the unsuspecting kids. The prisoners involved in Y.A.P. came down to the basement in a single file that closely resembled a chain gang.
The prisoners introduced themselves, one by one.
“My name is 80A4590, I was convicted for armed robbery.”
“My name is 79A2992, I was convicted of armed robbery.’
“My name is 83A5725, I was convicted of murder.”
And the list went on.
Prisoner 80A4590, a burly man with dreadlocks, stood up to talk. “Oh, God, what is he gonna do?” Tanya thought as her heartbeat quickened.
“You see this?” he asked, holding up a metal mop pail. “It looks heavy, don’t it? How would you like it if you was hit with it? It hurts like hell. I know-I was hit with it.”
Then 80A4590 told about the washing procedure. While doing this, he passed around a beige bar of soap. Tanya put the soap to her nose, sniffed, and made a horrible face.
A small, stocky man, 75A72-95, stood up and began speaking of his crime.
‘I Blew Them Away’
‘Someone stabbed my sister, so I thought the only answer was revenge. One day three guys came up to me and they told me they wanted my money. I gave them my money and when they turned their backs, I blew them away. That’s right-I shot three human beings in cold blood.’
75A7295 was far from finished:
‘What if I shot your sister or brother, huh? What would you do then?’ Clare thought about the possibility for a second but quickly dismissed the horrifying thought.
There was a dreadful silence. The silence was broken as 81A4788 stood up to tell them that it was time for lunch.
At one end of the basement there was a table set up for one group, and on the other side there was another table. The table that Clare and Tanya ate at was in a small area that resembled a bullpen.
The meal was eaten with plastic forks, for no knives were permitted. To Tanya, the mystery meat was bland and tasteless. OK, the corn was good . . . and the bread. Clare tried using her plastic fork to mix up the concoction so it would appear that she had actually eaten some.
Finally, lunch was over, but the visit wasn’t. Tanya and Clare looked on from the bullpen as the prisoners separated the kids into small groups and began having personal discussions with them.
Tanya and Clare strained to hear what the prisoners were saying, but unfortunately the only thing they could hear was . . . nothing.
The Maze of Despair
Twenty minutes later, the groups broke up and it was time to go. Tanya and Clare were led back through the maze of despair. The world that they were going back to seemed brighter as they went down the hall towards the scanning room.
The gate was opened, and in a few seconds Tanya and Clare were outside the prison. “It’s gorgeous out here,” Clare said to herself as she sniffed the spring air with delight. “Finally, ” thought Tanya as she stepped back into the world.
When they looked around at the green grass and the trees and listened to the birds chirping, it was hard to believe that right behind them stood a prison. They were glad they could see the skies and the trees again.
Unfortunately, the prisoners couldn’t see the beauty through the bars.
The Lost Souls of Fishkill Prison
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.