The Gay Word

Calling something 'gay' as an insult is wrong

I grew up with a best friend who had two moms, one of whom was my godmother. Two of my best friends identify as bisexual. When a friend described our neighborhood in three words once, one of the words was “lesbian.” She didn’t mean it negatively, just as a matter-of-fact statement.
For all these and other reasons, I have always thought that being gay or lesbian is just another way to be, one that’s neither better nor worse than being straight. In fact, while I was 12 and 13, more than one boy in my grade genuinely thought I was a lesbian because of my outspoken support for women’s rights, and it didn’t bother me.
I have, however, heard “gay” used as an insult, and it always surprises and disturbs me. The first time it happened, I was watching a movie in 9th grade health class, sitting near the back next to a boy that I was friendly with. I don’t remember what the movie was about, but I remember his comment as he leaned back in his chair with a groan: “This movie is so gay.”
I turned to him, surprised. “What?”
“I don’t like the movie. It’s stupid.”
I didn’t particularly like the movie either, but I definitely disliked his use of terms. “Why are you calling it’gay’ to say it’s stupid?”
He looked at me as if he was torn between weariness and wariness. “That sounds like something Katie would say.”
What did that have to do with anything? Katie was a mutual acquaintance of ours-in fact, she was one of my best friends-and she was bisexual. “So?” I said scathingly, and turned back to the movie.
Just Joking?
I’d heard “gay” used as a negative term before, but never by someone I knew and liked. I was honestly taken aback. After that, I began to notice it even more-people used “gay” to describe homework, teachers, or anything else they thought was stupid, annoying, or weird. It seemed so alien to me to take the word for a whole category of people and turn it into an insult.
The people who used “gay” in this way lost a lot of standing with me. you’d think that by high school they’d know better. But it seemed it was considered acceptable to use “gay” as a general negative term, without really caring what this suggested: that to be gay was to be stupid, annoying, or weird.
Maybe my peers’ nonchalance stemmed from the fact that, in the liberal New York community we come from, the only people who seem actually homophobic are either marginal, possibly crazy people like subway preachers, or people from other, less tolerant communities. Under these circumstances, it sometimes seems hard to take homophobia seriously. Sure, we think, there are homophobic people-but they don’t live here. No one will really mind, because everyone knows I’m joking.
A Judgment Deep Down
And, sure, I’m pretty sure that most people in my community don’t actually think gays are bad people. My neighbors generally aren’t like the fervent preacher who once stepped into my subway car and told everyone on board that “The gays will be toasting, and the lesbians will be crispy in hell!”
People like that represent an extreme. But prejudice can come from someone who doesn’t believe that gays are sinful. Even if a person politically supports equal rights, doesn’t using “gay” as an insult imply that some sort of negative judgment is going on deep down?
We should be careful about the judgments we make without realizing it. I noticed my friend making this kind of subconscious judgment when she told me the story of how her younger sister was called a lesbian by a boy in her grade, and the teacher said he shouldn’t call people that. My friend told this story in a way that suggested she approved of the teacher’s response.
“But being a lesbian isn’t bad,” I said.
“I know,” she said. “But-you shouldn’t call people it anyway.”
Why not? I thought. It doesn’t mean anything negative. It’s not a bad word-but it will be, if we keep treating it like it is.
Hitting Where It Hurts
My friend is not homophobic, and yet without realizing it, she was implying that being called gay is a bad thing. It’s similar to when you hear boys telling one another, “don’t be a girl”-which makes me, as a girl, both angry and uncomfortable. If they’re using my gender, my state of being, as an insult, then they’re saying it’s bad to be the way I am.
It’s more hurtful than hearing blonde jokes, though I hear those too. Blonde jokes can be mildly annoying, but being blonde is not fundamental to who I feel I am. I could dye my hair if I really wanted to. On the other hand, if someone were to take a part of my identity I’m deeply connected to-like my gender, race, or sexual orientation-and use it as a synonym for “stupid” or “unimportant,” then the insult would be that much more cruel.
And what’s next? If we already say “gay,” “fat,” “girl,” and “blonde” when we’re trying to be insulting, then what type of people, what state of being will be targeted next? Will it become an insult to call someone “brunette,” “tall,” or “Christian”?
Words Make Meaning
These are unlikely, because those groups aren’t the ones that have tended to be victims of violent discrimination in American society. In fact, thinking about what groups have or haven’t historically faced discrimination makes me reflect that we’d never consider it acceptable nowadays to use “black” or “Jewish” as insults. And those are the very identities have been used as derogatory terms in the past.
Blacks and Jews have gone through enormous suffering because of who they are-from slavery to the Holocaust-and everyone is aware of that history.
Maybe those horrible things were allowed to happen because “black” and “Jewish” (or their synonyms) had been used as insults for so long that people had actually begun to believe that these groups were nothing more than the insults directed at them. Now, because of the atrocities against those groups, it’s no longer acceptable to use “black” or “Jewish” as insults.
My point is that the way we use words influences the way we think. For example, “Lesbian” originally just meant someone who was from the Greek island of Lesbos. It came to mean what it does today because of the Greek female poet, Sappho, who was a lesbian in both the original and modern sense of the word.
Now when we hear “lesbian,” we think of a woman who dates other women. If we start using “lesbian” as an insult, we might hear “lesbian” and think of someone who’s stupid, annoying-and eventually, perhaps, of someone who’s fundamentally bad, or less important than other people. If we start making connections like those, it will without doubt lead to discrimination, and perhaps even large-scale atrocities like slavery or the Holocaust. Nazis labeled Jews untermensch or “subhuman.” We shouldn’t underestimate the power of the words we use to influence the way we perceive things.
So please-next time something disappoints or annoys you, resist the temptation to declare, “That’s so gay.” Think about the power of your words.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.