Several weeks after the September 11th attacks, John Elfrank-Dana, a teacher at Murry Bergtraum HS in Manhattan, wanted to conduct a project to help his students understand what was occurring around them.
Murry Bergtraum’s located in lower Manhattan, less than a mile from the towers, and students and teachers were forced to evacuate the day of the attacks.
But when they tried to get information from the Internet, all access to websites on terrorism was blocked because “terrorism” was one of the words targeted by their school’s Internet filter. “Terrorism” was on the New York City Board of Education’s list of forbidden words.
Federal Law Requires Filters
This is only one of thousands of incidents experienced daily by students doing research via the Internet. They can’t get information they need for projects because of filtering software installed in school computer systems.
Internet filtering software was developed in the early ’90s to keep minors from accessing inappropriate sites. According to the Free Expression Policy Project, 75% of public schools adopted the software before December 2000, which is when Congress passed the Children’s Internet Protection Act, or CIPA.
The act requires all schools and libraries receiving federal assistance for Internet access to use filters on all computers used by teens and adults. According to Section 1711 of CIPA, the filter must block “visual depictions” that are “obscene,” “child pornography,” or “harmful to minors.”
But critics of the filters say that the software is faulty, and often blocks access to non-obscene sites, such as health and sexual identity resources. In addition, instead of screening the obscene sites by content, the filters use keywords to label a site as inappropriate.
“Filtering information defeats the purpose of education,” said Jan Shakofsky, who taught at Benjamin Cardozo HS four years ago. “Responsible classroom computer use requires that the teacher both monitor use and assist students.”
Couldn’t Access Sites On Diabetes
Shakofsky feels that teachers, not programmed software, should be relied upon to make sure that students aren’t accessing inappropriate sites. In September 1999, she discovered that she couldn’t teach computer lessons she’d planned because various sites relating to the material were blocked.
Students were prevented from accessing sites on diabetes and breast cancer (they mentioned the word “penis”), the National Rifle Association, and even John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath (the message read, “explicit sexual content.”)
“In researching the issue of gun control, my class found that they could get anti-gun sites, but were blocked from the National Rifle Association; in researching the issue of abortion, they were able to get the anti-abortion sites, but were blocked from pro-abortion sites,” Shakofsky said.
Shakofsky eventually left the public school system to teach in private schools. Public schools are more likely than private schools to have filtered Internets because they’re more dependent on federal dollars. That’s part of what some people call the “digital divide.”
Less of an Impact On Wealthier Schools
Because wealthier schools and libraries don’t need federal aid as much as poorer schools and libraries do, the impact of CIPA falls disproportionately on lower-income communities, where many families don’t have the money for Internet access, much less a computer, at home. The “have-nots” are then restricted to the access they have at schools and libraries.
According to the U.S. Department of Commerce, in 2000, 51% of all U.S. homes had a computer, and 41.5% had Internet access. But only 23.5% of Black households and 23.6% of Hispanic households had Internet access, compared to 46.1% of Whites and 56.8% of Asians and Pacific Islanders.
Aiming to ease this divide, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a federal suit in March 2001 against CIPA, claiming that it forces libraries to censor constitutionally protected speech.
Able to Access Gay Site
One of the plaintiffs, Emma Rood, 16, a student at Simon’s Rock College, detailed how having unblocked access to the Net helped her deal with being a lesbian. She said she didn’t feel comfortable researching gay sites at home, since she wasn’t out at the time.
But she was able to choose an “unblocked” search at her local public library. She visited PlanetOut, a gay website, and got online advice from other gay teens and adults.
In May 2002, after hearing dozens of testimonies from library patrons like Emma, library administrators, and organizations whose web sites were blocked by library filters, the court lifted the CIPA requirements for public libraries.
But the debate over Internet filtering isn’t over. Appeals protesting the ruling against CIPA have been sent to the Supreme Court. And the CIPA requirements are still in place for schools.
‘Use Media Literacy’ Instead
Free speech organizations and community leaders held a three-city press conference this September to address this issue. Guests at the New York conference included Emma Rood and Danya Steele, a student reporter from the online newspaper HarlemLive. They spoke out against the federal mandates for Internet filtering software, and conference organizers urged the repeal of CIPA.
“Until that day comes, however, we ask that schools turn the filters on to their least restrictive settings and make every attempt to unblock mistakenly blocked sites,” said Stephanie Elizondo Griest, one of the coordinators of the conference and the communications director of the Free Expression Policy Project.
“We would also like for schools to use media literacy education as an alternative to censorial tactics like filtering software.”
To find out more information on Internet filtering software and free speech, log onto www.peacefire.org, www.fepproject.org or www.eff.org.
The Fight Against Internet Filters
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.