The Dropout Dilemma

Why it happens, and what one group of teens is doing about it

Today, about 25% of all students in the United States will drop out of school before getting their high school diploma. For youth in foster care, the dropout rate is close to 50%.
Why do students drop out? The reasons are complicated. Dropping out is often a decision made after years of negative experiences with school. If you’re in foster care, you might be dealing with frequent school changes. Other reasons include failing grades and being held back a grade, feeling bored and unchallenged, dealing with problems outside of school and not getting enough support at school, at home or from peers.
Two years ago, a group of teens in Chicago set out to find out why the overall graduation rate there was so low. The group, called Voices of Youth in Chicago Education (VOYCE), asked more than 1,300 students and hundreds of teachers and parents in Chicago high schools about what they thought the problems were. Then they came up with some solutions, including getting new freshmen connected with supportive teachers and counselors in these schools. VOYCE is now working with 12 schools and hopes many more will benefit from their efforts.
Karen Valles, a 17-year-old junior at Chicago’s Hubbard High School, has been working on the project since it began. She talked with Represent about how the dropout problem has affected her personally and offered some tips about getting back on the right track, especially if you’ve had to transfer schools.
Q: How did you get involved with VOYCE?
A: I had some friends and family members drop out, so I really knew the effects that dropping out can have on your life. It’s a cycle – you don’t wake up one day and decide to drop out. I wanted to be a part of a group that was trying to find solutions.
Q: Tell us about some of the people you’re close to who have dropped out.
A: My brother dropped out. He was a smart guy, but he’d say, “School is boring, what’s the point, they don’t teach you anything you can use for life.” He was cutting a lot of class. He was labeled a “Demo,” which is short for “demotion.” That’s what the schools call someone who doesn’t have all the credits they need to go to the next grade.
Once they have that label, Demos are excluded from many things. He didn’t have a lot of people at school who supported him. He didn’t feel like he could talk to his teachers. He didn’t see the point of coming to school.
When we did the survey, we found out that one thing students really needed and wanted was more support from the school. A lot of students get labeled by the school-for their behavior, their grades, whatever. Those negative labels are really discouraging to students. They start to believe in the labels, and they give up.
Q: Behavior can play a big role in dropping out. Are there things that schools can do to better help a student who has behavior problems?
A: Instead of just suspending students so they’ll be out of school for weeks without having their homework, miss class and not know what’s going on, students need a chance. Instead of pushing them away by suspending them or expelling them, schools need to get to the root of the problem.
Q: If you’ve had problems at school in the past, how can you make a fresh start, especially if you’re transferring to a new school?
A: My advice would be to leave the past in the past. If you’ve had behavior problems, for example, show that you’ve changed, or that you want to change. Start building a relationship with the teacher so that when the teacher asks, “Were you struggling before?” you can say, “Yeah, but I’m not like that any more.”
I think lack of communication all the way around is how kids get onto the dropout track. Sometimes students are scared to ask the teacher for help, especially if they’vehad bad experiences in the past. It’s not just the student’s responsibility-teachers are supposed to be doing the same for us, too. But if that’s not happening, don’t be afraid to approach them. If you’re not feeling good about your grades, your teachers really can help you.
If you’re new, find out what’s going on in the class and how things work there. Talk to the other students. Find out about activities at the school so you have a sense of belonging. Like I said, building relationships with students and teachers will help, even if you jump from school to school.
To find out more about what VOYCE is doing to fix the dropout problem in their schools, visit www.voyceproject.org

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.