The Draft Trap

Now that I’m a freshman at Purchase College, part of the State University of New York, you can find me reading Plato for my Western Civilization class, hanging out at my dorm with my new friends, or getting involved in campus events like open mic night. My first class of the day starts at 10:30, and that class is only on Mondays and Wednesdays. I’m often up late talking with my roommate, finishing a paper that’s due or making a midnight run to the 24-hour diner.
It’s a lot of fun, but I was worried at first that I would never have these experiences. Going to college costs money. Attending SUNY Purchase costs $5,440, and that’s for tuition alone. With room and board, my expenses go up to around $12,500 a year. And that still doesn’t count supplies and personal expenses, like books, snack food and traveling home and back.
I Hadn’t Registered For the Draft
So to help pay for all this, I applied for financial aid. After I filled out the online form for federal financial aid, though, I got an e-mail message saying there was a problem with my application: I hadn’t signed up for Selective Service.
Selective Service registration creates lists of men throughout the United States who could be called up for military service if there were ever a draft. The U.S. stopped drafting young men into the military in 1973 at the end of the Vietnam War, and since then we’ve had an all-volunteer military.
Registration for Selective Service ended two years after the draft did, in 1975. But it was put back into effect in 1980, so that, just in case there ever is a need for more soldiers, the draft boards would have the lists of young men ready to choose from.
On the financial aid form, I had marked “No” to question 28, which says, “If the student is male (age 18-25) and not registered, answer ‘Yes’ and Selective Service will register him.” By checking “Yes,” I’d be putting myself on one of those lists.
Even if I didn’t need financial aid, nearly all males in the U.S. are supposed to sign up for Selective Service when they turn 18. If we don’t, we could face a fine of up to $250,000 or a prison sentence of up to five years. No one’s been sent to prison over this since the 1980s, but with our country at war, the government might decide that now’s the time to crack down. In the meantime, tying financial aid to Selective Service registration is one way the government pressures young men to follow the law.
Sign Up Or Don’t Get Aid
I’m only 17; as the question notes, 18 is the required registration age. But even though I’m not old enough, I had to sign up for Selective Service or I wouldn’t have been allowed to receive any financial aid from the government.
I don’t think it’s right to have to sign up for something that I disagree with.
While there isn’t currently a draft, I still don’t like the possibility of being drafted to fight in a war. For the most part, I am a nonviolent person. I don’t like the idea of fighting with people, let alone going into war and shooting at them.
What if I were against the war I was being forced to fight in, like the war in Iraq? I don’t think that war is being fought for the right reasons. I wouldn’t want to be forced to attack people for a cause I don’t believe in.
It also bothers me that men have to register for Selective Service, but there’s no Selective Service registration for women.
Law Based on Discrimination
In fact, women not only don’t have to sign up for Selective Service, but they can’t sign up if they want to.
I was raised with the idea that women are just as good as men at anything. Women are senators, astronauts and company presidents. And there are currently about 200,000 women in active duty in the U.S. armed forces, almost 15% of the total active force. So why would women be exempt from Selective Service?
The legal reason for keeping Selective Service for men only is that there are many positions in the military that women can’t hold, including combat positions.
But I think the real reason is that old stereotype that men are the protectors and that women aren’t. I know a lot of women who know how to protect themselves better than many men do. To assume that women can’t defend themselves or our country is unfair to them, because it makes it seem as though they are dependent on men.
Taking It to Court
I’m not alone in this thinking, but enough judges and congresspeople stick to the old-fashioned view to keep the system from changing. When President Jimmy Carter reactivated the draft registration process in 1980, he suggested that women register, too. But Congress did not agree with Carter, so when the Military Selective Service Act became law, it covered only men.
Several men sued the government, calling the men-only regulation unconstitutional because it discriminated by sex. But they lost; the Supreme Court ruled in 1981 that the policy was constitutional.
Then earlier this year, Sam Schwartz, 18, his stepsister Nicole, 17, and three of his friends, filed another federal lawsuit against the male-only registration policy.
After Nicole teased him about having to register, Sam looked up the policy and, like me, thought it was unfair. Sam’s father, a lawyer, said he’d help bring the suit to court, as long as Sam and Nicole did the legal research. They thought they had a chance of winning, since more jobs are now open to women in the military.
I Gave In to Get My Money
Unfortunately, in May, a federal judge threw out the case, saying that things hadn’t changed enough since 1981, and that Congress still doesn’t want to draft women. Still, Sam and his friends may appeal; the case reassures me someone is actually doing something about the gender differences in this law.
But feeling like I didn’t have any other choice, I changed my answer from “No” to “Yes” on question 28. I’ve probably been added to the list of people to be processed, and when I turn 18 this December, I’ll officially be on the Selective Service roster.
I don’t like it, but I have to consider my education and I need the money. College is the most important thing to me right now, and I’ll just have to sacrifice my ideals and opinions to achieve what I want.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.