The College Essay: Write from the Heart

Imagine sitting at your table and wondering what to write about yourself to impress someone you’ve never even met. Add to that the stress of feeling like the rest of your life may depend on what you write. For many people that’s what the experience of doing an essay for their college applications is like.
Personal essays are a required part of applications for most private colleges, and some public colleges. Some schools give you a specific question to answer while others tell you to write about anything you want. But all of them want you to use the essay to tell them something about yourself that they won’t find anywhere else on your application.
“The important thing to keep in mind is that the most difficult task an admissions officer has is looking at a folder full of papers and trying to figure out who is behind the papers. That’s where the essay comes in,” said Ed Custard, a former college admissions officer and author of The Big Book of Colleges.
The ‘You’ Behind the Numbers
Helena Ku, college and employment counselor at the OPTIONS program in Forest Hills, agreed. “They’ve seen the numbers-your average, SATs-and they want to get to know the person behind the numbers, what [you] think, feel,” she said.
For Jennifer Fondiller, director of admissions at Eugene Lang College, the essay serves two main purposes: “One is to see the ideas and thoughts that you have. Your personal background and upbringing and also the thoughts you have about the world around you,” she said. “The other is to see the student’s writing ability.”
How important a factor the essay is in determining whether or not you’re accepted “varies from college to college,” Fondiller said. (It’s “very important” at Lang, she said.) But a really good essay can tip the scales in your favor if you’re on the borderline, according to Custard. If your grades aren’t that high, the essay gives you a chance to highlight the other things you have going for you-personal qualities or special talents. And, Custard added, “strong writing always has a positive effect.”
Fondiller agreed. “I do see students who write well, but don’t do well in school,” she said. “We then look at the teacher’s recommendations, etc.”
Think (A Lot) Before You Write
For many students the hardest part of the essay is deciding what to write about. For that reason Fondiller’s advice is to start thinking about it as early as possible. “The summer of your junior year is a good time to start…It might take you three months to figure out a topic,” she said.
Ku agreed. “Give yourself enough time to think about what you want to write because that process might take longer than the actual writing,” she said.
If you think the way to impress admissions officers is by writing about an “important” topic like nuclear energy or world peace, you’re wrong. Write “what you feel comfortable writing about,” said Ku. “Not what you think the admissions officer wants to hear, but what you want to write.”
Everyone I interviewed agreed that it’s best to write about your own life. “I would encourage everyone to write a personal essay,” Custard said. “Why would you choose to give up the opportunity to show the admissions officers why you are an attractive student?”
Keep It Personal
Fondiller agreed. “You shouldn’t pick something you are not personally connected with or an entirely new topic to you. Just pick a slice of your life,” she said.
For example, Fondiller said that when she was applying to colleges, “I lived in a town that was far from my high school, and I had a long commute. I wrote my essay on everything I thought about every day on my way, the people I met and [how] it really shaped my life,” she said.
You should write about something that will “make you stand out in the crowd,” as Ku put it. That’s why Custard thinks it’s best to avoid topics like “How My Coach Changed My Life” or “My Trip to Spain.” “They are too common,” he said.
Writing about a negative experience can work if it had a positive effect on you in the long run. “What you want to focus on [with negative topics] are the lessons you’ve learned and how that experience affected you or might affect you in the future,” Fondiller said.
Neatness Counts
Even though the main purpose of the essay is to help the admissions officers get to know you, they also look at how well you write. “If it’s good ideas without good organization, then it’s not as attractive,” Fondiller said.
It is also very important that the grammar and spelling are correct and that it looks neat. “I have seen essays in pencil where people have crossed things out,” Fondiller said. That does not make a good impression. And the only reason not to type an essay is “if you’re a neat writer, and don’t have access to a computer,” she said. If you do hand write, Custard suggests showing it to someone who doesn’t know your writing to make sure it’s legible.
It’s also important to get feedback on the content of your essay. It’s not cheating to show it to a family member or a teacher to see what they think. But remember that you’re supposed to write about something that’s important to you, not something that’s important to your mother. “Consider the [feedback] of the source, but ultimately be true to yourself,” Custard said.
When you’re done, have someone proofread the final version to make sure there are no spelling or grammar mistakes.
And, although it may seem as if your whole future depends on it, you’ll write a better essay if you relax a little. “Don’t make the writing an ordeal,” Custard said. Fondiller agreed. “Just write from your heart,” she said.

SIDEBAR: What Was the Question?
Here are a few fairly typical essay topics from this year’s college applications: o Select a creative work-a novel, a film, a musical piece, a painting, or other work of art-that has influenced the way you view the world and the way you view yourself. Discuss the work and its effect on you. (NYU) o Submit an essay on a personal, local, or national issue that is of particular concern to you. (Bard) o Describe how your thinking has been influenced by the community in which you live. (Wesleyan) o Comment on the changes that have occurred in your life in the last four years. (Fordham) o Identify a person who has had a significant influence on you and describe the influence. (Wesleyan) o Evaluate one of the most rewarding or unrewarding educational situations-such as a course, a job, or a personal encounter-you have experienced during the past year. What made the situation either rewarding or unrewarding? What has the situation led you to believe about what education should or should not do? (Cornell) o Discuss your goals for the next four years and comment on your post-college plans. (Fordham) o Ask, and then answer, an important question you would have liked us to ask. (Cornell)

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.