Teens Speak Out on Teachers in Their Schools

When I interviewed teens about the teachers in their schools, the majority expressed disatisfaction and said that this is having a great effect on their ability to learn properly.
Keicha Bone, 16, of Martin Luther King HS, said, “A science teacher was teaching math and I failed his class. I felt that it was his fault because… I did my work and I believe that he didn’t grade me fairly. No one wanted to listen to him when he teaches, but I did. He’s a physics teacher and he should be teaching science, not math.”
Fortunately, in my school, Abraham Lincoln, there are very few problems with teachers that need to be changed. One problem, however, is that my school doesn’t have a sufficient number of music and hygiene teachers. Therefore, some students have to wait until their senior year to take these classes because they are too full.
‘Teachers Are Unprepared’
While interviewing teenagers, I asked if there were problems with the teachers in their schools and how those problems could be solved.
Suzanne Lerner, 16, of South Shore HS, said, “Many teachers are unprepared and I feel that they aren’t doing their jobs.”
She added, “We have a sufficient amount of teachers in our school, but they don’t know how to teach; some teachers have favorite students. If you’re not a favorite, then they forget about you.”
One student from Brandeis HS said, “Teachers in my school can’t even handle the class because kids are just too noisy. How can a teacher teach when no one is paying attention?”
I asked a student from Sarah J. Hale HS if the teachers are qualified to be teaching in her school.
She answered, “No, in my school teachers do not teach well, so if some teachers are disqualified from my school, I think the environment will definitely be changed.”
She believes that new teachers need to be hired because the old teachers are letting the students get away with things.
‘can’t Control the Students’
Patrick Bazile, 17, of Prospect Heights HS, said, “The problem with the teachers in my school is that some of them can’t control the students. All they do is let the students talk to each other in the classroom. If teachers could control students, the class would run smoothly.”
He added, “Also, students abuse teachers. There was once an incident where a student punched a teacher in his face.”
He continued: “I cannot personally change these problems with teachers in my school, but I can inform the student organization…and together we can go see the principal. Maybe he can do something about it.”
Can a Teacher be a Friend?
When I asked if they thought a teacher could be a student’s best friend, many of the students said that this could only happen if you pass their tests, come to class every day, and do your work.
Others felt it was impossible to have a teacher as a best friend, because all they do is teach you things you need to know, but they don’t care about helping you with your problems if you want to confide in them.
Jose Flores, 18, of Brandeis HS said, “If you try and share something with a teacher, they’ll pass it to the rest of the teachers.”
Miguel Torres, 16, Graphic Communication Arts, said, “Teachers can never be a student’s best friend because in my school teachers don’t even care about the kids.
“At one time a teacher threw a student out of the classroom, and the kid didn’t like when the teacher grabbed him; after the teacher closed the door, the student punched the window. His hand was cut up. The teacher didn’t even help the student. He let him suffer,” Torres said.
Michael Kingston, 17, of Erasmus Hall HS, says, “Most teachers really don’t care about kids, but I feel if some teachers put more interest in the students, they’ll learn faster. Even if the student doesn’t enjoy listening to the teacher, if she doesn’t get an attitude with the student, at least the student sees that this particular teacher really cares about me.”
He added, “The problems with teachers might be solved if they have a chairperson sitting in the back of each class watching the class and the teacher teaching a lesson, and maybe the class will become quiet.”
Students Have to Help
Collins Dominique, 16, of George Westinghouse HS, says, “If we want better teachers, in addition to hiring new ones, on our part we should be willing to learn.
“The teacher’s jobs are hard as it is, don’t make it any more difficult. We should cooperate instead of talking or fooling around in class, be respectful, listen carefully, abide by teachers’ rules, and avoid staying with the troublemakers and instigators.
“Therefore, not only are we receiving an education, but we are learning how to conduct ourselves mannerly to someone who has authority over us.”
Most of the students interviewed agreed that teachers are not teaching well, but teachers should be given a chance so that they could be understood better by their pupils.
Ms. Gale Brewer, executive assistant to City Council Member Ruth Messinger, feels that the only way school situations can be changed is if students are willing to help.
Working for Change
If teachers are a major problem in your school and if you want to see some changes, you must work together hand in hand with the school administration, she said.
Teenagers must write letters to the Governor, Mayor, State Legislators, the Board of Education, and the Board of Regents and request stricter requirements for hiring and testing teachers. They should request that the entry level salaries of teachers be competitive with those of private industry.
Also, students could encourage the Board of Education to retest teachers to see if they remain qualified in their disciplines.
It might seem difficult at first, but everything takes time before you see progress.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.