Teens Criticize School Survey

Students say Department of Education didn't ask the right questions

“Everything must be filled out,” yelled my homeroom teacher at Curtis HS as she passed papers with envelopes down the aisles.
“What’s this?” mumbled a student behind me.
Others who received the papers were laughing at the questions on them, which asked us to agree or disagree with statements like, “I feel welcome in my school” and “I am safe in my classes.”
We didn’t know what to think. Some people struggled to sincerely answer the questions. Others would have played garbage basketball with the papers if our teacher hadn’t stopped them.
Though my teacher didn’t tell my class about the mysterious surveys, I found out later that they were a part of Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s education reform plan. To collect information from the people most intimate with the ins and outs of New York City public schools, the Department of Education (DOE) gave surveys to 1.8 million teachers, parents and students last May.
“Parents, teachers, and students know better than anyone what their school does well and how (it) can improve,” said DOE spokesman Andrew Jacob in an email.
Missing the Issues
But in May, WNYC public radio station reported that many parents said the survey didn’t touch on critical issues related to schools, like class size and standardized testing. To find out what students thought about the surveys they filled out, the staff of New Youth Connections interviewed about 25 students from high schools around the city who had taken the survey and found that students shared the parents’ concerns.
While many students and student advocates said they were happy that young people’s opinions are being included in the city’s education reform plans, only two students interviewed thought the survey would be effective. The others said the survey process was flawed. And as a result, they said the results couldn’t be taken seriously regardless of what information the DOE gets from the surveys.
When asked to fill out the survey, Keeri Joseph, 16, of Freedom Academy HS, said most students found it “hysterical.” Tristan Reginato, 15, of Beacon HS called the survey “pointless,” and Nydia Palaz, who just graduated from Forest Hills HS, said that students in her school felt the surveys were “not effective.”
Silliness and Confusion
One reason students across the city laughed at the survey was the questions, which evoked silliness instead of seriousness from many students who took it. Students found questions like “How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements about being successful at your school?” too vague and general to seem like anything but busywork. Also, the majority of students interviewed by NYC said many teachers who passed out the surveys didn’t explain what the survey was for, which only heightened student confusion.
A Teen-Led Survey
Youth advocates at the Citizens Committee for Children of New York’s Youth Action group, which is made up of New York area public and private school students, gave out their own student survey in 2006. They were pleased with the insights it provided-they discovered that most of the schools they surveyed had out-of-date library resources, for instance. Youth Action member Grace Chao, 16, a junior at St. Mary’s HS, on Long Island, thinks it was how her group conducted the survey that encouraged students to provide useful information about schools.
Unlike the DOE’s survey, which was administered by teachers-many of whom students say didn’t explain what the survey was for-students handed the Youth Action survey out at schools they attended, and explained clearly what it would be used for.
And unlike the DOE’s survey, which had students answer questions only with an “agree/disagree scale” that many students found odd, the Youth Action survey allowed room for personal comments. Chao said that students are more likely to be candid when they’re speaking with peers and given room to explain themselves. (Results from the Youth Action survey Youth Weigh In are online at www.cccnewyork.org).
When I took the DOE survey, I shared many of the feelings of other students interviewed for this article. As my pen started to fill in the circles of “agree” and “disagree,” I couldn’t help wondering if anyone was actually going to take the time to make sense of my answers.
I kept picturing those “Tell me how I’m driving” signs on the back of buses. You’re supposed to call and complain if the bus driver is driving poorly, but I doubt that people call when they see a bad driver. And even if they do, they probably have to go through so many people to make their comments heard that they might give up.
Would anyone really take the time to look at my completed survey and analyze my answers? Or would they be locked away in a cabinet collecting dust?
Part of a School’s “Grade”
The Department of Education told me that the surveys were going to be used-not just forgotten. The survey given to students, parents and teachers will account for 10% of a school’s “grade,” that will rate how well a school is doing. And survey results should now be available to the public on the DOE website. The DOE also plans to hand the survey out again next spring.
When they do, Chao of Youth Action thinks they might be wise to adapt some of the techniques her group used when conducting their survey: add more “youth-directed questions” to “get a more comprehensive view from the students’ perspective,” advised Chao, and hold “more youth forums so they can see what is needed most.”
The survey results were released as NYC was going to press. To read the citywide and school-specific results, go to: http://schools.nyc.gov/Accountability/ProgressReports/Surveys/default.htm.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.