TAP-ped Out at CUNY

Once again, the City University of New York is facing massive budget cuts. If Governor George Pataki has his way, more than $100 million in state funds will be cut from the university’s operating budget and financial aid programs next year. That would mean higher tuition and fewer services for anyone attending a CUNY school next year.
The governor’s proposed budget for fiscal year 1996-97 recommends a $57.6 million reduction in state aid to CUNY’s 11 senior colleges and a $50 million (or 38 percent) cut in the Tuition Assistance Program, which helps low and middle-income students cover their tuition costs. It also recommends a $250 tuition hike that would take effect in September, making full-time tuition $3,450 a year. (This year’s state budget reduced TAP by 10 percent and forced a $750 tuition hike.)
The financial aid cuts would affect almost 70 percent of the 212,000 students who attend CUNY. Pataki is proposing that a student’s TAP award be reduced in proportion to her federal Pell Grant. According to the CUNY administration, that means students who receive both TAP and Pell Grants could lose between $850 and $1,200 each academic year.
Pataki has also proposed deducting portions of TAP awards from the welfare benefits of students who receive public assistance.
Students Will Be Forced to Drop Out
“The TAP cuts serve as a backdoor tuition hike for the students who can least afford it…Our poorest students could lose up to $850 per academic year. For many of them, that money is the difference between attending college and dropping out,” says Steve Kleinberg, executive director of the University Student Senate, a coalition of student government leaders from the system’s 19 campuses.
CUNY Chancellor Ann Reynolds told state legislators in January that students have traditionally used their Pell Grants to pay for books, supplies, transportation and other living expenses. But the proposed TAP cuts would force students to use Pell funds to help pay for tuition, leaving less money for other expenses. “Increases in such costs will affect CUNY students no less than increases in tuition rates,” she said.
Moreover, the poorest students will be hardest hit by the financial aid cuts. CUNY administrators estimate that 43 percent of the total TAP cuts will be borne by students who earn less than $4,000 a year. And the university estimates that about 12,000 full-time students would be forced to drop out of college if the cuts take effect.
Fewer Courses, More Crowded Classes
In addition to the loss of financial aid, the proposed cutbacks could translate into more crowded classrooms, faculty layoffs, fewer course offerings, less counseling and shorter library hours at most CUNY campuses. “Most of our departments are already running on a skeleton budget,” says Kleinberg. “These cuts will mean the loss of more faculty and class sections, and make it even more difficult for students to graduate.”
Governor Pataki’s proposed budget must be approved by the state legislature in Albany. The legislature can restore cuts and request other changes in the final budget. The governor and legislature are supposed to agree on a state budget by April 1, but in recent years the negotiations have extended several months past the deadline.
Students, faculty and other concerned activists are already organizing against the cuts. The student senate, along with the university’s faculty union, sponsored a series of “CUNY Awareness Days” on each campus in February. The events featured speakers, write-your-legislator sessions and voter registration drives. The New York Public Interest Research Group (NYPIRG), which has chapters on seven CUNY campuses, recently launched its own lobbying and letter-writing campaign aimed at influential members of the state legislature.
Different Ways to Protest
But some student activists are critical of the traditional lobbying approach favored by groups like NYPIRG, the faculty union and the student senate. “Letter writing and lobbying is usually done by student governments and the administration. It doesn’t require much grassroots student organizing,” says CUNY Graduate Center student Robert Hollander, who favors mass demonstrations and civil disobedience as protest tools. He says “there is a lot of cynicism” among students about only writing letters and lobbying legislators to restore funding for higher education.
Hollander is a member of the Coalition for Public Education, a group similar to the now-defunct CUNY Coalition Against the Cuts, which organized a massive demonstration in front of City Hall last March that attracted 20,000 people.
Members of the Coalition for Public Education are planning to organize a joint rally with the University Student Senate and the faculty union on March 21 near City Hall or Wall Street.
For more information about the March 21 demonstration, call the Coalition at (212) 642-2549. For more information about lobbying state legislators, call NYPIRG at 212-349-6460 and ask for Nicole Hospen.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.