Subway Tunnel of Love

I think there’s a cosmic connection between the New York City subway and my relationship with my boyfriend, Tom (not his real name). No matter what train we’re on, we’re either cuddling in the corner-most seat, or at each other’s throat. It’s a love-hate thing between him, me, and that poor stranger sitting across from us.
Maybe we’re so comfortable on the subway because we spend so much time there. I live in Queens. He lives in the Bronx. When we’re together, if we’re not at each other’s house or wandering about Manhattan, chances are we’re on the train.
And one crazy night last February, the second time we hung out, what could’ve been a subway nightmare turned out to be one of the best nights of my life.
‘Get Your Butt Back to Queens’
We’d met up in Manhattan that morning. We joked around, walked through Central Park, and even took the 4 train to his apartment in the Bronx to get me a sweater (it was freezing out). I felt so comfortable-with myself, and with him.
We ended up talking about our past relationships, and Tom was able to see my very emotional side-I cried twice that afternoon. To lighten the mood, we headed back into Manhattan that night to catch the last showing of Euro Trip at 42nd St.
After the movie, I noticed I had, not one, not three, but 12 messages from my mother.
“Danielle, where are you? It’s 10 o’clock. Please give me a call.”
“Danielle, it’s 11 o’clock, I’d appreciate a call.”
“Danielle, it’s 12 o’clock now, and I’m getting annoyed. Call me back.”
“Danielle, it’s now 12:30 and I haven’t heard from you. This is the last time you go out.”
I normally always let my mom know where I am so she doesn’t worry, but that night, I was in my own little world with Tom and I’d thrown caution to the wind. I called her back and tried to calm her down. She told me to get my butt back home to Queens ASAP.
Piggyback to Grand Central
I wasn’t anxious to go home, I’ll admit-partly because I’d have to deal with an angry mother, but mostly because I wanted to stay with Tom.
Instead of just crossing the street to the Times Square station so I could catch the 7 train back to Queens, we decided to walk to Grand Central Station so we could spend more time together. Tom gave me a piggyback ride on the way.
Despite being in trouble with my mom, I was having such a good time with him, nothing seemed to dampen my mood. But our luck was beginning to change. When we got to the station at 1:30 a.m., there was an announcement that the 7 line wasn’t running. I could’ve thrown a tantrum right then and there. On the other hand, now I’d get to spend more time with Tom.
I didn’t know any other trains so I asked a token booth clerk how I could get to Main St. in Queens. She said to take the A to Fulton St., where I could transfer to the Z to Queens.
Instead of just jumping on the 4 train to get to his apartment in the Bronx, Tom decided to see me safely home to Queens. I told him I could manage on my own, but he insisted. It was a nice, gentlemanly thing to do. Instead of a 45-minute ride home that night, he ended up enduring an 8-hour trek across three boroughs.
Right Guy, Wrong Train
We took the A to Fulton St. and sat on the floor to wait for the Z. We could see our breath in front of us. We sat close together, leaning against the back of the staircase.
I tapped my feet against the cold concrete, wishing aloud that the train would arrive. Part of me really did want to be on the warm train. At the same time though, Tom was providing all the warmth I needed.
Half an hour later, it was 2:30 a.m. and the Z still hadn’t shown, so we got back on the A, which goes out to Rockaway, in Queens. On the train, we sat close together again.
It was strange how mutual our closeness had become. Though we’d spent all day together, we’d had little physical contact. Now, as our conversation died down, we were brushing hands “accidentally” and scooting closer to each other. It felt like electricity running through our hands.
“It’d be nice to be in Queens already,” I said. He nodded in agreement. A guy sitting in front of us said, “This isn’t going to Queens. It’s going uptown.” That’s when we realized we’d gotten on the A going in the wrong direction.
A Perfect Fit
We got off and sat in a dilapidated station in the cold, somewhere in Harlem. It was close to 3 a.m., and I figured my mom was cursing up a storm. I was still worried about getting grounded until college, but I wasn’t that aggravated. Had the 7 train been running, I wouldn’t have gotten to spend more time with Tom.
While we were looking at the subway map in the station, Tom stood so close behind me, his body pressed into my back. His fingers entwined with mine. Soon, he had me in a hug. I remember his spicy cologne, and the cold leather of his jacket. His body fit so perfectly with mine.
We didn’t say much; we only savored each other’s warmth. It was slightly eerie in the empty station. Having Tom-this tall, dark, and gorgeous guy-with me, I felt safe and happy.
After about 25 minutes, we got onto a downtown train, which took us to Times Square, right back where we’d started. This time, we were told there was a shuttle bus there that would take us to the Woodside station in Queens.
Waiting for the bus outside, I could see the sky brightening already. We’d spent our entire night traveling, and we were still just in midtown. But I was more intent on staying out of the blowing wind by keeping my body tucked into Tom’s jacket, which he’d wrapped the two of us in.
Exhausted But Happy
I remember yawning and resting my head against his chest. We were both exhausted, but I marveled at his warmth, his solidness, my happiness.
Finally on the warm bus, which had taken its sweet time arriving, we spread out on a bench in the back. I lay on his chest while he rested his chin on the top of my head. We didn’t say anything at all.
I remember thinking, “This is odd. And really nice.” I’d only known him for a short time, yet I felt more comfortable with him than I’d felt with anyone my entire life.
I felt his chin get heavy; I was thinking he must’ve fallen asleep. I must have too, because the bus stopped at the Woodside station in no time at all.
Hugging As the Sun Came Up
Reluctant to leave the warmth of the bus-and each other-we got out anyway and proceeded to the station. Lo and behold, the 7 still wasn’t running. Frustrated, I called my mom and asked her to pick me up. It was 6 a.m., but she was understanding. “Just stay where you are, I’ll be there as soon as I can,” she said.
While we waited, Tom held me in a tight hug. We talked about how we would’ve killed for our warm beds, and how crazy it was that the sun was nearly up in the sky. Soon, I saw my mom’s car driving up the block.
When I told her that Tom had stayed with me the entire time, she said the least she could do was drive him home. He shook his head, said, “Thanks, but I’m good,” and walked across the street to wait for the bus. I think he was just a little embarrassed to hop in a car with my mom. He got home about three hours later.
Braving Four Trains for Me
When I got home at 7:37 a.m., I knocked out on my bed and didn’t wake up until 7 p.m., when a loud ringing cell phone disturbed my dreams. It was Tom, waiting for me in the Main St. station. It was a total surprise.
“Haven’t you had enough of Queens?” I joked with him, after my mom dropped me off at Main St. We took the bus back to my house. Though thoroughly nervous, he said hello to my family and proceeded to my room.
A bucket of KFC and a kiss later, we were cuddling on my bed. I was excited to be with him. But instead of having butterflies in my stomach and a pounding heart, I just felt happy and comfortable.
During the next week, he always called to say goodnight. He also surprised me several times with visits to my house after school. Each time, he braved the 2 and 5 trains, then the 4, and finally the 7 just to get to me, about 2 ½ hours each way. He even came in a blizzard once. We’ve been together ever since.
Savoring Our Subway Time
From our first “I love you’s” to our heated fights, the train holds the biggest memories of our relationship. When we stay at each other’s house, our last moments together before we set out for the day are on the train. He’ll go his way and I’ll go mine, but first we’ll kiss and cuddle and savor our time together before our stressful day starts.
I can’t pinpoint why we feel so at home on the train. Maybe it’s because we’re anonymous-no one knows us, no one can judge us. Tom and I can just enjoy each other’s company in our own little corner, without worrying about anything at all for those 45 minutes. Longer, of course, when we’re delayed.
And when we’re stuck on the train, in the middle of a tunnel, I rest my head on Tom’s chest and remember that night. Everyone around us groans with annoyance, but I hold onto my sweetie. My anger melts away as I say a silent thanks to the gods of the metro for bringing us closer together one fateful night.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.