Students to the Board of Ed: Listen to the Experts…That’s Us!

Students to the Board of Ed:
Listen to the Experts. . .That’s Us!
By Andrea Schlesinger, Student Advisory Member, NYC Board of Education
Young people can’t vote. We don’t have a union. Add that to the way we are portrayed in the media, and you know that we are hardly ever taken seriously. It’s as though we just have to sit back and live with whatever the schools give us.
But we have a right to be heard, just like anybody else. And we need to be heard from because when it comes to education, we are the experts.
When it comes to the schools, we know what adults often just can’t see and it would make their jobs a heck of a lot easier if they would just ask us. And it’s not just the A students, it’s not just the class presidents- it’s any young person who sits in the classroom. That alone makes us experts.
Think about it. You know when you are being taught well. If 70% of the students in a Sequential Math I class do not pass the Regents’ Exam, maybe it’s not the students’ fault. Maybe the math teacher can’t teach. An administrator sitting in on one class to evaluate a teacher isn’t enough. Ask us-we’ll tell you who should and shouldn’t be promoted.
We know when we feel safe. We know where we feel most at risk on our way to school. We know which students carry the weapons and why.
We also have rights. It is mandated that every school have a student government supported by a faculty adviser. The student government is entitled to meet with their principal every month to share their concerns: Why are our bathrooms in such horrible condition? How can we work it out so that student clubs can be given funding? and so on.
Fighting For Our Rights
Students also have the right to demand meetings with district superintendents and with officials at the Board of Education.
Our input can save lives. If you’ve noticed that a school security guard (SSO) is being too lenient with students, for example, you have the right-maybe even the obligation-to say something to the principal. The intruder that gets by the guards may be carrying a weapon, ready to do harm to you or your classmates.
You also have a representative on the Board of Ed. I am the main link between you and the seven adults that make the policy decisions that determine what goes on in your school.
The Board of Ed. does everything from establishing citywide science and math requirements and setting the standards for what makes good teaching to deciding which schools get metal detectors and which ones get a new football field.
Welcome To the Present
The message that I’ve attempted to communicate to the Board, to City Hall, to Albany, and to adults and students everywhere is this: Young people are not just the future, we are the present. There are young people active in their communities now, young people involved in their schools now, young people achieving now, young people succeeding now.
This year we have been able to accomplish a great deal. High school students will soon be allowed to participate in the selection of their principals. A student council has been created to advise the executive director of the Division of School Safety.
The “Guide to Your Board of Education,” a booklet that I wrote based on what every student needs to know about the Board, is available in every high school. Members of the student press have been invited to the Board on three separate occasions to ask questions of Board members and the Chancellor. Bus loads of students have gone up to Albany and met with legislators about giving more money to their schools.
I’m off to college next year, and although the Board can be amazingly frustrating, I leave proud and satisfied with what my peers and I have accomplished. We really have spoken up this year: We have told the Board what we expect of teachers, what we need in our buildings, how we stand on issues like truancy and HIV/AIDS education.
Speak Up, Get Involved
But we need to follow up. I ask of those of you who are not yet involved that you start demanding those meetings, start asking the people in charge hard questions. Whatever is on your mind as a student is valid, and should be heard.
If you have questions about what’s going on in your school, or the school system in general, if you want to talk about your school’s student government or just find out the number of someone in charge you can contact the student member at 718-935-3300.
The Board is not going to introduce themselves to you. Many adults don’t feel that they have to reckon with us until later when we become the future. It really is up to you to take the first step. And it’s not necessarily going to be easy. Even as a Board member, I’ve encountered those who aren’t willing to listen. I didn’t give up, and I ask that you don’t either.
Eventually adults will learn.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.