Students Speak Out on Metal Detectors in the Schools

Compiled by Tanya Wade, Kyeeniah Nix, and Michelle Weston
We put the following question to students from four New York City high schools:
“The board of education plans to install metal detectors at your school next fall to search students for weapons. Do you think this is necessary?”
Shana Haughton, 15, Andrew Jackson HS: “No, because then it causes too many problems. First of all, what if you have keys in your pocket? It takes too much time. They don’t bring [weapons] into the school, anyway; they don’t use them in school.”
Ray Burton, 18, Prospect Heights HS: “In a way it’s necessary,’cause it will stop a lot of students from bringing in weapons. The bad part about it is students will be treated like prisoners.”
Adrian J. Tapia, Prospect Heights HS: “I don’t feel that it’s necessary, but if it’s gonna be for the safety of the students, I’m for it.”
Tijuana Wright, 16, William E. Grady HS: “I feel it’s necessary because the school will be much safer and the new kids will feel safer in a new environment to walk around and get an education without worrying about someone trying to rob them.”
Lucrece Rene, 17, Andrew Jackson HS: “We need books. They’re gonna turn [school] into a prison. It’s gonna waste a lot of time. They’re losing the basic point of education. Some people feel secure in school, because everything happens outside of the school.
“I’m totally against it. They’re saying it’s for our own good, but it’s creating a problem. Most of the incidents happen outside. The people who do it don’t even go to this school. They come from the South Side. It’s only going to bring down Jackson’s name further.”
Jason Johnston, 18, Graphic Communication Arts HS: “No, because a lot of kids carry weapons just for protection. The bad kids don’t get caught, because they don’t come to school.”
Terron Curry, William E. Grady HS: “No, I don’t, because it’s making the school look like a jailhouse. It gives the school a bad reputation.”
Michael Eckford, 15, Andrew Jackson HS: “Yeah, ’cause a lot of kids be bringing guns and knives to school.”
Angela Smith, 17, Andrew Jackson HS: “No, ’cause I think that students should be able to carry anything they like into school. Even if it’s dangerous. The reason that I don’t want [metal detectors] is because I carry a weapon myself.”
Tanisha Cueto, 16, Graphic Communication Arts HS: “I don’t think they need it. Most of the fighting takes place outside of the school. There are no weapons really being used, because everybody knows they’ll get caught. More security guards should be outside of the school.”
“Broadway Joe,” 18, Graphic Communication Arts HS: “I feel that it is unnecessary because there have been no incidents with guns in the school. Other schools have more problems than ours. It would be a waste of money. They should concentrate on what’s going on outside.”
Gertrude Saintilaire, 19, Prospect Heights HS: “I think it is good’cause that protects everybody. Sometimes you have students from outside of the school that come in the school just to bother other students.”
Collie Gilles, 16, William E. Grady HS: “I think it’s right to get the detectors, because it will put a stop to intruders coming into the school with weapons and it will protect the people inside and make them safer. However, I dislike it a little because they [the guards] will search you for every little thing that goes off and you might have something personal on you.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.