TANYA GARCIA, 18, formerly at Fashion Industries HS, now at South Brooklyn Community HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“Pretty safe, safe enough. I wasn’t afraid of anything really [at Fashion Industries].”
Has anyone ever used a weapon against you at school?
This one time [at Fashion Industries], some girl had me against a wall with a broken Snapple bottle to my throat. I don’t know if that’s considered a weapon, but she did it because she didn’t like the way I dressed.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“No. [At Fashion Industries] they had a’see no evil, hear no evil’ policy. Students always brought weapons into school. This one kid even brought a sword in his coat.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yeah. They weren’t fair [at Fashion Industries]. I was using the bathroom once, and this security guard actually looked over the stall to see if I was really using the bathroom.”
If you could change one thing about the security system at your school, what would it be?
“Maybe to pay more attention to the students that had past offenses. The [Fashion Industries guards] ignored a lot of what was going on.”
ILYA VAYSBERG, 15, New Dorp HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“I feel safe enough because bad stuff doesn’t happen. But it used to happen. Before, some of my friends smoked weed right inside the school on the staircases and stuff. And now Bill Gates gave a million dollars to the high school-the school got more security and put up cameras, security guards and just became more safe. It’s a pretty good school now.”
Has anyone ever used a weapon against you at school?
“No, nobody has used a weapon against me in school. There’s security guards everywhere and they watch for people who do that kind of stuff. I don’t know anyone who has guns and stuff but I’m sure people still bring them.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“The school does not have metal detectors. But occasionally, like every two weeks or so, they do check with metal detectors before the students come in. Teachers get notified that there will be a search the next day and they tell the teachers to tell the students. They also announce it over the [loudspeaker] sometimes.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yes we do have security guards in our school and they do watch out for students who do anything wrong. If somebody gets caught smoking outside, they take their IDs and names down and take them to the deans’ office. I think they’re fair because from what I’ve heard from my friends [who go to other schools], their school security guards kick them out or get them into trouble for no reason.”
JUNIOR MELENDEZ, 17, Jacqueline Kennedy Onasis HS (JKO) and John Jay HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“I felt safe. It was a small school and in the city. Things popped off, but I never felt personally in danger.”
Has anyone ever used a weapon against you at school?
“Not at JKO, but in John Jay there were some kids that were supposedly going to stab me, but nothing ever went down.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“Not in JKO, but in John Jay they did. The metal detectors didn’t stop much, mad people still brought weapons in, like razors in their mouths, sneaky stuff.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yeah, every school in NY has security guards. In JKO they were cool, but in John Jay they treated every kid like a criminal. They were on some 007 stuff for real.”
YAHAIRA RIOS, 17, South Brooklyn Community HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“I feel safe because this school is a good environment to be in. Everybody gets along with each other, and if anything is bothering you, you always have your counselor to talk.”
Has anyone ever used a weapon against you at school?
“No, because I don’t get into problems. I come to school to get an education and to finish.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“No, because they want us to feel like we are trustworthy.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yeah, but only one. She is fair and understanding, but we don’t have many problems in this school.”
If you could change one thing about the security system at your school, what would it be?
“Nothing. The security system in my school is good.”
HASAN HOAKE, 17, Benjamin Cardozo HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“Somewhat safe, but I’ve seen guys bring in guns, batons and knives.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“No.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yes, we have security guards. They play favoritism. If they know a student, they’ll help him cut school.”
If you could change one thing about the security system at your school, what would it be?
“I really don’t want metal detectors but I want a better discipline system. It’s too lenient.”
DANA INNAB, 16, John Adams HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“Not [safe] because there are always fights occurring, even after all the security guards. There are like two fights a day, and that isn’t safe.”
Does your school have metal detectors?
“Yes, but it doesn’t really stop the students from carrying weapons, like fire crackers and a gun wrapped in foil paper that they hide in their bags.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yes, but they aren’t fair because they have their favorite students that they let get away with murder.”
If you could change one thing about the security system at your school, what would it be?
“Everything, because it sucks all together. The staff, because they are the ones that deal directly with the students.”
NIA JAGROOP, 17, Benjamin Cardozo HS
How safe do you feel at your school?
“I feel pretty safe with the security guards.”
Do you have security guards at your school? How fair are they?
“Yes [I have security guards at my school]. They are too strict, especially when it’s uncalled for. It’s not necessary to be so severe for little things.”
If you could change one thing about the security system at your school, what would it be?
“I would like them to be more lenient with hall passes and lunch admissions.”
Speak Out: School Safety
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.