Fatima Johnson, 17, Central Park East HS
Have you ever felt you didn’t belong?
“Yeah. I went to New Hampshire for the summer and the people around me excelled in their academics so much that I felt I wasn’t on the same level as them. I felt a lot lower.”
What’s something about yourself that makes you feel different from others around you?
“My beauty mark on my face. A lot of people used to say I have a mole, but after a while I learned to embrace it.”
Have you ever found that others see you differently from the way you see yourself?
“When people talk about politics I always second-guess myself and it makes me seem like I’m not focused.”
What makes you who you are? Do you think it’s possible to change that?
“What makes me who I am is how I care for everybody. I can feel bad for someone I don’t even know and I would never change that.”
Agnieszka Gugala, 16, Stuyvesant HS
Where you born into any groups that you identify strongly with?
“I was born here, but my parents were born in Poland. I very strongly identify myself with the Polish culture because I went to Polish school and my parents raised me around a Polish community, so I feel more Polish than American.”
Have you chosen to belong to any groups?
“For a couple of years, I went to Polish school. It was like supplementary education in Polish history, literature and geography. It helped me keep a sense of community.”
Name something you’re good at. How does it make you feel about yourself?
“I’ve been playing the piano since I was very young. I also like the liberal arts: painting, photography and things. They’re like a sense of self-worth and finding yourself.”
What makes you who you are?
“Art is about expression, so my art would define me.”
How would you answer the question “Who are you?” in only three words?
“‘I am Agnieszka,’ because my name is Polish and it says a lot about me. I’m the only Agnieszka in my school.”
Ida Lim, 19, Brooklyn College
What’s something about yourself that makes you feel different from others around you?
“I like Marvel comic books. I don’t like anime or manga, but I like comic books. It’s typical of Asians to like manga and anime. I refuse to go near anime and manga!”
Have you ever found that others see you differently from the way you see yourself?
“It sucked. I was alienated from the Asian group. This was in junior high school. They didn’t like me because I looked different. They thought I was mixed, like part Korean or something.”
How would you answer the question “Who are you?” in only three words?
“‘I am learning,’ because I don’t know everything in the world yet so that’s what I’m constantly doing.”
Chastity Land, 17, Central Park East HS:
Were you born into any groups that you identify strongly with?
“I was born into a black family. It’s important because you learn from their experiences in life.”
Name something you’re good at. How does it make you feel about yourself?
“Writing poetry. Seeing my thoughts and feelings on paper makes it easier for me to be myself.”
Can you remember any experience that changed how you saw yourself?
“When I was 8 years old, I was in the bathroom looking in the mirror and I was complaining to my mother about physical characteristics I didn’t like about myself. My mother was saying how I should love who I am and stop complaining because I can’t change who I am.”
What makes you who you are? Do you think it’s possible to change that?
“The experiences I had in the past, my family life, trusting myself and staying true to myself. Imma always be who I am.”
How would you answer the question “Who are you?” in only three words?
“Different, intelligent and me.”
Gladi Hazizaj, 16, Brooklyn International HS
Have you chosen to belong to any groups?
“Soccer-the group is like part of my family.”
Name something you’re good at. How does it make you feel about yourself?
“Helping, taking care of my friends, makes me feel really good about myself.”
Can you remember any experience that changed how you saw yourself?
“Losing my friend. My best friend died. I’m quieter now. I don’t curse or get into fights.”
Have you ever found that others see you differently from the way you see yourself?
“I see myself as fat. They see me as skinny.”
What makes you who you are? Do you think it’s possible to change that?
“Being Albanian makes me who I am. It may change when Hell freezes.”
How would you answer who are you in only three words?
“Controlling, because I want my way. Smart, because I know everything. Pretty, because I am.”
Michael Grosman, 19, Baruch College
Were you born into any groups that you identify strongly with?
“I was born into the life of the collapsing Soviet Union. I lived there for ten years of my life. Everyone lost their money, including my parents. It was like you woke up”-[claps]-“money was gone. It made me value things more. I grew up in the projects: Some days water, other days no water. There was a band of kids I was with. Every day was an adventure.”
Have you ever felt like you didn’t belong?
“Every day of my life, but in a good way. You don’t belong so you identify yourself with other people who don’t belong. And then, what do you know, you belong.”
How would you answer the question “Who are you?” in only three words? Why did you choose those words?
“I’m still thinking, because there is no definite way to define yourself. When you grow up it keeps changing. You don’t define yourself until you’re lying on your deathbed and by then you’re probably done thinking.”
Jane Gayduk, 16, Staten Island Technical HS
Were you born into any groups that you identify strongly with?
“Russian Jews, because I’m an immigrant from the Soviet Union. Gotta keep the pride.”
Name something you’re good at. How does it make you feel about yourself?
“Dancing. It makes me feel good. If I didn’t have dancing I would hate my life. Dancing takes the attention away from schoolwork and other stuff.”
What’s something about yourself that makes you feel different from others around you?
“I can put my leg behind my head. Most people are impressed by it. Especially the male gender.”
What makes you who you are?
“I am an overachiever, school-wise, life-wise. I want to be perfect, get good grades. I don’t think I’m doing a good job. It’s really stressful trying to be perfect, but I wouldn’t be myself if I didn’t do that.”
Pedro Diaz, 17, Central Park East HS
Were you born into any groups that you identify strongly with?
“Yeah, Hispanic. I grew up around Puerto Ricans.”
Name something you’re good at. How does it make you feel about yourself?
“I’m good at video games. I play games on the low, but don’t tell nobody. I’m a huge gamer and it feels great sometimes.”
What’s something about yourself that makes you feel different from others around you?
“I guess my personality. I have a laid-back personality.”
What makes you who you are? Do you think it’s possible to change that?
“Nobody hates me. I’m laid-back and I doubt someone could change it.”
Speak Out on Identity
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.