As an 8th grader, I chose to go to John Jay HS for its law and justice program. I wanted to be a lawyer and heard the program had a great reputation. I knew people who’d gone there and were pleased with it.
But I wasn’t aware that John Jay might close; if I’d known, I wouldn’t have gone. I was accepted to other schools, and I could’ve gone to either of my zoned schools, Franklin K. Lane or Thomas Jefferson.
Instead, starting September 1999, I took the A and F trains from my home in East New York to John Jay.
John Jay takes up a whole block and when I started there, it had nearly 3,000 kids. At first, I was intimidated because of how many kids there were. But I soon appreciated Jay’s size because I met a lot of different people and liked getting lost in the crowd.
In the beginning, freshmen had to travel together to the same classes, including lunch, so we got to know each other pretty well. I soon made close friends.
Like Pieces in a Puzzle
Jonelle, the N’Sync-loving loud one, was the organizer. Gloria was the “bodyguard,” always willing to step in and fight. Selina, the overachiever, was the one I looked up to for inspiration. Tasia, with her dark sense of humor, seemed rude when we first met, but I soon realized it’s to cover up her shyness.
Beautiful Tanesha, the envy of many girls in school, turned out to be very down to earth and my home girl to the end. Nakeisha and Kemoy were the inseparable politicians, pure feminists, ready to debate something until their point was proven.
David was a clown and made us all crack up. And Sceon made me laugh, too, because he’d play girls right in front of them and be so obvious that they’d allow it.
I was the “little one” in the group, the “shorty” who was always singing and who people came to for advice. It was as if each of us was a piece in the puzzle that made up our group.
‘Drama Jay’
There were a lot of different crowds at Jay, including gangs, and we often knew who had beef with whom, especially when girls from rival groups had catfights in the halls. Because of all that, we started to call our school “Drama Jay.”
But my freshman year was the last time John Jay HS was really John Jay. I heard talk from staff that our school was going to close, but I didn’t take it seriously. None of us did. I guess we thought if we didn’t pay attention to it, it would blow over. But it didn’t. [See “Why Did John Jay Close?” below.]
Over the next two years, teachers started leaving without any notice and taking jobs in other schools. Teachers with no seniority were asked to leave. We felt cheated and deserted, and we called them traitors. But we knew that some of them had to go or else they’d be fired.
I Felt Abandoned
When my guidance counselor left, I felt abandoned because she knew me personally. She’d gotten me into a challenging science research class and helped me get into Upward Bound, which is a college preparatory program.
She was replaced by a former math teacher, and the remaining students were shared by her and another counselor. Of course with all the changes, people had problems with their schedules and grade changes, and it took forever to see a counselor.
Then my science research teacher left in the middle of the year and the class was canceled. I was working hard in that class and I felt like I did it all for nothing.
The spring term of my sophomore year, we got letters informing students and parents that the school was closing and that we could transfer starting the following September. At special assemblies, the principal assured us that we could graduate with a John Jay diploma and that they’d make our last years at Jay as livable as possible if we stayed. But he also said it might be better for us if we went elsewhere.
Our Puzzle Was Breaking Apart
John Jay HS students soon became a limited commodity. Students who didn’t pass all their subjects were discharged from the school, and Jay stopped taking incoming freshmen.
Tasia, Nakeisha, Kemoy, and other friends transferred to other high schools spring semester because they couldn’t deal with all the changes or because their parents thought it was best.
It was a sad time for all of us. It was hard to talk about because we didn’t really want to think about it. Our tightly fitting puzzle was being broken apart.
By February junior year, the law and justice program-the reason I chose to go to Jay-was no more. That made me angry. I felt like I didn’t know what to do with my life all of a sudden. Both John Jay’s college counselor and the director of my Upward Bound Program thought I should transfer.
I thought about leaving, but I couldn’t go through with it. What if I didn’t like the other school? Plus at Jay I still had friends. Jay was home to me. I felt accepted and comfortable there. I didn’t want to leave and start over again.
Sometimes I Wished I’d Transferred
At times, though, I kicked myself for not transferring, because it got stressful when we started losing our classrooms and floors to the incoming school.
The new school, called the Secondary School for Law, Journalism and Research, wasn’t even a high school, but went from 6th to 9th grade. Two existing middle schools were combined and moved to our building. Each year, the secondary school adds another grade as each class is promoted until it becomes a full high school and middle school.
The “new school,” as we called it, took over our third and fourth floors, two of our three gyms, and most lunch periods.
Invasion of the 12-Year-Olds
It was a real shock to see 12-year-olds walking around my high school. The principal said we weren’t to go near them or go on their floors, like they didn’t want us to contaminate them. But they were our floors first!
My big, exciting school was shrinking. I felt suffocated and frustrated. “Drama Jay” held its name, just not in the same way. It was the drama of being forced to close.
Now it’s senior year and I barely know what a real school is like. We’re restricted to one floor now, plus the basement. We hardly have teachers because most of them were either “excessed” or left because they knew they had no future at Jay.
I feel the changes most in the morning. This last term, John Jay students are down to one table at the lunchroom to wait for the first period bell. The whole lunchroom has been taken over by little boys running around playing tag and little girls drooling over the Jay boys in a space that once belonged to young adults.
A Proud John Jay Survivor
I’m mad that the Department of Education shut down my school. I think they should’ve let the last of John Jay graduate before letting a new school come in. There would’ve been a lot less confusion. I feel that they didn’t care enough about how it might affect us, and that’s wrong.
Still, I feel good being one of the John Jay “survivors.” I don’t regret the decision I made to stay. At least now I know I’m capable of going through major changes without completely falling apart.
And because of it all, my remaining classmates and I are like a big family. As the classes got smaller, I became closer to the people in my classes and got to know people I probably wouldn’t have when the school was bigger. Smaller classes also meant fewer distractions and more class discussion, and I got more attention from my teachers.
I still succeeded-I’ll most likely be going to St. Johns University next fall-and I’m happy. Jonelle, Gloria, Selina, Tanesha, David, Sceon, and other friends I’ve made since freshman year will be graduating with me. We’re still close, and because of that, even if our school no longer exists, John Jay will live in my memory.
SIDEBAR: Why Did John Jay Close?
For years, school board members, local politicians, and neighborhood parents had argued that John Jay was a troubled school, with low Regents scores, many suspensions, and even police incidents. The attendance was lower than average for New York City high schools, and its dropout rate was above the average. John Jay’s troubled academic performance wasn’t the only reason for shutting it down. Our teachers told us that Park Slope parents didn’t feel comfortable sending their children to the school. They wanted a neighborhood high school, but not John Jay. That made me feel like something was wrong with me and the people in my school. I knew that some of the kids were bad, but not all of us.
Outsiders in Wealthy Park Slope
Park Slope is one of Brooklyn’s wealthiest neighborhoods, with a majority White population. But most of us at Jay were people of color, with very few (less than 5%) White students attending. And most of us came from low-income neighborhoods like Sunset Park, Crown Heights, Red Hook and Cypress Hills. We didn’t spend much time in Park Slope, but sometimes we got angry looks from people in the community, and comments about us making too much noise when we weren’t. Once, a woman walked by me and my friends in the train station and then backed up with a scared look on her face, as she said, “Please don’t touch me.” That made me think that people in the neighborhood were ignorant and racist. I thought we were being judged unfairly. No Worse Than Other Schools John Jay seemed like a regular high school to me, no worse than any other school. There were classes we worked hard in and some more laid-back classes where we felt like we could just chill. Jay had plenty of extracurricular activities, like teams, clubs, chorus, band, and community-service organizations. Sure, sometimes there were fights, but that’s true of a lot of schools. The worst thing I remember happening freshman year was a security guard getting slashed with a knife after she got into a fight with a student. But District 15 decided to reclaim John Jay HS by creating smaller schools within the same building. And that meant the gradual termination of John Jay itself.
