If you want to be a journalist someday, if you’re planning to write for a newspaper or a magazine, you’re probably asking yourself this question: should I major in journalism in college?
I asked myself this many times as a senior at Andrew Jackson HS in Queens.
I choose the liberal arts route when I entered Michigan State in the fall of 1984. My major was English literature with a secondary concentration in philosophy and religious studies. I chose a liberal arts major because I wanted to get as well-rounded an education as possible, and I didn’t think I could get that if I was required to fill large portions of my schedule with journalism classes.
However, my choice of English literature as a major did lead to occasional problems and confusion.
Avoid a Narrow Focus
Throughout college, anytime I told anyone my major, I got a confused stare. Most people who questioned me had a very narrow idea of the possible career interests of an English major. They all thought my major indicated that I wanted to be an English teacher, and they would ask me why I chose this profession.
don’t become a victim of narrow-minded thinking. Unfortunately, many students do allow their undergraduate major to define their career goals. Too many students who major in business limit their vision to careers in major corporations, and too many journalism students think the only job they want is to be the anchor on the 6 o’clock news.
don’t let yourself be molded by your major. Instead, mold your major, whatever it may be, to fit your needs. Make it work for you. Deciding on a major that doesn’t categorize or stereotype you won’t harm your future career in journalism. If anything, it will make you more attractive.
As a liberal arts major, you’ll stand out from the crowd of journalism majors, and, by working hard, you’ll be no less prepared than they are.
My experience indicates that I’ve made the right choice. To date I’ve had four internships with different types of publications, from daily newspapers to monthly magazines. It obviously hasn’t hurt me in terms of employment, and if marketability after college is a primary concern (as it should be), then don’t worry about it.
Advantages of Liberal Arts
The advantages of being a liberal arts major are many. As a liberal arts major, you are limited only by the amount of creative thinking and aggressiveness that you can muster.
But remember, you are not receiving the same professional training as your friends in the journalism school, so you must find ways to get that training on your own. One option is to actually take a few journalism courses as a part of your degree program. At Michigan State I enrolled in an introductory course, and I found that it was all that I needed to send me on my way.
After that, I aggressively sought professional internships to deepen my training and experience. By simply applying what I learned in that basic news writing course to one internship after another, I was able to improve and expand upon my skills.
One point that must be emphasized is that having a journalism degree is not some “golden key” that will magically open doors for you. It may help, but experience on the school paper and in internships is more important. You can get experience in journalism regardless of your major.
For me, a greater sense of academic freedom was another advantage of being a liberal arts major. Although my major was English, I actually found myself more interested in religion and philosophical ideas. Majoring in liberal arts gave me ample opportunity to explore areas of personal interest. Unlike some of my friends majoring in journalism, I found myself satisfied with my degree program.
‘A Waste of Time’
While working for the campus newspaper I had ample opportunities to question fellow reporters who were journalism majors. Too often I heard students say, “If I had a chance to do it all over again I would never major in journalism, because it was a waste of time.”
Another advantage is that whatever you study as a liberal arts major will probably relate in some way to your profession as a journalist. Studying philosophy as an undergrad in college required writing papers. In these papers, I was expected to take a difficult topic and write about it in simple everyday language so that everyone could understand the concept that was being discussed.
If, for example, you’re hired to work for a science magazine aimed at grade school kids, you’ll have to take difficult scientific concepts and explain them so that a 10-year-old can understand them. So, writing philosophy papers can have direct relevance to writing for newspapers or magazines.
In-Depth Research
The ability to do in-depth research on a topic is another advantage to being a liberal arts major. History courses that I took in college sometimes required that I look up information from numerous sources. In addition to using an encyclopedia, I also became acquainted with sources like the Reader’s Guide to Periodical Literature and The New York Times Index. I often use both of those resources in my work as a journalist.
The only disadvantage was that because I wasn’t enrolled in Michigan State’s School of Journalism, I was sometimes treated as an outsider. I can still vividly remember arguing with the department secretary, who thought that the fact that I wasn’t a journalism major should bar me from going to job fairs for students who were journalism majors.
The most important thing to realize is that there simply is no royal road to a career in journalism. People get into journalism through a variety of routes. One major is just as good as another, as long as you take the initiative and do lots of writing while in college.
Sheridan Honore, a former NYC reporter, recently graduated from the Graduate School of Journalism at Ohio State University and is now a reporter for the Lansing State Journal in Lansing, Michigan.
Should Aspiring Journalists Major in Journalism?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.