Sex Ed: Questions About Condoms

While brainstorming topics for this Sex Ed segment, the other teen writers and I realized that despite school health classes, we still had questions about condoms. A lot of us had heard that the NYC condoms, the ones you get for free in school, aren’t as good as the ones you buy. I even heard that some bored kids would poke holes in them, which sounded horrifying. We also wondered if the Magnum condoms were really bigger. So I decided to do some investigating.
We have NYC condoms in our office so I headed off to Duane Reade and bought two different types: Trojans and Magnums. Back at the office, I stretched them over my arms so I could compare the differences. To me, the Magnum didn’t feel bigger than the others. They just felt stickier. It seemed that the plastic was thicker and more rigid than the Trojan, and the NYC condoms were the most flexible. All three went up to about the same place on my arm. The NYC condoms definitely felt as strong as the other two. From my admittedly crude experiment, it seemed like it was just a matter of what feels more comfortable but they all fit about the same.
I also spoke with Kristin McDonough, the director of the Adolescent Health Center at The Door, a New York City-based program that offers various services to teenagers.
YCteen: Are the free NYC condoms as good as the brand name ones or do they break more often?
Kristin: I’ve heard the free NYC condoms have gotten the reputation as ones that break more often but they are made by Durex, a common brand. In terms of effectiveness, they’re all the same.
YCteen: How can you tell if a condom breaks?
Kristin: Sometimes it pops like a balloon, plus you can see it. We get patients who are concerned that maybe there was a teeny, tiny hole. That is very unlikely. However, depending on what you were doing exactly at the time it breaks, you might not feel it, so you want to look at it after having sex. It will look obviously broken.
YCteen: What should you do if a condom breaks?
Kristin: I would suggest there be a conversation about getting STD testing. I also recommend that girls get Plan B.
YCteen: Can you still get a sexually transmitted disease when you use a condom?
Kristin: There are some infections that can be transmitted by skin-to-skin contact. If there’s an infection on somebody’s body and that’s not covered by the condom and it touches the other person, it’s possible. But wearing a condom significantly reduces the likelihood that even that infection would get passed.
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.