Separate Is Not Equal

The phrase “separate is not equal” was heard during the civil rights movement in support of racial desegregation of schools. The theory behind segregation-that Blacks and Whites could receive a “separate but equal” education-was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1954.
There is no such thing as “separate but equal.” Segregation in any form breeds ignorance and ignorance breeds prejudice.
Therefore, all students should be mainstreamed. By putting students who are disabled, pregnant, or homosexual into separate schools, we lose a chance to achieve mutual understanding.
The intention may be to help such minority groups, but what actually happens is that misconceptions about them are increased. The only possible way to correct misinformation is through contact and communication that bring diverse viewpoints together.
Hiding Students is Not the Answer
I am not ignoring the oppression that is part of the experience of all minority groups. Yes, students who are gay, disabled, or pregnant are often victims of abuse from classmates. But hiding them in a separate school is not the answer.
There are some practical values to separate facilities: barrier free schools for mobility-impaired students, schools like Harvey Milk HS which provide shelter for victimized gay students, and schools for pregnant and parenting students that can provide medical facilities and day care.
But these facilities and programs can and should be provided in every public school to enable the successful integration of all students.
Granted, these students also need to get emotional support from those who share their disabilities, sexual preference, or parenting responsibilities. However, support groups and clubs within already existing schools would provide forums to help these students cope.
Mainstreaming simply means that the characteristics that supposedly set some students apart are not the focus of their existence. An individual is a human being before anything else. By creating separate schools, this fact is ignored and the process of mutual understanding is brought to a standstill.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.