Xavier Reyes went to regular school before entering foster care. After he entered foster care, Xavier was placed in special education because his teachers did not think that he was doing well in regular classes.
Xavier was having problems. Living in a group home. It was hard for him to concentrate on school. “I had too much going on in my group home to worry about some teacher,” he says. He would often end up in the dean’s office because he never paid attention or was hanging out with the wrong crowd. But he doesn’t think that special education was the right placement for him. And once in special education, it felt like he would never go back to regular classes. He felt stuck.
Nearly one-third of foster youths in New York City surveyed by Advocates of Children reported that they are receiving special education services. That’s a lot. And more than half of those kids were not in special education before they entered foster care. No one knows for sure why so many foster teens in New York City are in special education, but child advocates agree that it needs to explored.
Educators say that special education is good for troubled teens. The point of special education is to provide support and extra services to youth who have a disability, so they can learn the same information and skills as other kids. The disability could be physical, it could be a difficulty understanding or organizing information, or it could be an emotional disability.
An emotional disability is when you’re too unhappy or angry to function in school or at home. “An emotional disability doesn’t have to be something you’re born with-kids who live in war-torn countries develop emotional disabilities because the human mind is not intended to cope with what they face,” says Diana Autin, executive co-director of the Statewide Parent Advocacy Network in New Jersey. “Kids in foster care deal with many strong emotional issues both before and after they come into care. Those experiences can lead to developing an emotional disability.”
Getting Extra Help
It is true that a teen placed in foster care has issues to address, like the problem with not living with family, being faced with the fear of homelessness after being discharged from care, even having difficulty socializing with others in the foster care environment. It can be a lot to deal with having been abused or neglected, as well. Special education is supposed to help, because students can get more attention in small classes, or by getting extra help during class.
But a big problem is that special education does not always work like it’s supposed to. In New York City, the vast majority of kids in special education are supposed to stay in a regular classroom, learning the same thing as other kids. The school is supposed to bring supports to them in class, Autin says. And even if they do go to separate classes, youth in special education are supposed to be learning the same material, taking the same classes, and learning just as fast as other teens. Teens in special education need to take the same classes and the same Regents to graduate.
Special Ed Can Be a Trap
But kids with behavior problems are often sent out of the classroom and put in separate classes or schools. Often, those classes are much easier than regular classes. “If kids are being removed from their classrooms, that probably means that their rights were violated,” Autin says.
Special education places the teen in a trap that is very difficult to get out of. It’s hard to get out of special education and back into regular classes. In the last 10 years, only about 1 in 10 students in New York City who were between 14 and 21 got out of special education and into regular school. For foster kids, the rate is much lower. Only about 1 in 50 foster kids in special education get moved back into regular school.
Staying in special education may have long-term consequences, according to The Least Restrictive Environment Coalition. Lots of people in special education don’t graduate on time, or ever. In New York City, only about 2% of kids in separate special education schools and 9% of kids in separate classes graduate in four years. Having a high school diploma is the main ingredient to finding a better job to become self-sufficient. Many foster teens have to start supporting themselves in their late teens. How can they do that without finishing school?
When a teen is placed in special education, and the class is too easy or out of control, it can be very frustrating. When Xavier went into special education, he found it very difficult to function. He said, “Now I was living in two hells, one at home and one at school. The kids acted out in special education. I had to watch my back all the time. Fights would break out everywhere, either between students or the teachers. It was like going to school in prison. I would see kids being restrained all the time.”
Xavier was in special education classes for three years, and his education suffered. “What was repulsive was what I was being taught,” Xavier said. “All the work was like two grades below where I was. I aced all my exams. Special education tied me educationally.”
We Need Support-In Regular Classes
Xavier wanted desperately to get out of special education. He made sure that he did all the work that was assigned to him, even if it was boring and too easy. He remembers, “I didn’t belong there, I had to prove myself to my teachers to get out.”
Then he turned to his advocates and to a lawyer to help him get out of special education. He was fortunate. Eventually he got out of special education and received his high school diploma.
But few foster teens are able to get out of special education like Xavier did. And those who aren’t getting the right services are likely to drop out of school and have more difficulty making it on their own after leaving foster care. If schools are really dedicated to helping foster teens succeed in life, they should provide foster teens more support in regular school before sending so many of us to separate special education classes or schools.
SIDEBAR: Special Ed and Your Rights
Diana Autin, executive director of the Statewide Parent Advocacy Network in New Jersey, explains your rights in special education.
Q: How do schools decide if a kid should get tested for special education?
A: Under federal and state law, special education is only for certain defined categories of disabilities. Students have to have one of those disabilities and it has to affect their ability to learn to the point that they need special education services. Sometimes kids are referred for evaluation because there are race or cultural differences between kids and teachers, and teachers misinterpret a kid’s behavior. Often, it’s because adults don’t want to deal with kids who have challenging behaviors.
Q: Who has to approve you getting tested or placed in special education?
A: Anybody in a school can refer you to get tested. Parents can also refer kids, or students can refer themselves. But the evaluation cannot be conducted unless a parent or guardian signs a consent. Once a student becomes 18 they sign for themselves. For a child in foster care, a parent can sign, or if a parent’s rights have been terminated, the child has to be assigned a surrogate parent by the school district. That surrogate parent is someone who is not employed by the foster care agency or the school. It can be a foster parent, but it can’t be a social worker or case manager. One of the problems we hear about a lot is that people who work for the foster care agency are signing consents, and that’s against the law.
Q: Do teens have a right to be involved in planning their education?
A: When a child turns 14, the school has to start talking to the child about transitions-what to do after finishing school-and make a plan to provide services that will help a child become a productive adult. After 14, children have to be invited to their educational planning meeting so they have a voice in that process.
