Science Teaching Doesn’t Have To Be a Flop

Beyond those science classes that put you to sleep, beyond those math classes that had you drawing sketches of your teacher hanging from a tree, beyond those boring and tiresome lectures is the Medical Club at I. S. 183 in the Bronx. It teaches science beyond what is normally expected in any public school. It adds a window of knowledge to a windowless classroom.
I know of the Medical Club firsthand because I was in it myself, and I could tell you it was a great adventure.
When other teachers were tearing my papers in front of class, or throwing me into a small room to threaten me, the Medical Club was the only place where I was treated fairly. It was a place where I fit in.
A Teacher Who Believed in Us
Under the supervision of Mr. David Hemans, a group of screw ball kids, including myself, went to Lincoln Hospital and visited the dentist department, the x-ray department, childbirth, childcare, etc.
We went to the Red Cross Center and did what wouldn’t be expected of us if we didn’t have Mr. Hemans. We passed the CPR and First Aid tests with flying colors. We went to Hostos College where we dissected rats the size of cats, along with baby pigs and frogs.
They didn’t treat us like children who would cut themselves unless under supervision. They let us dissect the animals and observe the insides, and they answered our every question in detail.
We all worked together. We made sure we all had our lessons down pat. We all protected each other.
Mr. Hemans was the teacher that made this possible. He took this class of kids from the South Bronx and made us believe in ourselves. When other teachers would call us “hopeless cases,” Mr. Hemans saw that we belonged and stood with us in that windowless classroom from 3 to 5 in the afternoon, helping us, pushing us, believing in us.
Today’s Medical Club is not much different. When I visited to interview the new club in the white building called Paul Robeson, they were learning about stress, although it was parents’ night.
Mr. Hemans hadn’t changed one bit. He was still as tall as a basketball player, and as helpful as a encyclopedia. I felt the positive energy as he sat with me for the interview.
“I’m not quite sure why the kids stick with it,” Mr. Hemans said. “I know the work is real hard. Passing grades are 80s instead of 65s. You go from 9 in the morning to 7 at night with a lunch of 15 minutes, but students seem to volunteer to want to do it.”
When asked about problems with teaching math and science, he replied: “Most students aren’t allowed to be creative enough in math and science. I think Blacks and Hispanics will do better if they are given a chance to express more of their creativity.”
Learning by Doing
He compared teaching math to teaching someone how to drive a car.
“Instead of doing chalk and talk, have students doing something all the time. Okay, here’s an example: you’re in a car and someone takes you some place and you don’t drive. Then they say, `David drive.’ Would you get there most of the time? No. But if I put you in the driver’s seat and coach you, you would.
“Science is the same way. If I teach you something and tell you about it, then it’s like you’re in the passenger seat. But if I let you do it, then you’re in the driver’s seat and you’re more up to learn how it came about it.”
He also believes that students should be aware of the contributions their ancestors made. “Like the Egyptians were doing brain surgery in ancient Egypt. Egypt is part of Africa. The contributions people made in Puerto Rico and that kind of stuff. You’ll feel better about yourself.”
Although the Medical Club had grown in size, it hasn’t changed much.
“It’s a lot of fun. You learn a lot of things to help people,” said Rivera.
A. Perez said the Medical Club “encourages more students to come to school.”
Anothony Horsley likes the Medical Club because “the teacher is fun,” although he thought Mr. Hemans told “corny jokes.”
Saurez said it showed him a different side of science. “I wasn’t interested in being a doctor until I started the Medical Club,” he said.
M. Ford said he would use what he learned in the Medical Club to aid his uncle who has heart trouble: “By me learning CPR and First Aid I can help.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.