I go to a failing school. No, not a bad school, a failing one. My school, Humanities Prep, is actually pretty good when compared to the citywide average. For the past two years, 100% of its graduates have been accepted into college. And while the New York City public school dropout rate is about 11%, Prep’s is around 5%.
You might ask, “Why, then, is Humanities Prep failing?” The answer: the No Child Left Behind Act, which is forcing schools to emphasize tests like the Regents more than ever before.
Same Standards for All Kids
No Child Left Behind (NCLB) is the update of a federal act that provides money to the states for education. Championed by President George W. Bush and passed in 2001, NCLB continues to provide federal dollars for schools. But in addition, states are now required to test students in math, English and eventually science, and set standards for improvement, or “adequate yearly progress,” for their schools. One of the main ideas behind the law is to push schools to make sure all their kids succeed-especially the kids who tend not to do as well in school.
If schools don’t meet the standards, they are required to make drastic changes. After four years of failure, schools may have to replace teachers and administrators, increase the school day or year, or get someone besides the principal to help run the school. If a school fails for too long, it can have its registration revoked, and that puts it out of business.
More Must Pass Regents Exams
Here’s the way it works: If enough kids in any one school pass all the tests and meet any other requirements that the state sets, then the school is said to be making adequate yearly progress. But if they don’t, then the school is said to be failing. (Exactly how many students need to pass the tests differs from state to state).
New York State uses the English and math Regents to judge a school’s NCLB performance. Humanities Prep, a small alternative school, was declared failing because not enough kids in the school passed those Regents exams in the 2002-2003 school year.
In order for a school to make the grade this year, at least 40% of all students in a school’s class of 2004 need to pass both the English and math Regents. As the years go by, the bar will be raised higher and higher. The state also judges a school by the percentage of students graduating in four years.
A lot of people have problems with this method of judging a school’s success, especially teachers and principals of alternative schools, who have spent years fighting the use of Regents as exit exams (tests that you have to pass to graduate).
The Regents exams, they say, really just measure kids’ test-taking and fact-memorizing abilities, and aren’t accurate measures of what a student has learned or whether he or she is ready for college.
Tests don’t Work for Everyone
“Kids have different ways of exhibiting knowledge,” said Vincent Brevetti, principal of Humanities Prep. Some kids may have decent English, math and science skills but just don’t do well on the tests.
Instead, schools like Humanities Prep prefer what’s called “performance-based assessment.” We call them senior portfolios. Instead of taking one test to determine whether we’re accomplished enough in a subject, students write a paper or put together a collection of our work (like essays, papers and presentations).
Supporters argue that portfolios show more relevant skills-like writing, research and understanding complicated themes-than standardized tests do.
Urban Academy is a portfolio school, too. The school didn’t require students to take any Regents exams until this year, and still doesn’t give the math Regents.
Despite the fact that Urban has a strong college acceptance record (97% of all graduates enter college the year after graduation), it’s also failing to make adequate yearly progress according to NCLB. That’s because New York State makes completing a portfolio assignment equal to getting a 55 on the Regents-which is failing.
Will We Lose Creative Courses?
The principals of these two alternative high schools, as well as many other critics of the law, say that NCLB forces schools to improve test scores-but that doesn’t necessarily improve students’ education.
According to Brevetti, the law’s emphasis on test scores is pressuring teachers to teach more to the test, and that’s taken its toll on the curriculum. In English classes, he said, assignments and questions are now modeled more to teach the test, rather than to inspire creativity or interest.
I believe it’s important that teachers have some space to experiment and do what they think the students need instead of being locked onto a set path. Last year, at my old school, Robert Louis Stevenson School, I took a class called “Contemporary Social Issues.” Students were more energetic than usual during this current events class, and we had some lively arguments over issues like assisted suicide and the death penalty.
This interesting class wouldn’t necessarily get taught in most schools where kids have to take the Regents, but it might at Humanities Prep. Right now I’m taking Spanish history, human rights and journalism, among other courses.
Under NCLB, where there’s so much pressure to have all the students pass standardized tests, schools may not take these kinds of liberties with their classes and students might lose interest in learning.
Ann Cook, the principal of Urban Academy, believes that Congress didn’t pay attention to what works best in education when it passed NCLB. “It’s a political policy, not an educational policy,” she said. As a result, Cook doesn’t take the label “failing” too seriously. “Part of me feels like if we weren’t on that list, I would be almost offended.”
Challenges Ahead
For the principals of New York City’s schools, NCLB is asking a lot. Most schools will have to drastically improve their students’ performance on the Regents. Some schools, especially alternative ones, will also have to make large sacrifices in the way they teach just to get that done.
Brevetti said he’s working on ways to make sure that Regents testing and NCLB won’t stop Humanities Prep from providing the kind of education the school prefers for its students. “We believe Prep will outlive NCLB,” he told me.
But Urban Academy’s Ann Cook has decided to risk going against the demands of NCLB. “We are confident that we are meeting standards and that we are preparing the kids for college-level work, and we are prepared to stick with that,” she said.
No matter how the No Child Left Behind adventure unfolds, many say that for better or worse, NCLB marks the beginning of a new era of standards in educational policy. Attempting to make every student in the country skilled in math, science and English in just another 10 years, which the law claims to do, is an enormous-many would say impossible-task.
Schools Under Pressure
Federal law demands higher test scores
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.