Schools Get an `F’ in AIDS Education

How many times have you sat on the train and seen an advertisement warning that unprotected sex puts you at risk of getting the AIDS virus? Most of us will say: too many times to count. But is that enough?
The AIDS virus is spreading among teenagers because many of them don’t know how to protect themselves. The best protection against getting the AIDS virus comes through education, and that requires much more than subway ads. The entire school system has to become involved. However, very few schools teach students about AIDS.
Education Is the Best Protection
They mainly covered things like pregnancy and diseases. We never really got to it [AIDS],” said Delveeta Flaherty, 17, of Bronx Science HS. “We may have discussions outside of school, but we didn’t get anything in class. Most of what I know is what I hear about, or see on TV.”
Denise Stokes, 17, of Hunter College HS agrees that she gets very little “real” information about AIDS at school: “Most of the stuff I know about it is from the media and basically, the stuff we learn about it in school is more technical and obscure information.”
The New York City Board of Education currently mandates that at least six lessons be given on AIDS education in grades 7-12. But some students only get these lessons in one grade and forget what they learn. “The information was useful for the time, but that was a couple of years ago,” said Dexter Wimberly, 17, Brooklyn Technical HS.
New Aids Curriculum
The Board of Education plans to update and expand the current AIDS curriculum by focusing on developing skills for students to protect them-selves, making condoms available to students, organizing training sessions for teachers, creating an educational brochure, and providing a resource directory on community-based services. The idea is to get students exposed to AIDS education as early as possible.
Dexter agrees: “[AIDS Education] should start as early as possible…at any age when kids are exposed to anything having to do with sex-the television age really.”
Andy Humm, a member of the AIDS advisory council to the Board of Education and the director of education at the Hetrick Martin Institute, said that the AIDS education curriculum in New York City needs to be revised. He said the council “started to realize that there was no real comprehensive vision for AIDS education in the schools.” The council made thirteen recommendations to Chancellor Fernandez about improving AIDS education, including one that condoms be made available in the high schools.
The Board Gets an ‘F’
At a meeting, the chancellor said, ‘I give us an “F” in implementing the existing AIDS education’ and he said he would make the recommendations a priority,” added Humm.
Meanwhile, health education teachers have to decide for themselves just how much more AIDS information to give their students. “Teachers have to do a lot on their own,” said Carol Phillips Stallings, a health and physical education teacher at Martin Luther King HS. Stallings has created a very comprehensive AIDS curriculum, including workshops and guest speakers who talk to the students about AIDS.
She said that at first, students weren’t interested. “They felt like they had enough about AIDS on TV, in the newspapers. Then I had guest speakers come in and they…brought the picture home so they could relate to it.”
Students agreed that guest speakers make a difference: “I really would like to meet a person with AIDS firsthand and be able to talk to him or her about it,” said Denise.
Lillian Dvostep, a health educator at Hunter HS feels AIDS education at Hunter is working.
Anika Gibbons, 17, of Hunter College HS recalled taking Dvostep’s class in the tenth grade: “[It] was taken seriously because things like AIDS and sex were taken seriously. At first, she [Dvostep] got giggles from the class, but when we found out that AIDS kills and anyone can get it, then everyone was quiet.”
Students Have Misconceptions
Dvostep said that during group discussions, she finds out that many students have misconceptions about the disease: “They were very surprised oral sex could transmit the virus…A lot of the adolescents express the fact that they may not go all the way, but they will engage in oral sex.” Dvostep let them know that they can get the AIDS virus through oral sex.
While Dvostep is confident that her students know enough about AIDS to protect them-selves, she noted: “I have no doubt that they know what to do, whether they do it or not is a different story.”
“There are some good teachers out there who are doing a great job and are making it happen,” said Humm. But he added that some teachers are “afraid of talking about it and don’t want to get in trouble. They just don’t want to deal with the grief.”
Students in the alternative high school program are now receiving an in-depth AIDS education with the help of people like Julie Beck and Beth Bomze. Beck is the new HIV/AIDS coordinator for City-as-School and Beth Bomze is the health educator for the AIDS Education Initiative Program for the Alternative High School Superintendency. (This program is funded by the New York State Department of Education.)
Speakers, Skits, Videos, and Trips
The program has just started, but Beck is planning a lot of interesting ways to get AIDS information across to students, including a student-produced video, trips to neighborhood clinics, and a student-produced brochure about HIV and AIDS.
“What we’re doing is a much more comprehensive kind of endeavor because we’re making it interdisciplinary, so eventually we’ll have an art component, [and] we’ll have lessons in history and social studies.”
She plans to invite several guest speakers to the program. “Kids are already saying they’re getting very straight, honest information which no one has shared with them before,” said Beck.
Bomze works with actors from the Creative Arts Team at New York University who go into the classrooms and act out situations dealing with safe sex and AIDS. In addition to the show, the students have the opportunity to “get advice on how to protect themselves and they can ask me, as the HIV coordinator, questions about AIDS and HIV,” said Bomze.
The school system needs to be a lot more committed to AIDS education because teens are still not getting the message that unprotected sex is deadly. On January 23, the Board of Ed will vote on the new AIDS curriculum, including the proposal to make condoms available to students.
“What we’re after is getting everybody’s attitude toward AIDS changed. The hard thing is to get young people to admit that this is their problem,” explained Humm.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.