Whenever Alex, 17, sees the big blue van parked in front of his school, he knows that they are “scanning” again. With his blade tucked securely under his belt buckle, Alex walks in anyway.
After the guards select him to be scanned, he stands on line until it’s his turn. The guard tells him to empty out all of his pockets onto a tray. Then he searches Alex’s bookbag thoroughly with a stick. Finally, he takes a hand held metal detector and passes it over Alex’s body, from head to toe.
The device beeps twice when it passes Alex’s waist but the guard assumes it’s just his belt buckle and Alex goes off to class. “Kids will bring in weapons in any way they can,” he explained. “[In] shoes, behind zippers, pants, belt buckles, blade pieces in their mouths.”
Scanning currently goes on once a week at 19 public high schools with a history of shootings, stabbings, and other violent incidents. The program, which was started in 1988, was an attempt to keep weapons out of schools.
After two students were shot inside Thomas Jefferson HS in February, Mayor Dinkins and the Board of Education announced a plan for a new expanded security system that will include scanning every day, more guards, and conflict resolution programs. It will be brought into 40 high schools over the next year and a half.
Sneaking Through Is Easy
But teens from schools that already have scanning know that the system doesn’t work. First of all, too many teenagers, like Alex are finding ways to pass through the inspections with weapons.
In the girls’ room of a school that scans its students, Taisha (not her real name), 17, showed me a five inch jagged knife she had smuggled in her bra. Then she pulled out a beeper (also metal and also against the rules) and two switchblades. Taisha admits to sneaking them in “every day.”
Another student showed me how she hides her razor from the metal detectors by concealing it under the metal buttons on the sleeve of her jacket. Still others said they place weapons in their boots, behind zippers and metal buckles, and in the brims of their hats.
“Sneaking through metal detectors is easy,” claimed Alexa, 17, who told me she has walked through with a switchblade on occasions when they were scanning. Laura, 16, who once got a razor past the scanners by hiding it in a sanitary pad inside her bookbag, agrees. “When there’s a will, there’s a way,” she said.
If the purpose of once-a-week random scanning is to catch students off guard, that too has failed. Students at schools where they scan say they can recognize the tell-tale signs.
It’s Totally Predictable
“Usually [they scan] on Tuesdays and Thursdays,” said Asmodeia (not her real name), 16. But she knows for sure because “they always have a blue van and cops out [in front of the school].” She also said there was often a stranger hanging around outside trying to look like a student. Once they’ve scanned, everyone knows they won’t be back for the rest of the week.
Even when they do scan, the schools don’t scan every student. By law they don’t have to. But according to Board of Education spokesperson Bob Terte, guards are supposed to pick the students who do get scanned entirely at random, using a set system like stopping every third or fifth person.
In spite of the official policy, some guards pick who will get scanned and who won’t based on the way they look.
For one thing, guys get scanned more than girls. “They look at guys and think of us as a violent percentage,” said Alex.
Alex admitted that guys tend to be more violent than girls but “the guys ask the girls to hold their weapons. The girls are treated with more freedom than guys, when it comes to scanning.”
Too Sexy To Get Scanned
A few girls I interviewed said they never get scanned. Asmodeia says girls don’t get scanned when they look “innocent” or “sexy…guards try to make passes at girls by letting them go [through].”
Several students said the guards also decide who to scan based on how they dress. “If you look like a hoodlum with gold teeth or if you don’t look decent they will scan you,” said D’eidre, 17.
Asmodeia agrees. “They scan people who [they think] look like criminals, metalheads, hip-hoppers, dangerous [looking people] and people they aren’t sure about,” she said.
But according to Alexa, who hardly ever gets scanned, that’s not the greatest system. “They usually pass me by,” she said. “And I’m the wrong person to let pass by.”
Another thing that either helps you or messes you up is if the guards know you. “I see them favoring certain students,” said Laura. If you’ve been in the school for a long time or are friendly with the guards, there’s a good chance you’ll get in without getting scanned.
“[The guards] act too friendly for their own good,” said Alex. They’ll also judge you based on your reputation or your friends. Alex said that “the people that hang with gangs or known troublemakers, or people who were busted before with weapons” will probably get scanned.
Hassles With the Guards
Sometimes, guards will hassle people for reasons that have nothing to do with weapons. Timothy (not his real name), 16, said when one guard saw the heavy metal tapes in his bookbag he asked, “Have you lost any of your hearing yet?”
D’eidre recalls the time when “I had a key chain that said “wine me dine me 69 me” and the lady asked if I was sexually active.”
The scanning program is so flawed in so many ways that the students I spoke with do not think it makes their schools any safer. To make it work, we would have to be scanned every day and also have programs that teach teens to resolve conflicts without violence, programs that let teens be heard, that teach teens to respect themselves and each other. Even then it might not work, but at least it would be a step in the right direction.
SIDEBAR: Safer Schools Depend on Students
People at the Board of Education are aware of some of the problems with scanning. “Nobody said it was perfect,” said spokesperson Bob Terte. “We can’t take kids and shake them upside down to find weapons.” He described the program as a “short term effort” to try to reduce violence in the schools. “Metal detectors [are] not the final answer although it helps,” Terte said. Since scanning began in 1988, serious incidents have declined more dramatically in schools with scanners than in those without them, according to Board of Ed. statistics. Since September, 1,779 weapons have turned up in and around schools with scanning in place. But Ed Muir, director of school safety for the teachers’ union (UFT), says, “There are always ways to beat any system.” Muir said a lot of new weapons are being made out of plastic and metal detectors are useless against them. “[There’s] no way to keep out all the weapons,” said Muir. “I’d be happy [just] to keep out guns.” While I was in his office, Muir got a phone call about an incident in which a student was stabbed and another was caught with a gun at Springfield Gardens HS, where only days earlier another student had been accidentally shot in the hip. (Springfield Gardens does not have scanning.) Muir sounded really fed up. “This stuff used to be at Jackson,” he said into the phone. “What’s going on?”
Positive Peer Pressure
Both Muir and Terte spoke of the need to get at the root of the problem. “We must convince kids that there’s other ways [to resolve conflicts]” said Terte. “Life is too precious to waste because one kid stared at you or stepped on your sneaker.” Terte mentioned the need for multicultural education and anti-bias programs that help students learn to accept each other. He talked about the need for smaller classes, better guidance services, and a “user friendly” faculty. But most of all he stressed what he calls “positive peer pressure” or letting students who don’t carry weapons influence those who do. Terte said schools need more student “mediators” trained to help other teens settle disputes before they become violent and more kids who take some responsibility for what’s going on in their schools. He said even the new, tougher scanning system won’t work unless it’s coupled with educational programs about guns, violence, and ways of resolving conflict peacefully. Muir said those programs need to begin in elementary school. Besides educational programs, the city’s new security plan will include daily scanning in 40 schools and more security guards and police. Muir says they will have a computer that uses “chaotic random selection” to pick the students who get scanned in unpredictable ways. There’ll be special devices to X-ray bookbags, and electromagnetic exit doors with a 30 second delay that will give security guards time to find out who’s sneaking in or out of the building. Finally, he said if he has it his way, anyone caught with a gun in school will be subject to a mandatory one year jail term “no questions asked.”
