School Insecurity

“Hurry the hell up! You’re holding up the lines,” a pudgy-faced security guard yelled at no one in particular. It was 7:45 a.m., the first Wednesday of September 2000, the first day of my freshman year at South Shore HS.
When I arrived, I was shocked to see about 200 boys lined up to the right of the front entrance and 300 girls lined up to the left. As I joined the girls’ line, more students began to file into the school. It began to look like Eastern Parkway on Labor Day.
I had envisioned school staff happily giving us guided tours and information about the school. Instead I saw grumpy security guards. Everywhere. Yelling orders. I began to feel uncomfortable and nervous.
“Take off your belts, hats, doo-rags, keys, any fake jewelry y’all got on and any change y’all have inside your pockets. Or else y’all going back outside!” yelled one female guard. I started going through all my pockets to see if I had any change in them. I took off my belt and watch and placed them inside my bag.
Felt Like a Criminal
When I walked through the scanner, I heard it beep and I was sent to another security guard who held a wand in her hand. She grabbed me and told me to put my arms out in front of me. She moved the wand all over my body and found nothing.
I felt like I was a criminal being searched by the police, but I tried to relax and forget about it. I realized that this was something I’d be doing every day for the rest of my high school career.
I chose South Shore HS because it’s close to my home in Canarsie and I wouldn’t have to worry about arriving at school late because of bad weather. My parents didn’t care where I went to high school as long as I did well. I had heard rumors that South Shore was a problem school with unruly kids and trouble with violence, but I figured all schools see their share of troubles.
Fights in the Lunchroom
After my first few days at South Shore, I began to get used to the school. I made new friends, and I started to enjoy all the school had to offer. I liked the teachers and my classes. Most of the freshmen were kind and friendly.
It’s a big school-more than 2,000 students-with lots of activities and clubs. I eventually got involved with cheerleading, the Student Organization and the Humanitarian Club.
But it wasn’t unusual to see or hear about fights in the school, most often in the lunchroom. Boys would jump each other and roll around on the floor trying to pin one another, throwing punches that mostly missed their target. Girls would pull each other’s hair, scratch and punch. And if things got really bad, friends of the fighters would jump in, and it would turn into a mob scene.
Some students destroyed school property, too-writing graffiti on walls and ceilings and trashing textbooks and lab equipment.
Looking Over My Shoulder
These incidents, even when they were small, made me feel unsafe in school. Even now, I feel like I’m always looking over my shoulder to see if some angry kid is throwing milk cartons or acting crazy in the halls. It doesn’t affect my work, but I don’t like having my guard up so much in school, a place where I should feel safe.
Because of the fighting, part of me is glad that we have airport-style security to keep students from bringing weapons into school. But the school also has lots of restrictive rules that make me feel trapped. And I don’t like feeling constantly watched by guards.
My first week at South Shore, we got letters informing us that there were to be no electronics-walkmans, CD players, cell phones and MP3 players-brought into the building. My school has pay phones, but we had to get permission from a guidance counselor or a teacher to make a call.
We couldn’t carry glass bottles, either. That I understood, since they could be used to harm someone. Still, the letter didn’t provide any of the reasons behind the rules. We were just expected to obey them.
Too Many Rules
We also had to have a pass from a faculty member for access to the school’s library. We had to swipe our ID cards to get into the lunchroom. And once you left the school building, you could not reenter without permission from a teacher. I felt that they were treating us like we were in elementary school.
The rules made me mad at the school because I felt that the administration didn’t respect us. But I was also mad at the students who caused trouble, ruining it for the rest of us.
At times I found the little disruptions at school entertaining, like people acting stupid in the hallways and guys trying to talk to girls through the glass windows on classroom doors. But major incidents made me annoyed because I knew that the school would soon be taking away one of our privileges.
One June, when it got hot in the building, groups of students had water fights, throwing water balloons and squirting each other with water bottles. Soon after, there was a new rule: no water bottles allowed in school. We could either buy juice from the vending machines or try to drink water out of the gummed-up water fountains.
Security Tightened Its Grip
But while the water fights were mostly foolishness, some incidents felt more serious. Sophomore year, one student stabbed another. People still don’t know how he got the weapon through such “tight security” and into the school building.
The stabbing made me more concerned about my safety. I felt that a heated argument with the wrong person could get violent. I was cautious about offending others and became more aware of people around me.
But I told myself that this kind of thing happens even in the best neighborhoods and schools. And it wasn’t so serious that it took time away from my schoolwork and activities.
Then I felt bad in a whole new way when security tightened its grip. Some mornings, security made us take off our jackets and put them through the scanning machine. It was cold outside, and the lines were long.
If we went through the machine and it beeped, we were sent to another security agent who now made us hold onto tables and lift our legs as they scanned the bottoms of our feet. I guess they thought that students could stash weapons inside their shoes.
Havoc and Confusion
While they were doing this for our safety, I felt as if the guards were dominating our lives. The teachers were also fuming. A day wouldn’t go by without at least a handful of students being late to class because of the security lines. Some students wouldn’t even get to class until second period.
Teachers often had to stop their lessons to open the door for a student arriving late to class. And they couldn’t penalize us because it wasn’t our fault.
The tighter security at the entrance didn’t prevent some students from causing damage in the school. Last year (my junior year), small fires began to pop up all over the school. Someone would light sheets of newspaper on fire and leave them to burn in an empty staircase; the smoke caused a strong odor in the hallways. Students also broke the hallway’s glass display cases and set their insides on fire, leaving scorch marks on the walls of the school.
These fires created havoc and confusion within the school, and when the building was evacuated, we lost time from our education. I felt unnerved.
Cameras in the Halls
After the fires, more security guards were placed on duty, patrolling almost every exit on every floor. They caught one person who set the fires but not everyone; after he was caught, the fires continued.
This fall, when I returned to school, there were cameras at certain exits. To protect students’ privacy, the administration won’t install cameras in the locker rooms or bathrooms. I appreciate that, but many of the fights happen inside the locker room, so the cameras everywhere else won’t help much with violence.
It’s a shame that we have to go through so much to get an education. Both misbehaving students-and the rules and security measures meant to control them-are disruptive and demoralizing.
The majority of the students at South Shore are well behaved. It’s just that the troubled ones create such big problems that it seems as if the whole school is filled with criminals.
What’s the Solution?
What’s the best way to make South Shore a more pleasant school? I’ve heard some teachers suggest that the school should be shut down and started from scratch. I agree. The school would get emptier as each grade graduates. Then, when the final senior class graduates, the school could begin accepting new students.
Only students who are serious about their education would be allowed to attend. The school could then earn a reputation for excellence and good students.
I know the school system has a responsibility to educate all kids, even the ones who are destructive to the school atmosphere. But if a student hates school and is forced to go, he or she will only make trouble and cause distractions for other students.
If the school got rid of troubled students, it might help the rejected students to go to smaller alternative schools where they would get more attention-and fewer opportunities to disappear into a crowd.
For now, we probably do need our scanners and security guards, but I wish we didn’t. About 65 New York City high schools have scanners and metal detectors, but more than twice as many high schools-many of them smaller schools-don’t have these high security measures.
Not What High School Should Be Like
Something does need to be done to make the school safer for everyone. But the current approach of the school officials-rules upon rules and intense security-is not the way to go about it. These methods only add to the anger and hostility that students already feel. And it would help if the guards were nicer and more even-tempered; most of the time, there’s no need to yell.
Although this high security environment doesn’t affect my schoolwork, I don’t think this is what high school is supposed to be like. My friends who go to high schools without so much security seem to have more fun in school than I do. They don’t get hassled by guards and don’t have to wait on long lines to get into school. They just go in.
There’s no reason why South Shore couldn’t become an excellent school. Surrounded by shady trees in a great neighborhood, it’s got many extracurricular activities and some wonderful teachers who care about their students. This is my last year of high school, but for the sake of future students, I hope the school can become a more welcoming place to learn.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.