Scholarship or Scam?

Don't get ripped off

When I got home from school one day in April, I discovered a thick, creamy envelope that had come in the mail for me. My name was on the envelope, written in loopy cursive letters, and there was a fancy, prestigious-looking seal over the envelope’s fold. Naturally, I was intrigued by such a classy-looking letter, so I ripped it open excitedly, as if it were a Wonka bar and the golden ticket might lay inside.
“Congratulations,” the letter said, “You have been selected for admission into the National Society for High School Scholars, a scholarship selection foundation.” Wow! Was it really true? Was I being recognized for how amazing I am? Finally! How had I never heard of this organization? After reading through some impressive sounding credentials, I came to the end of the letter. Uh-oh.
“In order to solidify your admittance into our prestigious organization, please send a check or money order of $60 to our national headquarters.” Under the text was a list of various NSHS merchandise I could purchase, like a T-shirt or a bumper sticker or a mug. This organization was starting to look a little fishy. Paying in order to be recognized for “academic achievement,” and to get scholarships? That seemed pretty off.
Digging Deeper
I decided to give it a quick Google search to see what people were saying about the organization. About 10 links popped up, all of them with some variation of “Is the National Society for High School Scholars a Scam?”
I looked at the organization’s website, where they listed criteria for membership. Wait a second. After the list of criteria, there was an asterisk: “Note: receiving an invitation may not verify actually meeting these criteria.” So if they are sending out invitations to people who don’t meet the criteria, how could this be a real honor society? The website said you needed a PSAT score of 200 to become a member. My score was 189. The Internet consensus? Yes, this was, in fact, a kind of scam.
Was I really that gullible to be fooled by a letter clearly trying to play to the fragile egos of teenagers? Yes-but I wasn’t the only one. When I talked to my friends, it turned out some of them had received the same letter and were thinking about sending in the $60.
Easy to Be Duped
The fact that this organization had gotten hold of my personal contact information irked me, especially because they may have gotten my information from when I took the PSAT the previous fall. When I took the PSAT, I checked off the little box that allowed the College Board to give my information to colleges. Throughout the year, I’d been getting glossy looking letters in the mail from less-than-stellar colleges, but I hadn’t gotten anything so sketchy (asking for money) in the mail.
I wondered how many kids who get this letter actually send their money in because the letter makes admission sound so prestigious and selective. I myself was almost enticed by how complimentary the letter was, and how great the scholarship opportunities the organization appeared to offer were.
The only thing I could really do was be on the lookout for these kinds of scams in the future. There are a lot of other scholarship scams out there geared toward college-bound kids eager to get help with the ever-increasing cost of tuition.

Don’t Be Fooled
While doing my Internet research, I came upon a lot of advice to consider when trying to avoid scams. The College Board’s website had some good tips on what to look out for when applying for college scholarships, including a list of the typical signs that something is a scam:
“Exclusive Information” on Scholarships: If a scholarship service says it can offer information that can’t be found anywhere else, it is probably a scam. Most college scholarships and grants come from the government and from colleges themselves, so they wouldn’t be secret. And scholarships from private organizations are also publicized-they want to get the word out in order to get the most qualified candidates.
No Work-Free Money for College: If a service says it will do all the work for you, it probably is a scam. Most scholarship sponsors want to see an essay or letter written by the student who might be given the scholarship.
Scholarship Guaranteed: No service can guarantee students a scholarship, but’money-back guarantees’ are often a big selling point for these types of scams. Every real college scholarship will have some kind of criteria, so the service can’t promise everyone a scholarship.
You’ve Been Selected: This is the type of scam that I got in the mail. If you receive information that you didn’t request, you should investigate it like I did.
Application Fees: You shouldn’t have to pay money to apply for a scholarship.
Advance Fee Loans: Be wary of offers for a low-interest loan that require you to pay an upfront fee before the loan is approved or disbursed.
“Free Seminar” or Candidate Interview: Another glorified sales pitch.
Where to Get Real Information: If you’re looking for a scholarship, check out the financial aid pages for the colleges you’re applying to (often under the “Admissions” tab on a school’s website), or talk to your college counselor. Also check out ScholarshipHelp.org . They provide evaluations of online resources.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.