Rotisserie Leagues: You Too Can Own Your Own Team

The Knicks crash the boards. Oakley pulls it down. The give to Smith. The long outlet to Starks. He’s hammered by Maxwell but still gets the shot off. Yes! And it counts!
“Who has Starks?” I ask my friend Jon.
“I don’t know,” he replies. “He’s been traded too many times to count.”
Has John Starks been traded by the Knicks? No, he has been traded by the members of my rotisserie basketball league.
In a rotisserie league, members create fantasy teams and act as owner, general manager and coach. Each participant tracks the progress of his team members through newspapers and television, and compares their statistics to those of the players on the other teams. The owner whose team performs the best wins a boost to his ego, the respect of his peers, and maybe even a couple of dollars.
I first started participating in a rotisserie basketball league during the 1992-93 NBA season. A few of my friends and I had heard of such leagues and had seen them advertised in newspapers so we decided to start our own. We started by setting the rules.
Making Your Own Rules
Each of the seven teams would have 20 players. The season would be divided into three week periods. After two weeks, a roster of four guards, four forwards, two centers, and two players of any position had to be submitted to someone who we designated as the collector of rosters. After three weeks, the total points, rebounds, assists, steals, and blocks are counted. The top team in each of the five categories receives seven points, the second team six points, and so on, until the last team, which receives one point.
After the rules were clear, we got together and had a player draft. Each team was given imaginary money-$250-with which to bid on players. For example, I called out, “Scottie Pippen for one dollar,” and he was auctioned off to the highest bidder. I eventually got Pippen for $34, which is very low for a player of his caliber. I also got, for example, John Stockton for $42 and Dikembe Mutombo for $20. The total amount paid for any 12 players cannot exceed $250.
After each team had filled its roster with four forwards, four guards, two centers, and two other players, there was a reserve draft. Each owner drew from a hat to determine draft order and we went around in a circle picking up any players who had not been taken until we each had 20 players. You really have to know the players for the reserve draft because that’s when the Tyrone Corbins and the Willie Andersons of the league get picked.
Picking the Unknowns
After the draft, trading season began, and those with a true knowledge of the game were quickly separated from the pretenders. I mindlessly traded Mutombo and Stockton for Pervis Ellison, Glen Rice, Michael Adams, and Dale Ellis. In the beginning, none of us realized that there was a big difference between a player being valuable in a rotisserie league and a player being valuable in real life. But there is.
For example, Reggie Miller is by far the highest scorer on the Indiana Pacers. Few would argue that, in real life, he is the team’s best player. Anyone who knows anything about rotisserie basketball, however, would rather have Dale Davis, his shot-blocking, rebounding, teammate. Points come a dime a dozen in the NBA but it’s hard to find a good shot-blocking forward.
In fact, one block is worth more than one steal is worth more than one assist is worth more than one rebound is worth more than one point. If Reggie Miller scores 20 in a game, with three rebounds, two assists, one steal, and no blocks, he is worth 43 points for that game. If Davis scores 10, with 10 rebounds, no assists, no steals, and two blocks, he gets 54 points. So, Davis is on average worth more than Miller even though Miller scores twice as many points. If you’re still not following, you’ll just have to take my word for it.
I used this statistical system to guide me in trades. My blockbuster deal of the year, the one that sealed my victory that season, was a trade of David Robinson and Larry Johnson for Charles Barkley and Dikembe Mutombo (again). That would be a terrible trade in real life but my system showed me that Larry Johnson was virtually worthless as a rotisserie player because he gets no steals and no blocks. Plus, the age of a player is not much of a factor in a rotisserie league.
Baseball Season
Unfortunately for me, we weren’t playing for money that year. We did play for money this year but I came in fifth place. I had a bad draft because I rested my hopes on rookies Toni Kukoc, Bobby Hurley, and J.R. Rider turning into a ’90s version of Magic, Michael, and Larry. The money wasn’t a big deal though because the stakes were so low.
Luckily, I have a pretty good lead in my baseball rotisserie league, which is an eight-team league with a $160 pool. First place gets $100, second place gets $40, and third place gets $20 at the end of the year.
Baseball rotisserie involves the same concept as basketball rotisserie but has a 40-player roster and different categories. In baseball, we tally batting average, runs, runs batted in, homers, and steals for hitters; and wins, earned run average, saves, strikeouts, and baserunners per inning for pitchers. There are agencies that will keep stats for you but their services cost money that only professional leagues can afford to pay.
Playing With the Big Boys
The stakes are much higher, but it’s also much harder to win in these professional leagues. Many of them have weekly payoffs of several thousand dollars but they also have several thousand members. I don’t do it because there are professionals out there who devote every hour of every day to rotisserie leagues. They read minor league reports on players who they know will not be in the big leagues for four or five years. They not only know the name of every player’s dog but they know what kind of dog food it eats. I’m not going to waste my money trying to compete with that. It’s much more fun and much easier to win among friends.
Even in as small a league as mine, however, the successful baseball owner must watch Baseball Tonight every night on ESPN and read Baseball Weekly every week. To be successful in basketball, an owner reads newspapers and watches ESPN Sportscenter once, often twice, a night. In either sport, most of the owners watch at least one game every night, and often watch more. Any rotisserie league member, if he or she is to be successful, must have tremendous dedication to the game.
A Box Score Fiend
But one drawback is that I often find myself searching through the paper to see how many stolen bases Roberto Alomar had last night and not even caring who won the game. Whenever I see that a rotisserie league is diminishing my love for the game, I step back and ignore box scores for a couple of days. I have to constantly remind myself to keep the league in perspective.
A good rotisserie league has everything you find in a real league. In the draft it has a mock salary cap. In the season it has blockbuster deals and even a system of free agency. In the outcome, it has the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat.
It can get boring too, as it was for me when my team was in sixth place, and slumping badly with no hope for improvement. I stopped caring so much about box scores and just kind of haphazardly handed in a roster, with no regard for whether it was the best possible roster I could hand in.
Winning Is a Rush
If you’re luckier than I was that year, a rotisserie league will give you a tremendous rush. You’ll be watching the final game of the baseball season. Barry Bonds, your best player, will be facing Greg Maddux, the ace of the team with whom you are tied for first. The bases will be loaded with two outs in the bottom of the ninth. The Braves will have a three run lead in a game that both teams must win in order to get a spot in the playoffs. The count will be full. You will listen to Braves announcer Skip Caray make the call on TBS:
“The payoff to Bonds…And it’s a long drive deep to right field. Justice goes back. He’s looking up and that ball is gone! The Giants have won the game, five to four, I don’t believe what I just saw!”
The Giants will be in the playoffs but that will be secondary. You will have won your baseball rotisserie league.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.