Last year, the New York State Board of Regents began enforcing new standards and requirements to graduate from high school. During the 1999-2000 school year, students had to pass a newly created two-day English Regents exam to graduate.
Over the next four to five years, the Board will phase in mandatory Regents exams in math, biology, American government and history and global studies. Students who don’t pass all five won’t graduate.
There are 28 city schools, however, that are fighting Regents requirements. They are the so-called alternative schools, which include places like the Institute for Collaborative Education (I.C.E.), where I graduated from this year.
Learning Through Portfolios
Even though these schools are part of the New York City Board of Education, their requirements are different. At City-As-School, for instance, students learn new skills by doing work internships two to four days a week, and then write about what they’re learning.
And, instead of tests, many alternative schools use portfolios to judge students. Portfolios are samples of a student’s best work from each of their years in high school. These samples are usually things like research papers and projects.
A sample from my portfolio, for example, is a 15-page thesis I wrote in my junior year about how rock and roll affected society from the 1950s through the ’70s. The idea behind portfolios is that in-depth research and writing helps students improve their analytical abilities better than tests can.
I Like my Alternative
I feel that having to go through the portfolio process helped give me the skills I need for those evil 20-page essays I’m writing in college. I want to be judged for my writing skills, not my test-taking abilities.
If my school were a Regents school, though, I probably wouldn’t have been able to have that experience. The three months I spent on theses would have been used to prep for Regents exams.
My timing was good. I didn’t have to take Regents exams to graduate. In 1995, alternative schools were granted a five-year exemption from the Regents.
Commissioner Requires Regents
But in January 2000 Commissioner Richard P. Mills of the New York State Department of Education ruled that all alternative high schools would have to phase in the Regents exams.
According to The New York Times, Mills said that alternative schools had failed to show that portfolio reviews were as good as the Regents in terms of measuring student work. Mills gave alternative schools another Regents-free year with the understanding that they would soon have to prepare for the Regents.
To fight Mills’ declaration of Regents exams for all, the alternative schools formed the New York Performance Standards Consortium.
Ann Cook, co-director of the Urban Academy and one of the leaders of the Consortium, defended the educational quality of the alternative schools.
“Our curriculum prepares students to write research papers, defend original science experiments and solve sophisticated mathematical problems,” she said.
Two Schools Sue
Two schools in the Consortium, International HS and Middle College HS, sued the New York State Department of Education and took the case to the State Supreme Court, saying that alternative schools should continue to be exempt from required Regents exams.
In June, the New York Supreme Court upheld Mills’ decision to go ahead with the Regents, but the two schools appealed. However, in early November, the Appellate division also agreed with Mills’ decision.
This might appear to be the end of the argument: Students at alternative schools will have to take Regents exams to graduate. But things aren’t settled yet. Some people are questioning what schools are affected by the ruling.
According to The New York Times, Cook said that since only the two schools went to court, the court decision would only affect those two schools and not the other alternative schools.
But Tom Dunn, a spokesperson for the New York State Department of Education, told NYC that the ruling upholds the decision that the Regents requirements apply to all schools.
Can’t Get Away From the Classroom
Adding Regents requirements to alternative schools forces them to change their curriculums. Schools would have to spend time teaching how to take the Regents, and kids would have to deal with more traditional classroom structures.
“These kids are trying to get away from being in a class with 30-35 kidsâwe try to avoid that kind of thing. That’s why kids come here,” said Michelle Blatt, City-As’ principal. “A Regents curriculum needs everyone in-house, 8-3. There would be fewer chances for internships. We want to make kids care about trying things.”
Blatt feels that the Board is going about making improvements the wrong way. “Sure, some students graduate with a diploma that means less than it should, but the emphasis should be placed on interaction between people and development of an individual’s skills,” she said.
She believes that impersonal tests like the Regents exams take away students’ motivation to learn. “I agree that there should be a ‘measuring stick’ to determine if students can graduate, but it’s not the Regents,” she said.
Higher Expectations Are Fairer
“Everyone should be able to read and write,” said Blatt. “They should know how to think critically, or know the scientific method. They need to know the basics and make standards around that.” She recommends interactive activities for learning, like projects and discussions.
Others feel that the Regents is the right tool to measure student performance. New York City School Chancellor Harold Levy supports the new Regents standards. According to a budget request statement from his office, these standards prepare students for a workplace that “rewards the ability to frame a problem, to access, analyze and apply information, and to effectively communicate in both written and oral form.”
And Antonia Cortese, the vice president of the New York State United Teachers, has said that having high expectations for all young people is more fair to them because it prepares them for the future and respects their abilities. She believes that students will rise to the challenge of new, more difficult standards.
‘More Freedom to Learn’
But supporters of alternative schools argue that students have different learning styles, so having a single standard may
not be best for them. Jane Hirschmann, chair of the Parents Coalition for High Standards and Performance-Based Assessments, said the Regents requirement is unfair to students.
“It’s like testing an experimental drug. Sure, a lot of kids will probably fail miserably at first, but they’ll just be casualties of the system,” she said. “But surely everyone else will be fine. That’s ridiculous.”
Shawanda Davis, 19, a student at City-As, said the Regents would also change City-As’ image, and the images of similar schools, making people reconsider enrolling there.
She prefers the learning environment at her school.
“We have more freedom to learn what we want, and everyone’s treated like an adult,” she said. “You’re not stuck in one place for six hours.”
‘Education Is for Educating’
As the fight continues, others are still looking for more options. Peter Steinberg, of the Performance Standards Consortium, said his organization has formed a review board offering to do a five-year study on how students perform in regular and alternative schools.
“We’re confident that the study will prove portfolios are the better assessment tool,” he said. Steinberg added that portfolio schools follow more of the state standards than the Regents, and the study would provide enough evidence to leave alternative schools in peace.
Meanwhile, Dunn said that students who don’t wish to take the Regents can still graduate by taking certain Advanced Placement exams or the SAT II.
But some students don’t want their graduation to be based on a test. Ariel Levine, a 17-year-old City-As student, prefers her school’s system. “A pass/fail system like ours makes people know they need to workâRegular grades can be demoralizing,” she said. “Think of how ashamed students are by getting Ds and 70s,” she said.
“[The Board of Regents] needs to realize education is for educating, not testing. We need to learn for our sakes, not for grades.”
Regents Wars
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.