Protesting My Yearbook Attire

One uneventful Saturday in October I was sorting through the mail on the kitchen table when I noticed a glossy postcard from a local photo studio. They were coming to my school to take yearbook photos. Immediately, I had a sinking feeling. I thought back to my older sister’s high school yearbook in which all of the students donned gender-specific attire: a tuxedo for males and a drape for females.
It bothered me that students were being forced into traditional gender roles of male and female. I was born female, and I proudly identify as such to this day. But ever since I was a little girl, I hated wearing dresses, or anything else markedly feminine by societal standards. It felt dishonest, and it made me feel insecure. Today I choose my clothes based on what makes me feel comfortable and confident. I usually wear Levi’s, T-shirts and Doc Martens. But I also love getting manicures, and even paint my nails glittery pink sometimes.
I attend a New York City public high school that is diverse in all respects. There are students of various races, ethnicities, religions, sexual orientations-and student organizations dedicated to these specific groups. We also have “Respect For All Week,” when the diversity of the student body is celebrated and students are encouraged to appreciate their differences. A yearbook that suggests there are only two categories of gender did not reflect my school’s diversity. I felt something needed to be done, but what?
Just Being Who I Am
In 2010, there was a high profile case regarding this very issue. Ceara Sturgis, a high school senior in Mississippi, was denied inclusion in her yearbook because her school district did not approve of a female student wearing a tuxedo for the photo. Like me, she considered succumbing to the drape, but she cried at the thought of having such an insincere photo forever serving as a defining representation of who she was. Not only was her picture omitted, but her name was as well, and this caused her a great deal of emotional grief. In an article by the Associated Press, Sturgis expressed that she was being punished for “just being who I am.”
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) sued Sturgis’s school district for discrimination and an agreement was reached. They have now done away with gender-specific yearbook attire in favor of the gender-neutral cap and gown.
The case highlights the fact that not every student fits neatly into one gender “box.” What about my friend Noah Delos Reyes who describes himself as a feminine man who is not gay? He wears makeup and feminine clothes that he says accentuate his body. He believes it should be OK to mix and match masculine and feminine. If a student finds both the tux and the drape to be too gender-defining, I think offering a gender-neutral option of cap and gown makes the most sense.
Girls Play With Trucks Too
When I was about 5, I remember watching television with my older sister when a Tonka commercial came on. I was familiar with Tonka; the brand had released a computer game I liked. But this commercial had only boys playing with the trucks and construction equipment. I asked my sister, “Is Tonka only for boys?” She quickly reassured me that girls could do anything that boys could do and vice versa.
That was an early turning point for me. I became aware of what I later learned was called gender binarism, the division of society into two distinct categories: things that are considered typically “male” and others, “female.” As I got older, I began to question this definition and why people had to be classified so rigidly into one category or the other.
Why couldn’t boys play with Easy-Bake Ovens and girls Tonka trucks? Why did parents dress baby girls in pink and boys in blue? Why were boys made of-according to the popular nursery rhyme-“slugs and snails and puppy-dogs’ tails,” and why are girls “sugar and spice and everything nice?”
In my 11th grade sociology class, I learned that gender binarism is created by some societies to organize and divide people. It was something that I had always known, but things became clearer when I took that class. But I don’t want to be placed in one of two groups. I am a unique individual. I define myself.
Not a Hypocrite
I will graduate in June, and a simple yearbook picture is supposed to be a commemoration of this rite of passage. I want my friends and teachers to remember me for who I am and who I always hope to be: compassionate, kind-hearted, persistent, and strong-willed all the same. I want this photo to be representative of who I really am, not just my official gender.
To me, the purpose of the photo is to trigger memories of the person I was in high school. I feel that I am defined by my ambitions. I want to bring about positive change in the world and to break down barriers imposed by society. Every day I want the words I say and the choices I make to be for the betterment of society. If I had that picture of myself taken in a drape, I might as well have had the words “sellout” printed across my forehead. I refuse to compromise my values for anything or anyone.
Instead, I decided to take a stand and be a voice for these often overlooked students: I was not going to have my photo taken or purchase my high school yearbook.
I sent an e-mail to the teacher responsible for coordinating the yearbook committee. “I decline to have my picture taken and included in the yearbook because students only have the choice of featuring the female drape and the male tuxedo photos.” I explained that I believed students should also have the option of submitting their cap and gown photos to the yearbook. “I hope you understand, and I truly hope that this issue is addressed in future years; I am certain that I do not stand alone in my opposition to the outdated gender-binary system.”
Starting the Conversation
In retrospect, I feel I should have done more to help bring about change. Sometimes I wish that I had demanded that a picture of me in gender-neutral attire be included in the yearbook.
Still, I am confident that graduation will open a door to even greater opportunities for me to advocate for change and equality in so many ways. Kids need to feel more comfortable and safe to express their true selves, especially during their formative teenage years when they may question various aspects of their identities.
I know the power that a single voice can have, which is why it is important that I use mine. Hopefully, this story will inspire other students to demand equality as well.

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.