Progress Report

Is the System Moving in the Right Direction?

Ever since Nixzmary Brown died in January, New York City’s media have been reporting constantly on whether the city’s foster care system, the Administration for Children’s Services (ACS), has been leaving children in dangerous homes. The number of abuse and neglect reports to the state hotline skyrocketed, and the number of kids coming into care also doubled, compared to this time last year.
I spoke to Andrew White, the director of the Center for New York City Affairs at the New School’s Milano Graduate Center, who explained why this case has had such a big impact on the system.
The media has focused on Nixzmary Brown because her case was dramatic-torture was involved, and the ongoing abuse was not caught by so many people. There were also very expressive police detectives who spoke to the press after finding the child’s body. Another factor may be that there were several days when there wasn’t much going on in the news. Also, even before this case, the New York Times had started to look at deaths of children known to ACS because a reporter at the Times wondered if the system had swung too far in the direction of leaving children at home.
The big fear among advocates has been that all of this press will lead to reversal of the positive reforms the New York City foster care system has made-that we’d fire the commissioner and go backwards instead of forwards.
That’s what happened in the mid-1990s, when one case changed the system completely. At the time, the system was a mess. Former Mayor Rudy Giuliani came in January of’94 and immediately began to cut funding for foster care. $200 million was cut, and 2,000 staff were let go. Then there were all kinds of systemic problems-case files that were not computerized, badly trained staff, low morale.
One Case Led to Panic
In late 1995 a child named Elisa Izquierdo was killed by her mother. Her case revealed all of the problems in the system, as reporters quickly found as they followed up on her death. Giuliani created ACS a few months after that, and the system set out to improve caseworkers’ training and pay, and to improve the foster care agencies.
ACS policy at that time was to remove kids if there was any doubt they were safe, and over the next three years the number of children entering care ranged from about 11,500 to 13,500 per year, a substantial increase from the previous years.
At the time, people believed that many children would be better off in foster care, and some were very lucky and found decent foster parents to stick with them or adopt them. But a lot of kids in care don’t get the long term support that they need. Some recent studies are showing that many children who went into care in the 1990s, no matter what city they were living in, have had hard times as adults. Many have ended up in homeless shelters or in jail.
Positive Reforms
Starting around 2002, ACS began to pay a lot more attention to the concerns of people in the field, like teens in foster care, biological parents, foster parents, and the community organizations that provide foster care and family support services. That led to other reforms, like the focus over the last year and a half on “permanency”-moving kids as quickly as possible back to their parents, to homes with kin, or into adoption, so they’re not in care for years and years.
The system also began to try to get Child Protective Services-the people at ACS who investigate families and decide whether to remove a child-to have investigators work in a different way-to be more engaged in figuring out the kind of help families need. That last change has a long way to go and could be put at risk by what’s happening right now.
We have to wait and see. we’re certainly seeing signs-right after Nixzmary’s death there was a big increase in reports, a big increase in the number of court cases filed, and a big increase in removals. But it’s too soon to know if it’s a panic, or if those kids needed to be put in care but weren’t yet because of a failure in the system.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.