Prevention, Not Detention

In January, Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced the merging of the Administration for Children’s Services (the city agency in charge of protecting children from abuse and neglect) with the Department of Juvenile Justice. This is promising because it means that instead of being sent to juvenile detention centers, teens who are arrested for nonviolent crimes and aren’t considered dangerous should be more likely to receive counseling and other services in their own communities as they await court appearances.
The mayor’s decision represents a changing attitude toward dealing with kids who break the law. In New York and nationally, more politicians are realizing that many existing juvenile prisons don’t help kids change their lives for the better.
As encouraging as this shift is, however, we also need to solve deeper problems in our society. Specifically, we need to change the circumstances that lead to a disproportionate number of arrests among youth of color.
End the Cycle
It’s no coincidence that the highest rates of youth arrest occur in the poorest parts of New York. These areas tend to have the worst school and housing systems, and fewer resources overall. Without good alternatives, youth are more likely to be sucked into gang activity, drugs, and crime.
The cycle continues when kids wind up incarcerated. Beyond the psychological damage incarceration can do, it also damages job prospects: Both employers and schools are often hesitant to extend opportunities to a young person recently released from prison. The obvious route for a youth without other opportunities is usually to fall back into crime.
It seems logical, therefore, to concentrate on providing better educational and recreational resources in neighborhoods most affected by juvenile crime, so young people don’t get started on the wrong path. The Youth Promise Act (YPA), introduced by Representative Bobby Scott of Virginia last year, is a big step in the right direction.
Our Communities, Our Kids
The YPA doesn’t call for any laws to be changed regarding the punishment of crime. Instead, it’s designed to fix the underlying problems of high-crime neighborhoods. It would provide funding for councils to be formed in communities with the highest rates of youth incarceration. Made up of representatives from schools, courts, social services, law enforcement, health care agencies, and community- and faith-based organizations, these councils would develop strategies for improving the lives of local youth.
This is a smart idea. Since every neighborhood is different, people within each neighborhood are best equipped to decide what strategies will help their kids. The YPA has great potential to reduce the number of youth in lockup.
Necessary Steps
Beyond simply supporting the Youth Promise Act, New York politicians should put it into action in our state. Especially, they should:
¥ Begin to target neighborhoods with the highest rates of youth in prison. According to the Citizens Crime Commission of New York City, 40% of the youth admitted to city detention facilities in 2008 came from just 15 of the city’s 59 community districts. Especially within these 15 communities-South Jamaica, Bedford-Stuyvesant, East Harlem, Tremont, and others-legislators should help residents develop plans to prevent crime and to help youth who have been incarcerated after they return home.
¥ Provide more funding for community alternatives to incarceration. Alternatives to prison can provide personal attention to help youth address deeper issues that drove them to crime in the first place-issues like substance abuse and mental health problems, which often go untreated in prison.
Additionally, alternatives to incarceration are much less expensive than prison. The estimated cost to incarcerate one child for a year is up to $200,000, but it usually costs only $9,000-$12,000 to send a child to an alternative-to-incarceration program.
¥ Reduce the burden on family courts. If you’re charged with a crime, you might have to wait in jail until your court date. Because family courts are overwhelmed, youth have to spend more time in detention waiting for their cases to be heard. New York City should create neighborhood-based juvenile courts to reduce overload in family court.
¥ Close juvenile prisons that are never full. Closing just one of these under-used facilities could save millions each year. Savings could be put into alternatives to incarceration, prevention programs, and programs that help youth leaving the juvenile justice system.
Whether you write letters to your congressional representatives urging support of the YPA or simply spread the word, the opportunities to get involved in this issue are boundless. If we’re lucky, this year that started with the mayor’s welcome announcement will usher in many effective reforms.
Ways to Get Involved
¥ The Center for Court Innovation is a nonprofit think tank that looks for new ways to reduce crime and improve the justice system. Their programs include:
¥ The Youth Justice Board, which brings young people together to study and propose solutions to public safety issues. For more info or to request an application to join, e-mail [email protected]
¥ Youth Courts: Five courts (in Red Hook, Greenpoint, Harlem, Staten Island, and Newark) help train local teens to serve as jurors, judges, and attorneys in cases involving their peers. To learn more, call the Center for Court Innovation at 212-397-3050 or e-mail
[email protected]
¥ Express your support for juvenile justice reform:
¥ To contact your state assembly member, go to assembly.state.ny.us/mem/ and type in your zip code. It will direct you to your representative’s website, where you’ll find contact details. To find your state senator, type in your zip code at nysenate.gov
¥ You can send an e-mail to your representative in Washington by visiting writerep.house.gov and entering your zip code and address.
-Chantel Morel

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.