One afternoon last spring, several members of the Hunter College HS baseball team were on their way back from a game. They all wanted to take the bus but most only had subway passes or no pass at all. Luckily for them, teammate Dave Stevens, 16, was able to come to the rescue. “I had four or five old passes, handed them out, even got Coach on the bus,” says Dave.
What Dave and his teammates did is quite common. During interviews with 12 students from seven schools around the city, I found that all had misused a pass at least once. And they knew many others who had done the same.
Students routinely use subway passes on buses and vice versa, use their passes after the 7 p.m. deadline, and flash passes from the wrong month or those issued to their classmates.
Just Flash It
Elphon Ospina, 16, of A. Philip Randolph HS says that kids he knows very often funnel subway passes through the station gates to waiting friends. “If you forget your pass, you just use somebody else’s,” he says.
But an even more common method in the subway is “flashing.” Students can get by an apathetic or inattentive token clerk or transit cop by quickly displaying either a bus or subway pass from a different month and disappearing into the crowd. “I go to a station where there’s a lot of kids and I flash it,” says Edwin Perez, 15, of Bushwick HS. “The token clerk doesn’t pay attention.”
Often the gate operators care so little that kids get through without any pass at all. “If people aren’t paying attention, you can hold up something that looks kind of similar,” says Alex Jonatowski, 17, of Hunter College HS. Alex claims that he once got by with a business card that happened to be the same color as the subway passes.
Such methods are less popular on buses, both because bus drivers are close enough to examine the pass and because it is nearly impossible to sneak onto a bus without catching the driver’s attention. Nonchalantly letting a stray finger cover the month or the type of pass is what seems to be in vogue. “It’s really easy to cover [the box that specifies the type of pass],” says Ben McAnaney of Regis HS. “You just flash it at them…They don’t look.”
Pass ‘Doctors’
Many students have resorted to more complex, premeditated approaches to “doctoring” bus and subway passes. Dave, who claims to have 30 or so older passes dating back to 1987, has been doctoring passes regularly for several years. He does it because it’s “a pain” to use his half-fare bus pass. “It’s much easier to get an older pass, cut it up, laminate it, and not have to pay for the rest of the month,” he says.
Jeff, 16, of Stuyvesant HS, makes use of his personal computer to help him doctor his pass. He prints out the words “High School Pupil” on the computer and carefully covers the words “Half-fare Pass.” “I have never paid the half-fare,” he says. “I think it’s a joke.”
Let the reader beware, however, that pass abuse does have its consequences. The official penalties, listed on a card that is handed out along with the pass, are confiscation of the “altered or misused” pass, and a fine of between $60 and $100.
I personally know of one student who was issued a summons by a transit cop for trying to go through a subway gate with a bus pass. Ben says that his guidance counselor has told horror stories of having to testify in court for kids who have misused passes. Most of the students I interviewed, however, had never heard of anyone being fined. “Usually they just take [the pass],” says Jeff. “I don’t think the bus drivers and token clerks care.”
The Ta Cracks Down
While pass abuse does not seem to carry much of an individual penalty, the abuse of passes has caused the Transit Authority to take action in other ways. Students with subway passes are now required to wait on line at the token booth before being let through, a policy that is unpopular with many students.
“With a [subway] pass, it’s like you have a token,” says Thomas (not his real name), 17, of Hunter College HS. “People who already have a token don’t have to wait on line.”
In addition to this rule, service gates are now opened electronically by token clerks rather than by the user, to reduce the problem of students sneaking through.
Also on the way (but not for several years), says Mary Ellen McGarry, manager of the Board of Education’s Bureau of Pupil Transportation, is a new type of pass with a magnetic strip that must be run through a sensor that will read whether or not it is valid and automatically let you through the turnstile. The new pass will have a limited number of “trips” on it, equal to twice the number of school days in a month. After the mandated number of trips has been used, the pass will stop working.
Isaac Esterman, 17, of Hunter College HS, doesn’t believe the new passes will be much of an obstacle. “Obviously it’ll cut down on cheating but there’s always been a way around it in the past and I’m sure there’ll be a way around it now,” he says.
Immoral? Or Just Illegal?
Most of the students I interviewed did not see anything wrong with misusing passes. “I’m not going to lose any sleep over it,” says Dave. Bob (not his real name), 17, of Hunter College HS agrees. “Just because you’re misusing a subway pass doesn’t mean you’re gonna become a criminal,” he says.
The Transit Authority disagrees. “Morally, it’s wrong,” says TA spokesman Termaine Garden. “If you know a pass is not valid, why would you attempt to use it?” He adds that students often become hostile when token clerks challenge the validity of the pass.
But in the minds of the students, pass misuse is like jay walking. The general sentiment is, “Sure it’s illegal, but it’s not hurting anybody, so why not?” Jamal Fisher, 14, of LaGuardia HS sees using tokens as a waste. “I have to get around and I’m not going to pay $1.25 for it,” he explains.
Thomas agrees. “I’m not trying to screw the Transit Authority,” he says. “I’m just trying to get home.”
Pass Abuse: Fare or Not?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.